Herbal Tea vs. Water

missbabybee
missbabybee Posts: 64
edited September 20 in Food and Nutrition
I work in an air conditioned office and I am always cold. To keep myself warm, I drink several cups of herbal tea each day (no cream or sweetener). Does that count toward water my daily water intake or should that be counted separately?

Replies

  • tammietifanie
    tammietifanie Posts: 1,496 Member
    If it's caffeine Free i would count that as water intake..
  • I also drink a fair amount of herbal, decaf tea each day for exactly the same reason (in a medical office that is freezing). I don't count it towards my water intake thought because I figure that since tea is a diuretic I should still drink my set amount of water (if not more) on top of it to keep myself balanced. Hope this helps, and I am curious to see what everyone else does!
  • barbarella
    barbarella Posts: 609 Member
    I've been told by my doctor......... nope! :flowerforyou:

    Tea is tea, and water is water ............. :drinker:
  • neenaleigh
    neenaleigh Posts: 584 Member
    I've been told by my doctor......... nope! :flowerforyou:

    Tea is tea, and water is water ............. :drinker:

    im with you... water is the only thing i count for water....:bigsmile:
  • MacMadame
    MacMadame Posts: 1,893 Member
    But it's not "daily water intake", it's "daily fluid intake" and tea is a fluid.

    Btw, it turns out that caffeine isn't really a diuretic after all.
  • jowily
    jowily Posts: 189 Member
    HYDRATION: Does it Always Have to be Water?

    Whether you’re an elite athlete, an avid exerciser, or more the
    spectator type, there’s one common fact: you can’t live long
    without water. Your body needs enough water to carry out
    many vital body functions and help you perform at your best.
    That’s why it’s so important to stay hydrated both on and off
    the field, says fitness expert, author and celebrity trainer,
    Kathy Kaehler. “Proper hydration keeps our bodies running
    the way they’re supposed to,” she says.

    Read on to learn the ins and outs of hydration, as well as
    some surprising facts about caffeine and hydration.

    Fulfilling Daily Water Needs

    Being hydrated means the water you consume from beverages
    and foods is in balance with the water your body loses from
    perspiration, respiration, elimination and other body processes.
    The term “water” can mean more than just plain drinking water
    in this case. It includes other liquids such as milk, fruit juices,
    sports drinks, and watery foods such as fruits and vegetables,
    and even beverages such as soft drinks, coffee, and tea. The
    Institute of Medicine (IOM) recommends a daily water intake of
    91 ounces for healthy women and 125 ounces for healthy
    men. Water needs increase with factors such as strenuous
    physical activity, hot and cold temperature extremes, and
    being ill with fever, diarrhea or vomiting. About 80% of water
    intake comes from beverages and about 20% comes from foods.

    Surprising Facts about Caffeine and Hydration

    You may be surprised to learn that caffeinated beverages are
    not dehydrating, as is commonly believed. A 2004 report from
    the IOM concluded that caffeine-containing beverages such as
    regular coffee, tea and soft drinks contribute to total daily water
    intake, similar to beverages without caffeine. Although caffeine
    has a mild diuretic effect, it does not generally contribute to
    dehydration because the fluid in the beverage itself cancels out
    any fluid loss from the body. In fact, all beverages have a mild
    diuretic effect, even water.


    (FYI - water is most commonly recommended because it does not have any calories - but juices have water - it's just that they usually contain a fair amount of sugar as well - but if you drank a bunch of juice you would fulfill you fluid intake - but you would probably start to put on weight!).
  • July24Lioness
    July24Lioness Posts: 2,399 Member
    I've been told by my doctor......... nope! :flowerforyou:

    Tea is tea, and water is water ............. :drinker:

    Me too.............

    I was even told when you add crystal lite or anything to it, it is no longer water, but a sweetened drink.
  • Demetria
    Demetria Posts: 178
    If I were you I would count it toward your daily water intake. I feel that it consists mainly of water so water it is just with a little extra stuff.

    Herbal tea is different from the true tea such as green, black or white tea. Depending on what herbs the "tea" is made from it may have no caffeine at all.

    And you don't add sweeteners so that is even better.

    You don't want to drown yourself in water either because that can upset your electrolyte balance just as bad as not having enough water.

    HTH,
    Demetria
  • Thank you!! Although all the responses didn't point toward one answer (as I had hoped), I still learned a lot. I will talk to my doctor. Thanks everyone. Happy losing (weight, that is)!
This discussion has been closed.