We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Cheat Days: Fact or Fiction?

micmac327
micmac327 Posts: 128
edited November 2024 in Food and Nutrition
Hi Everyone,

I'v heard from many reliable fitness and weight loss experts that giving yourself one cheat day a week is key when it comes to losing weight. Some of their reasons:

- a cheat day allows you to indulge (within reason) on foods that you crave, allowing you to better stick with your diet
- a weekly "treat" makes you less likely to cheat during the week and motivates your efforts
- a cheat day confuses the body and prevents plateaus

I'm sure there are dozens of other reasons backing the Cheat Day theory.

I wanted to know what everyone else thinks of this and if you've have success in attaining your gials by giving yourself a weekly cheat.

Replies

  • bcunning
    bcunning Posts: 81 Member
    I have to say that having a cheat day once a week has seemed to help me a lot. I have been eating healthy and working out for about 6 months now, and have not plateaued yet. (keeping my fingers crossed). But , I do not go crazy with it, and just pig out for a whole day. I basically allow myself one or two cheat meals, and don't worry if I go over my calories for that day, as long as it is not too much.

    Things I noticed, when I first started changing my lifestyle like this, it helped a lot with the cravings, I had always eaten fast foods, and craved fatty, salty, high calorie foods and sodas.

    The longer I have gone now, the less I have those cravings, so it actually seems like I eat my cheat meals a little less often (it is more like once every other week now). And I have stopped drinking sodas altogether. So now I find that even my cheat meals are not so bad anymore, since I eat them in smaller portions than I used to as well.

    So I do recommend doing it, it has definitely helped me so far.
  • craignev
    craignev Posts: 1,247 Member
    I would go as far as to say I have a cheat 'day' but it do have a bit of a cheat meal with booze on the evening ater weight-in.

    It's more to preserve my sanity that anything else :drinker:
  • beskimoosh
    beskimoosh Posts: 375 Member
    Honestly?

    I love food. Cheat days let me have food without worrying about my calories, and have a glass of wine (or multiple glasses :p) without worrying about it. Keeps me sane and on track!

    Also, like someone else said, the longer I do this, the healthier cheat days get, with much smaller portions!
  • imkegoal
    imkegoal Posts: 156 Member
    My weigh in day is my cheat day and it Works for me! Yesterday I went 1500 Cals over and I weighed the Same today as yesterday. Either way, any weight you may gain on Your cheat day will come off within 1 or 2 days. it definitly makes the diet easier to keep up.
  • runnercheryl
    runnercheryl Posts: 1,314 Member
    I don't have cheat days, but I don't restrict what I eat at other times. If I want pizza, I have a bit. Works for me.
  • Sul3i
    Sul3i Posts: 553 Member
    I say everything in moderation... if we eat healthy most of the time little indulgants here n there don't hurt :-)
  • imkegoal
    imkegoal Posts: 156 Member
    Ps: as you may have gathered from my post: I still track on my cheat day. i tend not to go more than 600 Cals over my allowance on my cheat day. Which is generally less than wat I have stayed under in the days before weighin day, so it equals eachother out in the end.
  • DONNALEES
    DONNALEES Posts: 50 Member
    I have been on Jenny Craig since January 2nd. They don't allow for cheat days, I sure wish they did. I haven't cheated yet but have come very close in the past few days.
  • MogwaisGrandma
    MogwaisGrandma Posts: 195 Member
    I don't have specific cheat days but I do go over once in a while. Only been doing MFP for a month and I am hoping for my 10lb loss mark on Monday so it seems to be working for me.
  • kleighsamboer
    kleighsamboer Posts: 250
    I mean, honestly, didn't we all have enough "cheat" days? That is what made us fat! I allow myself organic 70% or higher dark chocolate IF my calories allow for it. I don't drink, smoke, rarely drink coffee and I eat a clean diet without processed foods. I had to drastically change my life. I just don't see how people can justify cheat days or weekends and gorge themselves on fast food and alcohol.
  • Lauraph
    Lauraph Posts: 79 Member
    When I first starting "dieting" to lose weight I weighed in on Friday morning and then Friday was my "free" day. I didn't have to count my calories and I could enjoy some of the things I had craved that week. It worked for me because it helped keep me sane and on track the whole week. As my health started improving and I changed my diet to mostly whole foods I no longer craved that food that I was saving up for Fridays. I just didn't want it anymore.

    The key for me was learning to eat for health and not just weight loss.
  • laurabini
    laurabini Posts: 257 Member
    I can't avoid a cheat dinner today: my aunt has made lasagne :love:

    Anyway I have a cheat meal once a week and sometimes before a workout I treat myself with chocolate, I think it's not too bad.
    As everyone says: everything with moderation :)
  • runnercheryl
    runnercheryl Posts: 1,314 Member
    I mean, honestly, didn't we all have enough "cheat" days? That is what made us fat! I allow myself organic 70% or higher dark chocolate IF my calories allow for it. I don't drink, smoke, rarely drink coffee and I eat a clean diet without processed foods. I had to drastically change my life. I just don't see how people can justify cheat days or weekends and gorge themselves on fast food and alcohol.

    Personally, I gained weight because EVERY day was a cheat day. Far more than a cheat day, actually.

    A bit of junk here and there, occasional days over calories, they're not the end of the world.
  • Bergiere
    Bergiere Posts: 39 Member
    I don't think it should be called a cheat day. Cheating implies you're doing something wrong, unless that appeals to the 'bad boy/girl' in you. :)
This discussion has been closed.

Categories