What do you count as exercise?
Replies
-
Intentional exercises only and activities that makes you sweat a lot.0
-
I'm the same way. I play outside with my kids pretty much every single day, sometimes for hours and I used to log it as walking or something, but it was too difficult to really calculate because sometimes I really chase them around and sometimes I kind of stand around and watch them play. I sort of felt like it was holding me back somewhat in my weight loss goals by trying to convince myself I was burning a lot of calories, when maybe I really wasn't. Now I only log true, intentional exercise and I feel like it's making a difference.
]0 -
Basically people that log, Cleaning, grocery shopping, walking to the bathroom as exercise are KIDDING themselves.
Exercise is above and beyond what normal daily life requires.
or we wouldn't be where we are now on MFP wanting to lose weight.
They may be some exceptions but i'm been very general here,0 -
I log cleaning and gardening as long as my heart rate goes up. Yesterday I hauled brush to the fire pit for about 45 mins and then raked out flower beds for another 45, I actually decided to do that instead of going to the gym. Cleaning I only count when it is the out of the ordinary stuff like moving furniture and washing all the windows. Everyday things like, working, grocery shopping, and laundry will never make it onto my exercise list.0
-
Only intentional exercise at the gym and on my mountain bike.0
-
I said earlier, I count cleaning, I don't count mundane things like dishes, or washing laundry. I count it if it tires me out, and I feel all sweaty and just pooped out afterwards. Like, last week, the daycare I work at had to close due to sickness. We all had to come in a scrub the joint from top to bottom, I counted that as 4 hours of "light, cleaning" cause It was a lot of work, it was actually 6.5 hours, but since, towards, the end I did a lot of sitting, I was realistic and skimmed some time off.
To each their own, I count this stuff because, before this year, I'd maybe get up and clean twice a year, I never folded up laundry, it sat next to my bed separate from the dirty laundry, I'd let trash pile up and then when the odor got too much, I'd take out sometimes 10-20 full bags at a time. I know it sounds gross. I'm getting better, last time I cleaned I only had to take out 4 bags of trash, It only takes about an hour to fold and hang up laundry, whereas before I would take 3-6 hours, cause I'm washing more often. I will admit, I'm a lazy slob! I'm changing that, so judge me all you want.0 -
I only count cleaning when I'm doing MAJOR cleaning. I don't count dishes, laundry, dusting etc. since I do those things every single day anyway.0
-
I mean, I burned 296 calories just cleaning yesterday, and that was more than a lot of people did when they counted their actual "exercise," so you see why I counted that. Because it's a LOT and I worked HARD.0
-
why would anyone log shopping as exercise? i guess if you are shopping for a complete set of dumbbells i'd understand.0
-
I mean, I burned 296 calories just cleaning yesterday, and that was more than a lot of people did when they counted their actual "exercise," so you see why I counted that. Because it's a LOT and I worked HARD.
how was that calculated? if it was by heart rate monitor thats one thing but id be skeptical if it was MFPs numbers. they are off.,0 -
I see my friends logging cleaning a lot, and I say if that works for them, then great!
Personally...I've cleaned my house and chased after children for years and have still been overweight despite doing those activities. Since they haven't helped me build muscle or lose fat in the past, I don't count them.0 -
I mean, I burned 296 calories just cleaning yesterday, and that was more than a lot of people did when they counted their actual "exercise," so you see why I counted that. Because it's a LOT and I worked HARD.
how was that calculated? if it was by heart rate monitor thats one thing but id be skeptical if it was MFPs numbers. they are off.,0 -
I'm the same as you- if it's intentional, I log it. Most of the time I don't count cleaning and stuff, unless it's really hardcore. Anything else I just consider as part of my day to day doings.0
-
I count intentional exercise, but if we spend a saturday doing spring yard work or fall cleanup, I would count that as very low impact aerobics (as I'm usually sweating). This is only a 5 or so times a year that I would add something extra like that. I will go and jump rope for 20 minutes for an extra latte though. lol0
-
I am a Stay-At-Home Mom, with a +1 1/2 year old at home, and my Husband works 2 jobs, the full time one being 12 hour shifts. So I do not have a lot of opportunity to get workouts in, between our 9 year old's school activities, and meals and naps. So, when I do housework I put everything into it. I vacuum every room, some rooms 2ce, and I really work hard when I do the dishes, scrubbing them. High dusting and dusting, etc. I do it all. That way, I have calories I can count that day, even if I was unable to get a nice brisk walk in.0
-
My pedometer tells me how many calories I burn (based on my height and weight), how many steps I took and the distance, and speed. So if I'm walking around the mall for hours, you bet I'm going to count that. Otherwise I only count workout DVD's and other intentional exercise. I don't bother counting anything else.0
-
I have a seditary job and my setting is seditary, so log my morning and evening intentional exercise. I do house cleaning and yard work, etc...on the weekends but I don't log that. Only once when my husband and I did really heavy yard work all day long, including trimming bushes, tilling the garden, hauling mulch to the garden I logged yard work. Then I logged only half he time I actually did the work. I eat most of my exercise calories back so I am pretty conservative on what I log.0
-
I think it depends on your level of fitness what your body considers exercise.
