If you are a 5'9 woman or taller....

I'm 5'10 and currently 148. Since i'm a cyclist that is preparing for a upcoming race, I would love to get down to 135 pounds.

5'10, currently at 240lbs and would LOVE to be back down to 190 with an ultimate goal of 170. If I stayed at 190 though, I'd have absolutely no problem with that; it still has me in the "overweight" category with my BMI but my doc says I have a lot of muscle (under the fat, lol) and, as we know, that is more dense than fat.

I'm 5"10" and I'm 158 now but my goal is to 150.

Oh god I feel like I'm completely underachieving right now! I'm 5'9" right now and my goal is 180 and then reassess. I can't imagine myself ever getting lower than 170 without looking like a skeleton. I'm very big-boned (seriously, I am! My skeleton is huge! LOL) and I think I'd look skeletal if I went lower than 170. So I'm going to play it by ear. I'll truly be thrilled if I get into a size 10 or 12 - I think that would look very healthy on my build. But I'll play it by ear. :-)

This is me exactly. I'd be thrilled to be 180!! I'd probably be a size 10.

I'm 5'10" and 143 lbs. While I'm thrilled.. I mean THRILLED!!!.. to be able to finally weigh less than 150, my goal is around 135. I've started strength training though, and since then the scale refuses to bugde... but in the end if I can say 145 and NOT have a handfull worth of belly fat then I'll be the happiest woman alive.

5'9" and aiming for 150 ... I've been down to 145, but it was hard to maintain (& below was too low for me in the past). For me, it is less about a number and more about how I feel!

I'm 5'10" with an athletic build and weigh 152 and I'm planning on staying here. I wear a 4 or a 6 - mostly a 6.

It's info like this that is so fascinating to me! Years ago, when I was doing triathlons, I weighed 150 or so, and am 5'11". Never, ever got below a size 12, though! Occasionally squeezed into a size 10. It's a real head scratcher... but is good info for the OP to have.

Anyway, to answer the OP, I'm 5'11" and have felt/ looked comfortable at 150-165. I'm hoping to end up in that range again.

I know what you mean, I used to fit size 10 pants (US size 6) but have never got below a 14 (or 10) in the top. I'm guessing it is because I have broad shoulders and narrow hips?!? Also I sometimes had to go up a size in pants to get the legs long enough. Clothing sizes are weird!

"need a sandwich" :laugh: There is a big range of healthy weights and everyone carries their weight very differently. When you throw in muscle mass things get even more confusing. There are a couple of measurements that you can take to tell if you are on the right track.

Supposedly your wrist size can give you a clue to your frame size. Anyone else heard this? You wrap your thumb and your middle finger around your wrist. If the tips meet, you have a medium sized frame and should aim for the middle of the weight range. Middle finger falls below thumb tip for small frame sizes, etc. Not sure about that but I do know another very important measurement is your waist size. Supposedly this number can predict your heart health.

I am 5'10" and I have weighed everything from 145 (wedding day 18 years ago) to 190 (pregnant 11 years ago). I am very active so even when the scale has a high number I always feel like I look good.:laugh: I think this is where being taller is awesome. It feels like we can get away with weighing more somehow...

Even with using wrist size, it still is a very poor gauge of frame size. Based on my wrist size I have a small frame. But based on my actaul hips, because I am 5'6 and even when i was an athlete and under or around 100 lbs with under 10% body fat my hips were STILL 36 inches. So not remotely a small body frame. Better to just look at fat mass vs. fat free mass.

Hip size is different from waist size. It is our "waist" size that is a good indication of our heart health. The apple shape ( large waist ) is more at risk for heart disease than the pear shape ( large hips and thighs ).

I'm just over 5'9" and my skinny is 175-180lbs or that was my skinny weight. I'm aiming for 160lbs this time but if it get to lookin like I need a sandwich I'll stop.

I'm 5'10. I started at 270 and 20W. I'm 231 now and a regular 18. A 12 would be ideal for me, which would put me at about 180, I guess?

I'm 5'10" and currently around 160. My goal is to get between 145-150. Anyone who has lost weight--about how long did it take you? I know that everyone's different, but I'd like to plan this out for myself. I understand losing about a pound a week is good?

I am 5'10" and weigh 176 about size 10 - 12. Pre cancer diagnosis I was 143. Who would have thought you gain so much during chemo!! Hope to get down into the 150's and will re-evaluate then. At least I am still here....just want to be a healthy weight.

I am 5"9....I started out at 380 pounds and now weigh 198 pounds. With so much weight loss I have excess skin. (Estimated at a Dexa Scan about 5 kilos/11 pounds of skin)...it was recommended a ideal weight for me would be around 79-81 kilos/180 pounds. But I am mostly going to base it on my body fat %. Currently its 27.6% and my aim is 20-22%.

I am 5'9" and currently weigh 207 lbs. In 2012 I weighed my heaviest at 265 lbs. I have worked hard to get close to 200 lbs (which was my original weight loss goal) however; I am aiming for 165-170 lbs (which is what my doctor's consider healthy weight for someone of my stature).

I have very wide hips and a large rib cage which actually makes weight loss very difficult. I tend to carry weight in my upper body more than my lower now (I attribute that to my cardio regimen). So I have refocused my exercise on upper body techniques and I will start swimming this week (I live in Arizona, swimming is not only fun - it helps you survive the heat waves we get).

Most of my weight loss came from a reduction in sugary foods, reduction in eating at fast food/sit down restaurants and an increase in vegetable intake. I easily consume 4-6 servings of vegetables a day (typically through juicing or by blending spinach, cucumbers and carrots in my magic bullet). The increase in vegetables has helped with my fatigue and made me more alert at work.

I am actually really excited to be so close to my goal. I am hoping to reach 180-185 by the middle of August this year. (I am 28 years old and nearly ALL the women near my age in my family weigh 250-350lbs or more - it would be a great way to show them that weight doesn't need to control you)

Love reading this and seeing how everyone's 'comfortable/happy' weights are so different, just shows weight is not the be all and end all of health- we all have such different builds even at this height :-)

Just to add my two cents, I am 5'10.5" and currently weigh around 137lbs. I wear UK size 8 on top, 10 on bottom. I have a beanstalk build (read: long and narrow). This is the best I have looked in ages re. a flat stomach, but I don't want to lose any more weight. In fact I would be more than happy to gain lbs in muscle!