Wanted: Anti-Binging Buddy!!! :D
ParisArkw
Posts: 186
Okay. As far as my diet & exercise goes, I am REALLY happy with how I eat!
BUT 1-2 times a week I run into some stupid binge that undoes all the other good days of the week. I hardly lose weight. Sometimes I gain weight instead.
I thought it would be helpful to find someone to help me hold myself accountable - and I could do the same for someone else who is struggling, in return.
I want this to be something that we communicate about EVERY day! At the end of every single day, let us come online and be able to tell each other that we did not BINGE! I honestly feel like that would help me be more conscious about it.
It would also be the goal for us to say that we staid within our caloric range.
That's pretty much it. A checking-in buddy. My only absolute need is to be able to depend on you to check in once a day. It only needs to be one message, anytime in the evening, and we can chat more if we so wish. So if you're interested, hopefully you are in a remotely similar time zone as myself (I live on the west coast of the US. Please be within 3 hours.)
If a few of you are interested, we can make a group, so long as everyone is serious about checking in. I have such a hard time controlling these binges, I'm running out of ideas. =\
BUT 1-2 times a week I run into some stupid binge that undoes all the other good days of the week. I hardly lose weight. Sometimes I gain weight instead.
I thought it would be helpful to find someone to help me hold myself accountable - and I could do the same for someone else who is struggling, in return.
I want this to be something that we communicate about EVERY day! At the end of every single day, let us come online and be able to tell each other that we did not BINGE! I honestly feel like that would help me be more conscious about it.
It would also be the goal for us to say that we staid within our caloric range.
That's pretty much it. A checking-in buddy. My only absolute need is to be able to depend on you to check in once a day. It only needs to be one message, anytime in the evening, and we can chat more if we so wish. So if you're interested, hopefully you are in a remotely similar time zone as myself (I live on the west coast of the US. Please be within 3 hours.)
If a few of you are interested, we can make a group, so long as everyone is serious about checking in. I have such a hard time controlling these binges, I'm running out of ideas. =\
0
Replies
-
I'm in!!0
-
I'm taking off for the night, but will check back here later!0
-
I will! (:0
-
I can't promise I will always be able to chat (work, school etc.) but I am certianly interested in this and could really use the encouragment! It is something I struggle with. Feel free to add me.
0 -
just add and message me eveynight and i'll do the same0
-
Hey! I'm happy to see people that are interested! I will check in with everyone, and everyone can check in with me.
I have to go now, but I will add you all as friends when I get back! 0 -
I totally do the same thing! I would love to have someone that I could text, even. It's easy for me to ignore the internet when I've gone overboard or feel like I want to give up but if my phone is going off I can't ignore it! Would be like an AA sponsor for food hehe.0
-
So if you're happy with how you eat, then why the binging? Binging happens when people WANT more then they aren't getting in most cases.Okay. As far as my diet & exercise goes, I am REALLY happy with how I eat!
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
NOT TRUE. Your posts aggrivate me most of the time because you assume everyone is all alike.0
-
I'm in! I found out this weekend that I can't even cheat a little because I go out of control so I'm back to finding healthy alternatives and pre portioned items so I can't binge on junk... :ohwell:
Anyways I'm in Ohio so our time zones will be different but I'm willing to help whoever! So feel free to add me! :happy:0 -
Assuming you're speaking to me, please define what binging is. Then tell me why some who is "happy" with the way they are eating is experiencing episodes of it?NOT TRUE. Your posts aggrivate me most of the time because you assume everyone is all alike.
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
People May binge eat because they are pissed at their boyfriend, or sad because their mother died. It doesnt mean it is because they are UNHAPPY with what they have been eating.0
-
So then why not binge on vegetables? People will binge on foods that they DON'T normally have on a daily basis. That's why it's called binging.People May binge eat because they are pissed at their boyfriend, or sad because their mother died. It doesnt mean it is because they are UNHAPPY with what they have been eating.
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
"So if you're happy with how you eat, then why the binging? Binging happens when people WANT more then they aren't getting in most cases. "
@ ninerbuff -- Good point
Yes I agree with "binging happens when people want more than they are getting", but it's not necessarily food that they aren't getting enough of. Emotional issues pay a part in that too. We have to remember that we are ultimately responsible for what we receive from ourselves and from others. And that we are responsible for our own happiness in life.
"So then why not binge on vegetables? People will binge on foods that they DON'T normally have on a daily basis. That's why it's called binging."
Another good point. If a binge happened on veggies, it would still be a binge, but most people aren't trying to control their veggie intake. Although binging on veg would be infinitely healthier. It's a crazy cycle, you try to limit certain foods only to want them more especially in times when you feel things are out of control.0 -
If you have room for more, I'll do it! But I'm in the east coast of the US.
If you want, I can take those from the east coast to check in on and they can check in on me.Or we can create an anti-binge group and select partners.0 -
I too have binging episodes. I just added you. I live in FL, though different time zone.0
-
In! I'll add you. I also usually will binge 1-2 times per week while the other days are perfect. I'm hoping to stop this.0
-
I understand emotional eating and get it, but the OP had mentioned binging based on going out with friends and other events. Binging is either a "planned event" or "unplanned event". One that's planned probably has a back up plan to counter, the other is usually one that makes them feel "guilty" later for doing it. I would think that if someone was happy with the food they binged on, they wouldn't feel bad about it later. Binge foods are usually foods that are high calorie, high fat, high sugar, etc. and aren't part of person's standard day to day eating. This is usually why the guilty feeling later.@ ninerbuff -- Good point
Yes I agree with "binging happens when people want more than they are getting", but it's not necessarily food that they aren't getting enough of. Emotional issues pay a part in that too. We have to remember that we are ultimately responsible for what we receive from ourselves and from others. And that we are responsible for our own happiness in life.
One thing is for sure: people won't binge on something they don't want to eat. They binge on foods they really want to eat and don't have control over. In my experience, binging happens because the food that is chosen is food that is very restricted or has been omitted in the person's current dieting regimen and they cave in for it because they really really want it.Another good point. If a binge happened on veggies, it would still be a binge, but most people aren't trying to control their veggie intake. Although binging on veg would be infinitely healthier. It's a crazy cycle, you try to limit certain foods only to want them more especially in times when you feel things are out of control.
Like anything else, if something is part of your life on a daily basis, you'll tend not to miss it. You miss it when you don't get to be around it or have it except on occasion.
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
@ ninerbuff -- great points and I do feel that you get it!
I have lots of work on myself to do and eventually it will all come around. Accepting and talking about my feelings will make all the difference for me. I still journal my downfalls and keeping the journal is helping me see patterns.
(ON the bright side, I did exercise for 2 days in a row and am putting stickers on my calendar! )
And you are right about the restricting thing, if I tell myself I can't then I WANT. When I was preggo with our girl (2005), I kept seeing all those new smirnoff vodka cooler adds and wanted to rip that Yuri guy limb from limb. Moderation is the key for me.
You seem very centred but that isn't a surprise considering your experience!0 -
First things first, I'm in add me if you would like. I have a few friends. On here and they are all supper supportive. I always like to add more. I'm on my phone app quite a bit ( I might have a small addiction) I have a cheat day one a week, it's good for me.hope that I can help.
Now on to that whole if you're happy with your diet food you wouldn't binge conversation. If we ate healthy allthe time mostof us wouldn't be.counting calories. Fact is most peoples favorite things are not exactly good for you. I whole heartedly admit I love a good burger made with real beef and a side of French fries. Once in a while I will totally binge on one. It's not the easiest thing in the world to eat a salad at a restuant and look across the table and watch your friend have a juicy Berger and not have one. I totally get it. It dosent make someone bad or less than to splurge once in a while.0 -
I felt this was unnecessary and insensitive.
So if you're happy with how you eat, then why the binging? Binging happens when people WANT more then they aren't getting in most cases.Okay. As far as my diet & exercise goes, I am REALLY happy with how I eat!
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Why? It's addressing the issue at hand. It's not a personal attack, but a question of why the binging if everything is apparently right?
I felt this was unnecessary and insensitive.
So if you're happy with how you eat, then why the binging? Binging happens when people WANT more then they aren't getting in most cases.Okay. As far as my diet & exercise goes, I am REALLY happy with how I eat!
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
The point I'm making is that people DON'T have to cut out their favorites. That's what leads to binging. Restriction and omittance of foods doesn't really work unless that person is totally going to be committed to it. If there's any doubt at all, it makes much more sense to figure out a way to involve it in a diet someway, rather than wait for the time of weakness and totally give into it setting that person into a feeling of failure and guilt.First things first, I'm in add me if you would like. I have a few friends. On here and they are all supper supportive. I always like to add more. I'm on my phone app quite a bit ( I might have a small addiction) I have a cheat day one a week, it's good for me.hope that I can help.
Now on to that whole if you're happy with your diet food you wouldn't binge conversation. If we ate healthy allthe time mostof us wouldn't be.counting calories. Fact is most peoples favorite things are not exactly good for you. I whole heartedly admit I love a good burger made with real beef and a side of French fries. Once in a while I will totally binge on one. It's not the easiest thing in the world to eat a salad at a restuant and look across the table and watch your friend have a juicy Berger and not have one. I totally get it. It dosent make someone bad or less than to splurge once in a while.
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Hi. I have never replied to anything on here but I think it is time. Definately have an issue with the binging so I am in. Most of the time I eat well, healthy and not so carefully that I am starving but within my calories. I work out four times per week but don't lose weight. I believe it is because I allow myself to "cheat" once a week but it spills into the next day often times. Any support is helpful.0
-
Why? It's addressing the issue at hand. It's not a personal attack, but a question of why the binging if everything is apparently right?
I felt this was unnecessary and insensitive.
So if you're happy with how you eat, then why the binging? Binging happens when people WANT more then they aren't getting in most cases.Okay. As far as my diet & exercise goes, I am REALLY happy with how I eat!
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
I think it's because you put it so bluntly and I do agree...the way you asked that question was very insensitive. It's nice that you have all of your ducks in a row but some of us are on here because we're trying to get to that point. When I read your comment, I felt that you said it like "a know it all". If it was that black and white then people wouldn't be binging. If I was to follow your theory I would be so fat right now it's not even funny! I'm willing to bet money that if I was to eat garlic dip every day of my life there would still be days when I would still binge on it! Yes I love it that much!
I'm in the exact same boat as Paris and others on this forum...but my binging happens when I go to friends and drink (drinking gives me very bad munchies) then I just can't stop eating. This doesn't mean that I should have pizza and french fries everyday because I might binge on them on Friday....it means I need to learn how to control my binging which is exactly what we're all trying to do here.
Anyways...@Paris...I'll send you a friend request. I can use any support I can get :bigsmile: I may not be able to get with you everyday but I'm on here quite often.0 -
It's hard to emote tone of voice on the forums and if read as if it were an attack, it can be perceived that way. I wouldn't last long as a PT if I talked to clients with a tone that was condescending. It's not black and white and I never stated it was. My comment was "in most cases". There is no situation that fits everyone. However I did mention that people that do binge will absolutely do it with something they want..............I haven't met anyone yet that binged on foods they disliked. And yes you can still end up binging on food you may be eating now, but the likely hood for it to happen vs foods that are liked but omitted are likely less.I think it's because you put it so bluntly and I do agree...the way you asked that question was very insensitive. It's nice that you have all of your ducks in a row but some of us are on here because we're trying to get to that point. When I read your comment, I felt that you said it like "a know it all". If it was that black and white then people wouldn't be binging. If I was to follow your theory I would be so fat right now it's not even funny! I'm willing to bet money that if I was to eat garlic dip every day of my life there would still be days when I would still binge on it! Yes I love it that much!
I think we can all agree that binging is an issue that stems from a personal issue and that it should be addressed so that the behavior can be changed, but as the above study (and I'm sure there are more) indicates, restriction of foods that people like can be a trigger for a binge.The relationship between strict dieting and later binging may explain the high numbers of people who become trapped in a cycle of dieting and weight gain, often reaching higher and higher weights after each round of dieting and binging.
http://www.treatmentcenters.net/eating-disorders/
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions