We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Do I eat back all these calories?

ginnyblank
ginnyblank Posts: 2
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
I will be starting marching band in a months time for two major reasons. One I love music and two I think it will be great excersise. Practice will be twice a week for four hours now if I add those minutes to my excersise. It gives me 1233 calories or something similar that would mean I would double my intake for the day. Should I really eat all those calories back?

Replies

  • nixirain
    nixirain Posts: 448 Member
    I would probably change your profile settings accordingly. What are you set to right now: sedentary, lightly active etc?
  • AlwaysSarah87
    AlwaysSarah87 Posts: 62
    I would probably change your profile settings accordingly. What are you set to right now: sedentary, lightly active etc?

    That is a good idea^

    Also I think just watch your NET and if you are at least at 1200 a day then you will be OK.

    Maybe also think about getting a HRM. MFP is pretty bad about giving away too many colories when putting in exercise.
  • Loko_Ino
    Loko_Ino Posts: 544 Member
    Depends on your metabolism..try a few weeks not eating and then eating..see how your weight goes.
  • weepingnicole
    weepingnicole Posts: 3
    I'm in colorguard and I'm not eating any calories on some days that we have practice. I just think of it as losing fat instead of calories.
  • yesthistime
    yesthistime Posts: 2,051 Member
    I would not trust MFP's calorie count (they tend to overestimate cardio calories, in my and many other MFPers' experiences) Can you you get a heart rate monitor with a chest strap before you begin marching band? Or adjust MFP's calorie count down to maybe 50-75% of what it calculates for the exercise?
  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,359 Member
    Personally I think this is where the MFP approach to number of calories is not always the best. Ideally you would want to spread those out a bit through the week rather than eat them all on one day. I know I switched over to eating a fixed amount of calories that include my expected exercise in them already. Then I don't have to eat more for the exercise. I have only been doing it for a short time, so I can't comment on how effective it is. I have more calories for the day than MFP gave me, and I should still lose about 1 pound a week.

    I used the tool here to calculate my maintenance calories for my goal weight, and took 500 off that. http://www.fat2fitradio.com/tools/bmr/

    If you are going to use MFP, I would increase your activity level up one and call this part of your normal activity. Then you only would need to add actual intentional exercise.
  • AngelikaLumiere
    AngelikaLumiere Posts: 862 Member
    It really depends upon your metabolism and how much extra body fat you have. For the first 6 months that I was loosing I did not eat any exercise calories back, but my body had so much extra to draw on I never got hungry and I lost weight. But after I got closer to normal, I go hungry when I exercised so I switched to eating my exercise calories back. I think you have to figure out where you are. If you have more than half your weight to loose, or only 10-20 pounds, it makes a difference.
  • krazyforyou
    krazyforyou Posts: 1,428 Member
    I always use my HRM to monitor calories burned. I agree with Seantaylor. Just try it for 2 weeks and see what your body tells you. You may have to increase calories just to keep up your energy.
  • Feathil
    Feathil Posts: 162 Member
    On Wednesdays I have to play sax for 4hrs 45 mins, which apparently gives me 962 calories? I don't think so. And I play minimum 2 hours a day other days, minimum 220 calories. Nope, I logged them once and realised it was way out of reason.

    Marching's a different story though, that's a lot more active. Try get a HRM for that, but I don't understand how MFP calculates music.
  • MommaFuhrer
    MommaFuhrer Posts: 214 Member
    ....or if you think MFP is over estimating your calories burned put that you are marching for 2 hours instead of 4 and then enjoy eating those extra! :)
This discussion has been closed.

Categories