Gaining at 1200 cal limit?
guamSUPERgirl90
Posts: 255
Is it possible? Im gaining back weight lost. Trying to say at my limit of 1200cals. My food diary is open. All opinions are appreciated!
Info: 5'4"
starting: 190Lbs
lost: 11Lbs
gained: 4Lbs
current: 184 lbs
Exercise:
2-3 days/ week brisk walking
work= Some physical activity as Im a Sales/ Customer service Rep at a mall.
Info: 5'4"
starting: 190Lbs
lost: 11Lbs
gained: 4Lbs
current: 184 lbs
Exercise:
2-3 days/ week brisk walking
work= Some physical activity as Im a Sales/ Customer service Rep at a mall.
0
Replies
-
Be careful not to eat too few calories.0
-
Your food diary is not open.0
-
Didn't look at your diary...but, I am betting it is water weight. I had a 6lb gain one week and freaked out. It was TOM and 3 days later those 6 and one more was gone. Remember to gain "actual" weight you would need to eat an extra 2500 cals in a week plus your reduction each day back.0
-
Try to up your calories a bit.:bigsmile: Your food diary isn't open so I can't see what you're eating but if you are eating 1200 calories and burning calories with exercise, your net could be and probably are too low.:noway: I had to up mine to start losing again. I hit a plateau. Hang in there. There is a lot of trial and error.. What works for one may not work for another.:flowerforyou:0
-
A pound is actually 3500 calories not 2500.
Are you eating back your exercise calories? I have recently upped my calories, and lost over a pound last week eating between 1800-2000 calories. It is possible that you are eating too few calories.
Read through this post
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/538381-in-place-of-a-road-map0 -
need to see some numbers. your diary isnt open.0
-
need to open your diary hon0
-
Sorry guys! NOW OPEN0
-
My guess is it's water weight from sodium. That's not fat gain, but it moves the scale in the wrong direction all the same. You can turn on sodium so you can see it on your food diary. Aside from that, I'd say give the extra calories several weeks before you make any changes.0
-
I would say it is water weight. You are eating at subway which has processed deli meat that are HIGH in sodium. Track you sodium. It is an option in your food diary settings.0
-
Real quick...
Add Sodium tracking to your diary.
You are taking in too much sodium.
You need to cut back on fat intake. You are consistently going over fat limit. Consuming a lot of fat will make you fat. Also gives you low energy levels.
Almost every time you exercise, you eat back the calories you burned. Don't eat back those calories.
You hardly stay at 1200 calories.0 -
Is it possible? Im gaining back weight lost. Trying to say at my limit of 1200cals. My food diary is open. All opinions are appreciated!
Info: 5'4"
starting: 190Lbs
lost: 11Lbs
gained: 4Lbs
current: 184 lbs
Exercise:
2-3 days/ week brisk walking
work= Some physical activity as Im a Sales/ Customer service Rep at a mall.
It is possible. First time doing this brisk walking compared to before?
Your body being asked to do more physical exercise now, wants to store more glucose, which always has water with it.
500 calories of carbs stored as glucose/water is 1 lb. So very possible.
Keep it up, body trying to improve.
Problem, did you select Sedentary activity level because you thought it would help you lose faster? You are not sedentary with your job - Lightly Active or Active depending on job time on feet and moving around for it. I'd say Active, because you aren't going to count those slow walks.
Don't shoot yourself in the metabolism by selecting wrong activity level, and only select 1lb weekly. You'll still lose more with that great daily activity though.
That much extra though, probably some sodium retention. Also the difference in body states between weigh ins. Best case last weigh-in, worst case this weigh-in.
Additional tip. Slow walking less than 3mph is just like your other daily activity - mainly fat burning usage. And that is exactly where your deficit should come from.
Good job feeding your workouts, but skip feeding the walking at slower the 3mph - unless that is up an incline and you have good heart beat and hard breathing. That is just more fat burning you don't need to feed.0 -
I'll cut down on carbs..bread.0
-
Thanks for all the feedback... this is what I have so far (moving forward)
Added Sodium to watch
Less sodium intake
Less Carbs intake
Adjust profile settings
more Cardio/ strength training...
I hope I see improvement... but most of all thank you for all your advices Pals!!!! .0 -
Find your BMR and don't eat below that. See how that works for you.0
-
Find your BMR and don't eat below that. See how that works for you.
^^^ yeah that, and if you fall below your BMR with exercise DO eat back those calories.0 -
In chemistry, where sodium (salt) goes (food in your rmouth), water follows (kidneys will hold onto water).
From the CDC:
Top Sources of Sodium in the diet:
Breads and rolls
Cold cuts and cured meats
Pizza
Poultry
Soups
Sandwiches
Cheese
Pasta dishes
Meat dishes
Snacks
To reduce sodium in your diet:
Read Nutrition Facts labels when shopping to find the lowest sodium options of your favorite foods.
Eat more fruits and vegetables, either fresh, frozen (without sauce), or canned (with no salt added).
Limit processed foods high in sodium. When foods are processed, a sodium solution is injected into the food (NOTE: I am presuming they do this as sodium is a food preservative - think back in the old sailing days, salt pork was a mainstay food on ships).
When eating out, request no salt be added to your meal.
http://www.cdc.gov/salt/
Current dietary guidelines for Americans recommend that adults in general should consume no more than 2,300 mg of sodium per day. At the same time, consume potassium-rich foods, such as fruits and vegetables. However, if you are in the following population groups, you should consume no more than 1,500 mg of sodium per day, and meet the potassium recommendation (4,700 mg/day) with food.
You are 51 years of age or older.
You are African American.
You have high blood pressure.
You have diabetes.
You have chronic kidney disease.
Probably way more than you wanted to know about salt, lol, but bottom line, we all need to read the nutrition label.
HTH0 -
hey girl!
I started at 153 pounds and am down to about 147-148 range thus far. I consulted my nutritionist before starting. Since I have a sedentary job and work crazy hours I was told to take in 1200-1500 cals a day and to work out at a moderate intensity or higher for one hour everyday focusing on cardio. Being that you're ~180lbs 1500 is the absolute minimum for you unless a doctor is monitoring you weekly or bi-weekly. To help with the water-weight drink green teas throughout the day and to give you an extra boost, I highly recommend the GNC Vitapaks. They have CLA which REALLY helped me and plus the multivitamin and calcium is all there, and best of all the Energy pills! I took one in the morning with my coffee and one at noon/before a workout, and it really helped me push through the "i dont wanna" moods. Also I did the HCG diet (the 1200 cal version, and they have a 1500 version as well) for about a week and a half and I dropped some weight fast and haven't gained it back. It gave me a boost I needed. If you take in too few calories your body will think that youre on the brink of starvation and will store extra blubber to ensure you dont die. ( Evolution can be a cruel demon :P) So to counteract that, eat 5-7 small delicious meals a day to signal that "no, im not going to starve, body" I would keep apple slices and Cocoa powdered almonds in my purse and take a "bathroom break" to sneak it on on my shift =^-^= I'm crafty like that. Best of luck to you chicka, we all struggle with the same thing
~K0 -
Ok so I appreciate all the feed back... But what I am willing to try:
watch my sodium intake
watch my carbs
add green tea
workout 60min minimum atleast 3 days a week
try to up my intake between 1200-1350 (ill give this a try)
Ill post updates!
Thanks again Pals!0 -
Hello from sunny scotland!
Yes i am in total agreement with those who say water retention.
Your sodium/salt intake is disproportionately high, mid week.
Cut back on all processed foods, they have hidden nasties.
Drink loads of water to help your kidneys flush out sodium, no more than 2 liters a day tho,
It will balance out and you ll get a good loss soon0 -
Find your BMR and don't eat below that. See how that works for you.
^^^ yeah that, and if you fall below your BMR with exercise DO eat back those calories.
THIS ^^^
1200 is generally way too low for most!0 -
Here is a plan to keep on track with weight loss. courtesy of gp79.
1. Calculate your TDEE.
2. Create a 25% deficit and eat this amount regularly. Eat balanced.
3. Eat 1g protein per lb of lean body mass
4. Excercise 3 x per week.
- you won't be doing planks at your weight. I don't know why someone even suggested this.
- do what you are capable of doing. Incline walk, walk, jog at a level of intensity where it's slightly challenging to maintain a conversation.
- incorporate some resistance training if you find it enjoyable. If you feel like you don't have a good understanding of it or lack the knowledge of what to do, research and ask for help. Otherwise I suggest focusing your efforts on cardio.
5. Drink water throughout the day.
6. Patience, persistence and willpower / discipline to keep on a plan.
Eating correctly is 80% of it. It took your life to get to where you are today and it will be no easy task to undo what's done.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions