Cooked or Raw ounces

ronde
ronde Posts: 29 Member
edited November 12 in Food and Nutrition
What weight is the most accurate when counting any type of meat calories. Before its cooked or after?

Replies

  • JulieDerda
    JulieDerda Posts: 163
    hmmm ..I always weighed it after I cooked it and people told me I should also BUT as I was looking for references before I told you what to do I found this website :: http://jcdfitness.com/2011/09/counting-calories-a-no-bs-guide/ and this says to weigh it before. So guess I Have been doing it wrong.. But I still have been losing weight (weighing the meat/poultry/fish after I cook it) Lost 18 lbs so far. ... Sorry guess I really dont know and am just as confused :( .. ( and will be following this post as well!)
  • Jan0707
    Jan0707 Posts: 18 Member
    I always do mine after.
  • thinmintme
    thinmintme Posts: 63 Member
    I would weigh after! Only makes sense to me: some of the blood, depending on how 'done' the meat is, will cook away. Fat, if present, fries away as well, for the most part.
    This just makes more sense than weighing before. >.>
  • thebigwindmill
    thebigwindmill Posts: 98 Member
    Most accurate: raw Edit: Thought I'd add most nutritional info's say a serving is "4 oz raw"
    Most convenient: cooked

    I personally weigh mine after as I cook from frozen, not raw. I doubt the calories are so substantially different that it really matters though. Unless you eat A LOT of meat a day.
  • Karmynzahringer
    Karmynzahringer Posts: 192 Member
    Before. If you have 4 oz of chicken before cooking it, and it is 3 oz after it is still the same amount of calories. It loses water when cooking, but the calories remain the same. I always used to weigh it cooked and couldn't figure out why I was not losing weight, and I think that had something to do with it. Especially with pork loin! It is half the weight when broiled and I was only counting half the calories I should have been!
  • junyr
    junyr Posts: 416 Member
    They're all but the same. When you're done cooking most of what gets cooked out is water, with a small portion being fat....... assuming we're talking something like boneless skinless chicken breast.

    With that being said I've only ever seen anything being weighed before cooking. I've never seen or read or heard of anyone weighing things post cooking.
  • karenCalandro
    karenCalandro Posts: 92
    I've always thought before. If im making hamburger patties I make the patties 4 oz a pc. That;s 16 oz, 1 lb of ground meat. I weigh it before so i can see what size patty i need instead of cooking all different sizes then cutting pieces off to make 4 oz
  • Karmynzahringer
    Karmynzahringer Posts: 192 Member
    I also know that state guidelines for schools tell them to weigh meat raw, so if they are required to offer a certain amount of oz for meat at school, that is the raw oz, not the cooked. And the calories would stay the same as well.
  • AdAstra47
    AdAstra47 Posts: 823 Member
    Depends on the circumstances. If I'm at a restaurant and estimating how much is on my plate, I'll use the "cooked" weight listing. If I'm entering it into a recipe, or cooking it myself, I'll usually weigh it before I start and use the "raw" entry. But say I'm cooking with 80/20 hamburger, and I drain off all the grease, I know that will change the nutrition info a bit so I'd use the "cooked, browned, drained" entry there.

    (This is the reason there are so many entries in this database!)
  • sun33082
    sun33082 Posts: 416 Member
    It depends on what entry you use. If you use "beef - raw" then you need to weigh it raw. If you use "beef - broiled" then you need to weigh it after your broil it. Below is a site I use a lot and I've noticed that some of them are in the MFP database. It's usually the ones that don't have an * by them (i.e. not added by users).

    http://nutritiondata.self.com/
  • ronde
    ronde Posts: 29 Member
    Depends on the circumstances. If I'm at a restaurant and estimating how much is on my plate, I'll use the "cooked" weight listing. If I'm entering it into a recipe, or cooking it myself, I'll usually weigh it before I start and use the "raw" entry. But say I'm cooking with 80/20 hamburger, and I drain off all the grease, I know that will change the nutrition info a bit so I'd use the "cooked, browned, drained" entry there.

    (This is the reason there are so many entries in this database!)

    Thank you! This was kind of my reasoning...making recipes. I guess I will just have to make little adjustments depending on the meat. 1oz plus or minus will affect my daily calorie and I'm trying to be accurate as possible and consistant. Thanks everyone for you input.
  • lax75
    lax75 Posts: 118 Member
    Similarly, are the weights for things like oranges and grapefruits or bananas before peeling or after? (Much tidier to weigh before <g>, and when I have them at work I don't have a scale there anyway.) Or when you weigh one apple, do you subtract something for the core when you log it? Probably doesn't make a lot of difference caloriewise but it also affects fiber, etc. I can do it either way, but I don't know what assumptions get used when the info goes into the database.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories