Always Hungry After Dinner
graelwyn
Posts: 1,340 Member
I am not trying to lose anymore weight, just maintain.
It seems even when I eat a fairly large dinner, I am still really hungry after. It doesn't seem to matter how much protein or carbs I have, it is the same. I didn't seem to get this hungry eating the same amount for a meal when I weighed more.
Tonight I had a fillet of boiled trout, 300g of sweet potato, and 200g of broccoli. I only at it an hour ago. And already I am hungry.
I did my usual cycling, 105 minutes of it and I had a tub of cottage cheese before I set off.
I am sure I should not need so much food to be full.
Someone suggested that it is because I am at too low a weight for my body.
But I really would rather not go up too much above the 126 I originally aimed for. I am 5'9.6
What will help fill me up more with my meals? Ideas?
It seems even when I eat a fairly large dinner, I am still really hungry after. It doesn't seem to matter how much protein or carbs I have, it is the same. I didn't seem to get this hungry eating the same amount for a meal when I weighed more.
Tonight I had a fillet of boiled trout, 300g of sweet potato, and 200g of broccoli. I only at it an hour ago. And already I am hungry.
I did my usual cycling, 105 minutes of it and I had a tub of cottage cheese before I set off.
I am sure I should not need so much food to be full.
Someone suggested that it is because I am at too low a weight for my body.
But I really would rather not go up too much above the 126 I originally aimed for. I am 5'9.6
What will help fill me up more with my meals? Ideas?
0
Replies
-
You could try cutting down the exercise to see if that makes a difference? You may be burning off most of your meal and not leaving enough for your body to run on?0
-
It is a possibility, I suppose, tho I generally end up eating all the site tells me to, sometimes more.
And with an underactive thyroid I had assumed that my metabolism would be ridiculously slow, along with being 36, and not young anymore.
I see others on here having pretty small portions and being full, and wonder what an earth is wrong with me, lol. It would have taken double what I had to have left me full and that is crazy as I had a plateful.0 -
I'm always a lot more hungry after exercise. Maybe a piece of fruit and a yoghurt after your meal might do the trick?0
-
I can see why you're hungry today - you're about 1400 cal under what you could eat. I suspect part of it, today anyway, you had a small breakfast and 200 cal lunch before going on your bike ride. You're way under on your carbs (personally I find on Sundays after my long run if I don't have something to eat right away afterward I feel like I'm starving for the rest of the day) try something like chocolate milk or a clif bar after your ride.0
-
I'm always a lot more hungry after exercise. Maybe a piece of fruit and a yoghurt after your meal might do the trick?
I tend to usually have a large pear with a little 0% greek yoghurt on top a bit after dinner, but usually end up eating more later on as well, and often not very healthy stuff either, lol. I get chocolate and carb cravings before bed.0 -
Go to bed early and sleep off the hunger, well that's my solution anyway. The munchies always happen at night.0
-
I can see why you're hungry today - you're about 1400 cal under what you could eat. I suspect part of it, today anyway, you had a small breakfast and 200 cal lunch before going on your bike ride. You're way under on your carbs (personally I find on Sundays after my long run if I don't have something to eat right away afterward I feel like I'm starving for the rest of the day) try something like chocolate milk or a clif bar after your ride.
Yes, I am often way under this time of day as I tend to make up a lot of my calories at night, because I am in the bad habit of not going to bed until gone 3 or 4am. I am trying to change that a bit. I must admit, I tend to wait til dinner to eat after my cycling as I usually don't get back until a few hours before dinner. And because I dont get up til around midday, I don't get in breakfast, so tend to count whatever I eat before I sleep as breakfast. My body clock is a bit messed up as I am a night owl.
I am finding it really hard to get things right after so long of chaotic eating habits. I find it scary to experiment and see what happens weight wise. Usually I have about 800 still to eat by this point and get through it before bed.0 -
Have you checked your BMI at that weight? For some reason that seems a little low in weight, but maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.0
-
maybe try and eat more during the day as you are way under your goal maybe try protein shakes0
-
Another thing you should check - are you actually hungry or do you feel hungry? A long time ago, my trainer told me that feeling hungry at night may actually be your body burning the fuel you've put into it (particularly for late in the day exercisers). You can tell this burn from actual hunger by listening to your stomach. If your stomach growls - you've hungry, and you should eat. If not - you might just be burning away what you ate because of the exercise.0
-
Mentally, regardless of what I ate during the day, I have not been able to break the habit of feeling like I need to continue eating after dinner. My "hunger" after dinner does not correlate to my food choices or quantity throughout the day or at dinner. Your hunger may be very real, based on physical needs. In that case my advice may not apply. Here are my tips (maybe one or more will work for you:
1. I split dinner into two parts. I eat part 2 about an hour after part 1.
2. If I sense I am going to go on a binge, I allow myself to do so with raw vegetables such as carrots, celery and green pepper.
3. If I sense I am craving a sweet, I have tablespoon of mini chocolate morsels with a table spoon of walnuts.
4. I am really trying to end food by 8:00 in the evening (hope nobody goes balistic with this one, it is on the advice of the pharmacist in terms of medication management, as a cancer survivor I take quite a mix, but I know it doesn't apply to everyone).
5. To symbolize closure of the daily food cycle, I have a cup of peppermint or camomile tea.0 -
Well - I know you don't want to gain weight but you are right on the lower end of the healthy range BMI. So you might be just plain hungry!
And it doesn't sound if your food is that weel tied in with when your bpdy's asking for it after exercise, so it might be worth experimenting with the same calorie intake but changing the times of day and cutting down the nighttime calories (I do sympathise as I'm insomniac and struggle with this too, but I'm really making an effort to go for lower caloris snacks).
Also I had a quick look at your diary and you're pretty constantly high sodium and low protein, shouldn't think either helps.
Do you drink enough water? That often helps with hunger pangs.
But overall it sounds as if you're doing really well, but perhaps a bit scared to experiment in case you lose control. I don't think you will, you could have more confidence and maybe make a small change here and there to see if it helps.0 -
That is just your body's natural response. For so long, it was starving itself. Now it has access to food. It is trying to grab anything to put in the fat stocks.0
-
Have you checked your BMI at that weight? For some reason that seems a little low in weight, but maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.
For 5'9, my BMI at my goal of 126 would be about 18.5
But admittedly, I am half an inch over 5'9 and have dropped to 122/123 at the moment, so don't know my exact BMI now. even eating chocolate as well as my healthy stuff.0 -
That is just your body's natural response. For so long, it was starving itself. Now it has access to food. It is trying to grab anything to put in the fat stocks.
I haven't starved myself in sometime, until last summer, I was over 140 Ibs and ate what I wanted pretty much.
Though for a period of time, I did tend to go out cycling and not eat all day until evening. But I am now trying to eat in the daytime as well.0 -
Another thing you should check - are you actually hungry or do you feel hungry? A long time ago, my trainer told me that feeling hungry at night may actually be your body burning the fuel you've put into it (particularly for late in the day exercisers). You can tell this burn from actual hunger by listening to your stomach. If your stomach growls - you've hungry, and you should eat. If not - you might just be burning away what you ate because of the exercise.
Hmm, not sure. My stomach isn't growling. I just have a gnawing sense of hunger really, and don't feel full.0 -
Mentally, regardless of what I ate during the day, I have not been able to break the habit of feeling like I need to continue eating after dinner. My "hunger" after dinner does not correlate to my food choices or quantity throughout the day or at dinner. Your hunger may be very real, based on physical needs. In that case my advice may not apply. Here are my tips (maybe one or more will work for you:
1. I split dinner into two parts. I eat part 2 about an hour after part 1.
2. If I sense I am going to go on a binge, I allow myself to do so with raw vegetables such as carrots, celery and green pepper.
3. If I sense I am craving a sweet, I have tablespoon of mini chocolate morsels with a table spoon of walnuts.
4. I am really trying to end food by 8:00 in the evening (hope nobody goes balistic with this one, it is on the advice of the pharmacist in terms of medication management, as a cancer survivor I take quite a mix, but I know it doesn't apply to everyone).
5. To symbolize closure of the daily food cycle, I have a cup of peppermint or camomile tea.
Splitting dinner into a few parts is something I had considered actually last night as a possible help. I do tend to just eat it at once, then a short time later have a piece of fruit and yoghurt. The 8pm wouldn't work for me, lol, I tend to eat dinner at 9pm and often have snacks right before bed at 3 or 4am. Pretty bad routine to have gotten into, I know.0 -
Post workout food that I really like that keeps me full is bananas. It might be worth a try to eat one after your workouts and see if it helps curb the food cravings.
I would also suggest saving up a few calories for post-dinner snack. Just preplan it so you know you can eat it if you need to.
You may also be able to get away with eating a little more. Experiment with your calorie intake a bit to see if you can get away with eating 100-200 calories more per day that you're currently eating.0 -
This is the old hunter-gatherer response. The game is plentiful, the berries are ripe, and it is time to fatten up for the winter. And if you do, you will gain it all back.
This is the toughest part of dieting: outlasting that hungry response when you have received adequate nourishment long enough that your metabolism has a chance to adjust.0 -
Well - I know you don't want to gain weight but you are right on the lower end of the healthy range BMI. So you might be just plain hungry!
And it doesn't sound if your food is that weel tied in with when your bpdy's asking for it after exercise, so it might be worth experimenting with the same calorie intake but changing the times of day and cutting down the nighttime calories (I do sympathise as I'm insomniac and struggle with this too, but I'm really making an effort to go for lower caloris snacks).
Also I had a quick look at your diary and you're pretty constantly high sodium and low protein, shouldn't think either helps.
Do you drink enough water? That often helps with hunger pangs.
But overall it sounds as if you're doing really well, but perhaps a bit scared to experiment in case you lose control. I don't think you will, you could have more confidence and maybe make a small change here and there to see if it helps.
With water, I am doing really well actually. I used to be really stupid and restrict what I drank for fear of it showing when I checked my weight, but now I make sure I get plenty of water on top of my tea and chicory drinks. I didn't notice I was high on sodium, but I had assumed I needed the salt as I do sweat a lot when cycling. I want to add more protein, I thought tonight I should have had more fish and less sweet potato.
True I am afraid to experiment and also because it has been so long since I actually ate 3 meals a day, and was up early enough to eat 3 meals a day, that trying to adjust to the idea of a proper meal for lunch is really hard. And you cant really cycle on a full stomach. I guess I need to start getting to bed earlier and getting up early enough to fit in a lunch before my cycling. I am such a routinised person, I tend to get stuck in the same way of doing things each day.0 -
Have you checked your BMI at that weight? For some reason that seems a little low in weight, but maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.
For 5'9, my BMI at my goal of 126 would be about 18.5
But admittedly, I am half an inch over 5'9 and have dropped to 122/123 at the moment, so don't know my exact BMI now. even eating chocolate as well as my healthy stuff.
Well with those numbers your BMI is 17.9 which is in the underweight category. I suggest upping your calories and planning your meals out a little more rigidly. Including the calories that you intend to burn exercising and timing it around those exercises!
You're too small! Eat! and Enjoy it!0 -
A glass of water with metamucil is always enough to give that satisfied feeling as the fibre expands in your belly. I think it's only worth 20 cal for a tsp of Metamicil Orange (the smooth one) as well
0 -
Have you checked your BMI at that weight? For some reason that seems a little low in weight, but maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.
For 5'9, my BMI at my goal of 126 would be about 18.5
But admittedly, I am half an inch over 5'9 and have dropped to 122/123 at the moment, so don't know my exact BMI now. even eating chocolate as well as my healthy stuff.
Well with those numbers your BMI is 17.9 which is in the underweight category. I suggest upping your calories and planning your meals out a little more rigidly. Including the calories that you intend to burn exercising and timing it around those exercises!
You're too small! Eat! and Enjoy it!
Thanks, I shall try and eat more or exercise less, though I love my cycling, I must admit, as I am pretty sedentary the rest of the day and the cycling wakes me up a bit.0 -
Have you checked your BMI at that weight? For some reason that seems a little low in weight, but maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.
For 5'9, my BMI at my goal of 126 would be about 18.5
But admittedly, I am half an inch over 5'9 and have dropped to 122/123 at the moment, so don't know my exact BMI now. even eating chocolate as well as my healthy stuff.
So naturally your BMI is lower than 18.5. Typically anything under 18.5 is considered underweight and at risk for health problems. Maybe you need to reevaluate your weight. Your body is hungry because it is being forced to be smaller than your natural healthy weight. Since you're only maintaining, eating healthy snacks when you're hungry is not going to make you gain weight.
Heck, I'm 5'4" and 125 is my goal weight....0 -
You may also want to eat all of your fat cals...proven to aid in satiety.0
-
You may also want to eat all of your fat cals...proven to aid in satiety.
Yes, I find that part hard as I dont tend to use any oil to cook in. I have full fat milk in my drinks though, I just don't tend to log those. I tend to only hit my fat quota when I have peanut butter or nuts and seeds, but I tend to go overboard on those once I get started so I stopped buying them in. I will be having avocado more soon so that will add some healthy fats.0 -
A hodgepodge of possibilities...
I've been told that chocolate cravings sometimes come from dehydration. (Remember regular tea can be a diarrhetic.)
Since you're also low on fats, maybe about 5 chocolate covered almonds as a snack? Some warm milk and chocolate?
Are you still losing weight instead of stabilizing? Maybe you really aren't eating enough.
And remember that "not feeling full" is not the same as being hungry. It may take awhile to get used to not having food in your stomach all your waking hours.0 -
A hodgepodge of possibilities...
I've been told that chocolate cravings sometimes come from dehydration. (Remember regular tea can be a diarrhetic.)
Since you're also low on fats, maybe about 5 chocolate covered almonds as a snack? Some warm milk and chocolate?
Are you still losing weight instead of stabilizing? Maybe you really aren't eating enough.
And remember that "not feeling full" is not the same as being hungry. It may take awhile to get used to not having food in your stomach all your waking hours.
I would eat things like chocolate coated almonds, but the issue is, I wouldn't be able to stop at 5, lol. If I enjoy something, it is hard to stop once I start..though I am working on that.
I am not sure if I am losing weight. I had a load of chocolate the other day, and managed to lost half a pound still and am still down half a pound. I was 126 about a week ago, and have dropped to 122.8. I am sure cycling cannot use that much energy, as I am eating 2000 calories or more a lot of days.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions