I can't seem to eat all my calories....

You will need to open your diary for people to make an accurate assessment of what might help.

It seems everyday I max out my carbs, fiber, and protein (1st & foremost), but am left with 200-400 calories. I don't want to eat foods with no nutritional value, but I find myself eating a Jello or something similar just to build up the calories without adding to the others. Anyone know what I am doing wrong? Or advise of any food that are helpful? I eat the whole pyramid, in moderation, everyday, but still come up short!

Do you feel good? Are you hungry? Are you losing weight? Are your calories with the deficit of 200 - 400 still at a reasonable level? If the answers are yes, I wouldn't worry about it. Besides, you're probably eating more calories than you think.

I probably am eating more than I think, you're right.

I am not sure how to display my diary, so let me know!

I feel fine, not hungry, but am certainly eating less than I used to.
Have lost 3lbs since I started on Monday, think it might be the initial drop, and I don't want to "starve" my body, but YES to nuts and YES to the reduced fat items. With the deficit, I am still eating 900-1100 calories.....

Off your home tab go to settings, then go to diary settings. Scroll down and you will see where you can change it from private to public. Once you do that, people can give you meaningful advice.

Ok, just a quick observation based on the week or so I went back. You seem to be in the mindset that once you hit a macro, such as protein, you are done for the day. That's simply not true. Lot's of people actually manually adjust their macros to higher or lower levels, depending on their needs. Protein is a common one to up. So if you go over, don't sweat it.

You are consistently severely low on your calorie intake. That 1200 you are at is the LOWEST you should eat. In reality, you should be eating much higher, preferably above your BMR. Do a little research on this site to learn more about that and for now, don't go under 1200. Ever. You will likely end up binging later because it's just not doable for the majority of people.

You aren't getting a lot of variety. The macro you seem to leave hanging, along with calories, is carbs. Lot's of veggies and fruits have carbs and I don't see very many of those in your daily menu's. You are eating a lot of processed crap, but not a lot of fresh, filling foods.

Take the time to look at diaries on here. Especially those of successful MFPer's. One thing you will see is a HUGE variety just in one day. And LOTS of food. At every meal.

I hope that helps.

Just based on your meals today - Where are your veggies?? Add some romaine lettuce with that fish taco and toss in some tomato on top. If you like onions, add those too! And a bit of avocado would be great.

I usually keep a bag of carrots, celery, and cucumber (cut up) to eat when I want every day - its less than 150 calories, but allows me to get veggie in and "eat mindlessly".

Things like goldfish crackers are yummy, but instead get some whole wheat crackers and top with cheese and tomato! And instead of Campbell's soup, try making your own tomato soup, it's really easy and much healthier - plus then you can add other fresh veggies if you want (or at least real tomato).

When you first start on here, go for calories - eat at least 1200 a day and exercise 3 times a week (eat back half of what you get from exercise - so that you have at least 1200 regardless net) then you can focus more on protein, carbs, fats, etc - those are an advanced level.

Also, you said you think you are eating healthy - but you aren't adding in enough fruits, veggies, fiber, etc - so start eating more of that and less candy ;-) (that's a special once a week - yay I did it right -type thing).

I'd be more worried about shorting myself that many calories than I would about hitting those macros religiously, but that's me. I don't pay attention to mine at all so take what I say with a grain of salt.