When I was on MFP a few years ago and was obese and sedentary I did log things like cleaning, shopping walking the dog etc. But because of my weight and poor fitness there was alot of effort involved in these tasks and they'd all increase my heart rate quite abit.
Now I'm 70lbs lighter, fit and with an active job where I walk 4-7 miles a day and what I've log has changed. I do not log any walking as my HRM suggests that this doesn't increase my heart rate that much or burn that many calories. I just set my profile to lightly active and then log my gym workouts, classes and DVD's.0 -
The first time I saw someone post cleaning as exercise I was so excited for a way to add more calories I can eat! My house has never been cleaner! I only log sweeping and mopping and deep cleaning. I usually don't eat those calories back, but I like to know they are there if I want them! = )0
-
I don't count the supermarket or shopping trips. Mostly I too count "intentional" exercise. I also count something like mowing the lawn. So far that's the only non-intentional exercise I've counted. If I happen to be at a mall and have some extra time, I may walk around for 10-20 minutes and count that. I try not to count anything where I feel I've moved at less than 3 mph.0
-
I only count intentional exercise that is in the fat burning zone. 65-85% of my threshold (or whatever it's called). If I do weights, then it doesn't even ask for you calories. But when I was lifting weights, I was staying in my 65-85%, so I thought those calories should count.
I know my heart rate goes up when carrying in groceries & stuff, but I don't count it. I'm a nanny & I walk to the park & stuff, but I don't count that either. I am set at like a medium activity level tho, so it's prob factored in already.
Yesterday I carried cases of beer from my car, thru the backyard, and up to the porch (for my boss, I don't drink) and also a case of glasses I picked up from a rental place. Def got my heart rate up, but did not have my heart rate watch on, and wasn't wearing a sports bra, so it didn't count :laugh:0 -
usually just intentional excercize but sometimes on the weekends I count my cooking and some cleaning..I cook and bake for the entire week alot of saturdays & sundays so it does add up!0
-
Personally I log intentional exercise only such as playing basketball or lifting weights. Even though my daily activity level is listed as sedentary, I do walk around the office a bit (and go for strolls outside too) and see that as part of the included calculations.
The way I see it, if I'm getting changed into some shorts and a t-shirt/tank/jersey that says to me I'm going to do some proper exercise.
The only exception to this is my walk home from the train station after work. It's a 2.5km walk that I try and do as fast as possible (normally 3.5-4.0mph while carrying either a laptop bag or my gym bag). I have a HRM attached as well and I can tell you, once I get home that work shirt is pretty damp.0 -
I have been counting exercise I do at the gym, or an outdoor walk, or exercise video as exercise...basically, anything I do as intentional exercise. Now that I have been here awhile, I do see others putting in cleaning, gardening, grocery shopping, even sitting at a desk all day as exercise. So where is the line on what is exercise? Things we do to break a sweat? - sports games, heavy cleaning or gardening, etc seem to be okay to me, but grocery shopping? What do you count as exercise?
I put in anything that is out of the ordinary to my day which for me is intentional exercise like my workout dvd's going for a long walk e.t.c
Cleaning e.t.c is something I do everyday and always have I don't see it as exercise as such0 -
I count intentional exercise, heavy duty cleaning, and long walks if its a decent pace.0
-
I do not count cleaning as exercise. However, today I did pull a lot of weeds (four bags worth!) and hauled heavy branches so I did consider that since it was really super taxing.0
-
I'm marked as sedentary lifestyle since I work a desk job and I don't own a car, so I count some things others probably shouldn't, like going out for groceries. For me, that's a two hour walking and weight lifting exercise, since I use a basket instead of a shopping cart in the store and when I'm walking, I book it! I don't, however, count the general walking/stair climbing I do en route to work everyday.
Also counted:deliberate exercise, even if it's just going out for a walk I wouldn't normally have done, geocaching, heavy gardening (like my spring rake and soil augment.) Also, housework that gets me sweating, which is the out of the ordinary stuff, generally.0 -
I put myself as sedentary...so I get the least calories. But at work I am sitting, however from the minute I get home I am not sitting still.Im stacking wood, straightening the house for 10 minutes, grooming horses.... If I have a no formal exercise day, I log some of my daily stuff to make myself see I AM doing SOMETHING but I am careful not to eat those calories back unless I 'have to'.0
-
Only intentional exercise for me, too. If it's something I did regularly and I was able to become and stay this big, it clearly isn't enough of a workout!0
-
I only log intentional exercise. I am set up as sedentary. I worked in the yard this morning for two hours trimming hedges, cutting down bushes, pruning and raking. I also bagged 5 bags of leaves and debris. And picked up two trash cans full of branches that I had trimmed. I won't be counting and of that.
I am headed to the gym in a few minutes and I will log whatever I burn when I am there.
It's my personal decision to not log anything that I have not done as intentional exercise. This is my lifestyle change and I will be cleaning house and doing yardwork for the rest of my life. I won't be using it as an excuse to eat more.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions