weight lifting and losing weight questions
Lost_Mermaid
Posts: 136
I am trying to figure out how I should proceed with my workouts. I'm primarily concerned with losing inches, and getting tighter and stronger. I definitely need to lose some weight though, maybe not as much as I initially thought, but still about 15- 20 lbs.
So I was wondering what I should do for exercise. Do I still need to focus on cardio until my weight drops, or is a calorie deficit and weight lifting enough? And if I need some cardio, how much is enough?
So I was wondering what I should do for exercise. Do I still need to focus on cardio until my weight drops, or is a calorie deficit and weight lifting enough? And if I need some cardio, how much is enough?
0
Replies
-
The thing about cardio and weight training is that they are a symbiotic relationship. One lives off the other. Weight will come off using cardio and cardio will give you more energy to do weights. Weights keep the weight off by building muscle mass. Do both.0
-
Calorie Deficit and weight lifting are perfect
That is actually all I am doing right now!
You don't need to do cardio, but if you like it go ahead :]
To be tight, fit, and strong weight lifting sure will deliver!0 -
The thing about cardio and weight training is that they are a symbiotic relationship. One lives off the other. Weight will come off using cardio and cardio will give you more energy to do weights. Weights keep the weight off by building muscle mass. Do both.
THIS!
And, if you're doing weight training, you can still be raising your heart rate and burning calories that way.
I've had a lot of success doing both.....I started out doing about half and half and lost 11lbs in 3 weeks. I've lost 26lbs so far, and I do cardio 5-6 days a week and strength 3-4 days a week.
Good luck! 0 -
If you only have that much to lose then I would have you stick more to heavy lifting and a small calorie deficit with minimum cardio. Body recomposition works if done correctly.
A.C.E. Certified Personal & Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
What kind of schedule do think is best to start with if I do both? I read that you have to let your muscles rest in between heavy lifting, like only lifting every other day, but if you do cardio on the days you dont lift, is that still resting your muscles?
sorry for all the questions lol0 -
The thing about cardio and weight training is that they are a symbiotic relationship. One lives off the other. Weight will come off using cardio and cardio will give you more energy to do weights. Weights keep the weight off by building muscle mass. Do both.
I do feel like I have more energy since I started exercising, which ha been mostly cardio so far.0 -
Calorie Deficit and weight lifting are perfect That is actually all I am doing right now!
You don't need to do cardio, but if you like it go ahead :]
To be tight, fit, and strong weight lifting sure will deliver!
This is what I'd really like to do cause I enjoy the weights, but cardio, not so much lol
maybe I'll do a little cardio for now though, like two days a week instead of six!0 -
Calorie Deficit and weight lifting are perfect That is actually all I am doing right now!
You don't need to do cardio, but if you like it go ahead :]
To be tight, fit, and strong weight lifting sure will deliver!
This is what I'd really like to do cause I enjoy the weights, but cardio, not so much lol
maybe I'll do a little cardio for now though, like two days a week instead of six!
Sounds perfect! Do some cardio on your lifting off days for example Make sure you find something you like! I'm not so much in to cardio right now, but I love zumba, kick boxing, and play rugby. Something fun 0 -
What kind of schedule do think is best to start with if I do both? I read that you have to let your muscles rest in between heavy lifting, like only lifting every other day, but if you do cardio on the days you dont lift, is that still resting your muscles?
sorry for all the questions lol
Measuring tape works the best I take measurements once every month, sometimes 2 weeks. Scale can be a lair xD So don't let it discourage you. Water weight does crazy things
Yup cardio on off days still rests muscles, and every other day is perfect. I lift 3 days a week, and give myself one day of off exercise completely. Do you have a routine?0 -
Definitely find a cardio you enjoy. I discovered I just can't do machines, love kickboxing, Taebo, Zumba and BodyPump classes instead!0
-
What kind of schedule do think is best to start with if I do both? I read that you have to let your muscles rest in between heavy lifting, like only lifting every other day, but if you do cardio on the days you dont lift, is that still resting your muscles?
sorry for all the questions lol
Measuring tape works the best I take measurements once every month, sometimes 2 weeks. Scale can be a lair xD So don't let it discourage you. Water weight does crazy things
Yup cardio on off days still rests muscles, and every other day is perfect. I lift 3 days a week, and give myself one day of off exercise completely. Do you have a routine?
I think what you do is a good idea, with lifting 3 days and having one day off completely.
I've been doing some research on starting strength training and trying to come up with what exactly I should be doing as far as exercises. If you have some advice on that I would definitely love to hear it
I did cardio/ circuit training today, so I want to start in on lifting tomorrow!0 -
Definitely find a cardio you enjoy. I discovered I just can't do machines, love kickboxing, Taebo, Zumba and BodyPump classes instead!
I think I'll have to try this zumba...sounds fun!0 -
I would highly suggest Starting Strength by Mark Rippetoe :]
http://startingstrength.wikia.com/wiki/The_Starting_Strength_Novice/Beginner_Programs
Can't go wrong :] I base my routine around this one. Have gained a lot of strength! 185 pound squat and 225 pound dead lift :]0 -
Three times a week is good for weights for you IMO, with big compounds. What I've suggested below includes a push and a pull for your upper body, and a push and a pull for your lower body.
Week one - ABA
Week two - BAB
A
Deadlifts
Front Squats
Pull ups (assisted if you need)
Bench Press
B
Squats
Good mornings
Barbell BOR
Standing OHP
On Tuesday and Thurs you could do some core and cardio but, as said, you don't need cardio. For fat loss, in order of importance:
1. Diet
2. Weights
3. HIIT
Steady state cardio is not great for fat loss - you will lose as much or more muscle than fat if that's all you do.0 -
I would highly suggest Starting Strength by Mark Rippetoe :]
http://startingstrength.wikia.com/wiki/The_Starting_Strength_Novice/Beginner_Programs
Can't go wrong :] I base my routine around this one. Have gained a lot of strength! 185 pound squat and 225 pound dead lift :]
Starting strength is a decent program
Good lifts0 -
I would highly suggest Starting Strength by Mark Rippetoe :]
http://startingstrength.wikia.com/wiki/The_Starting_Strength_Novice/Beginner_Programs
Can't go wrong :] I base my routine around this one. Have gained a lot of strength! 185 pound squat and 225 pound dead lift :]
Wow, you are amazing!!
I will be checking that out first thing in the morning, thanks for the link 0 -
Three times a week is good for weights for you IMO, with big compounds. What I've suggested below includes a push and a pull for your upper body, and a push and a pull for your lower body.
Week one - ABA
Week two - BAB
A
Deadlifts
Front Squats
Pull ups (assisted if you need)
Bench Press
B
Squats
Good mornings
Barbell BOR
Standing OHP
On Tuesday and Thurs you could do some core and cardio but, as said, you don't need cardio. For fat loss, in order of importance:
1. Diet
2. Weights
3. HIIT
Steady state cardio is not great for fat loss - you will lose as much or more muscle than fat if that's all you do.
Thanks This looks great!
I know what most of these are but I need to look up a couple lol0 -
Calorie Deficit and weight lifting are perfect That is actually all I am doing right now!
You don't need to do cardio, but if you like it go ahead :]
To be tight, fit, and strong weight lifting sure will deliver!
This is what I'd really like to do cause I enjoy the weights, but cardio, not so much lol
maybe I'll do a little cardio for now though, like two days a week instead of six!
That is exactly what I do. I do 4 days of weight training (2 days of lifting heavy, 5-6 reps each exercise and 2 days of moderately heavy, 8-10 reps per exercise focusing on compound movements like squats, deads, rows, bench with a few iso movements to finish it off) and 2 days of cardio a week. I never do weights and cardio on the same days either. My weight has dropped about 12 pounds since Thanksgiving, but even when the weight does not drop, the inches surely do!
I would never tell someone to not do cardio, but I think it is overrated for weight loss, though. People stress is too much when the same results (or better, IMHO) can be obtained with weights as long as your calories are right.0 -
I think all the Jillian Michaels' dvds give a great combo of cardio and weight training. It depends on how heavy you are wanting to go on weight training though...0
-
We have just acquired a weight bench so this post has been helpful, thanks 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions