The 17 Day Diet
BekahLuv
Posts: 164
Has anyone tried this and if so what kind of results did you see?
0
Replies
-
I have an aunt that does this diet regularly and she looks amazing at the age of 45. I tried doing it but couldn't get it done. I kept cheating and faaling off the wagon then tried to start over again... a month later I gave up. I just couldn't do it.0
-
I tried it last year, lasted about 2 weeks. I lost about 5 pounds in that period then fell off the wagon myself. I'm going to finally start doing Zumba and I don't want to pay all that money and continue a poor diet, so I think I am going to start this diet again.0
-
Bump :-)0
-
Diets don't work and are temporary. It's all about healthy eating habits and lifestyle changes. If you can't do something 365 days a year you will have a life long struggle of getting in shape. This is a marathon not a sprint. Don't look for quick fixes because they don't work. Make small changes and then keep on building off of that. You will maintain your results and be much better in the long run.0
-
My bfs mom bought the book and shes probably never going to use it lol...ive been thinking about it! However i would love to lose weight quickly i need to be careful cuz my belly pooch from kids im scared if i lose weight to quickly it will get crazy saggy lol! But i think it might be a great quickstart! Why not try it along with working out! It might teach us some things! Good luck!:drinker:0
-
My M-I-L recently just did this a few months ago. She lost about 8 lbs. in 17 days and continued until she lost 15 lobs. She went down a size from a tight 4/ loose 6 to a size 2. She looks good! She has maintained all of the loss and indulges in the occasional treat. She doesn't do any strength training nor did she do the DVD that came with the diet. She has always been an avid walker...Walks 60-90 minutes every day.0
-
Diets don't work and are temporary. It's all about healthy eating habits and lifestyle changes. If you can't do something 365 days a year you will have a life long struggle of getting in shape. This is a marathon not a sprint. Don't look for quick fixes because they don't work. Make small changes and then keep on building off of that. You will maintain your results and be much better in the long run.
I'm not looking for a quick fix... just a quick jumpstart. I feel if I can start off dropping pounds quick in the beginning, that will help to keep me motivated to maintain and workout in the long run.0 -
My M-I-L recently just did this a few months ago. She lost about 8 lbs. in 17 days and continued until she lost 15 lobs. She went down a size from a tight 4/ loose 6 to a size 2. She looks good! She has maintained all of the loss and indulges in the occasional treat. She doesn't do any strength training nor did she do the DVD that came with the diet. She has always been an avid walker...Walks 60-90 minutes every day.
How long did it take her to loose the 15 lbs?0 -
I so agree with you. The thing about quick fixes they don't last long. This time I decided to just eat healther.0
-
Everyone is looking for a quick jump start and ends up jumping of the bandwagon because it is to much for them to make huge changes over night. Make small goals and changes daily so that you can keep the results in the long run. It is better to loose and maintain in the long run then loose quickly just to gain in all back because you can't maintain it. Don't look to make extreme changes in what you do. Make a small goal that is easily to obtain for the week and then add another small goal that is easy to obtain the next week and so on.0
-
BuMp!!
Day one is off to a great start! I can't wait to weigh myself on day 17 and see how I did.
Anyone else try this diet??0 -
Sounds like a fad. To be successful, you're gonna have to make some permanent lifestyle changes in order to lose it and keep it off.0
-
Diets don't work and are temporary. It's all about healthy eating habits and lifestyle changes. If you can't do something 365 days a year you will have a life long struggle of getting in shape. This is a marathon not a sprint. Don't look for quick fixes because they don't work. Make small changes and then keep on building off of that. You will maintain your results and be much better in the long run.
Which is exactly the philosophy of the 17 Day Diet. It's a life style change :happy:0 -
My 25 year old daughter did this and quite succesfully. She lost 30 pounds in around 7 weeks. The whole premise is the first 17 days is strict basically fish, chicken & Turkey lots of veggies, 2 fruits and 2 yogurst per day. You eat unlimited veggies and meat until just before you are full.
The 2nd 17 day cycle adds red meat and some limited high glycemic carbs brown rice, 1/2 potato etc.
Cycle 3 adds even more back to your repertoire
Cycle 4 you begin to add in all of the foods in moderation.
The entire purpose of this program is to give you a jump start and help you get to your goal in a healty and safe manner. This diet is endorsed by Dr. Phil, Dr. Oz and the Doctor's show. The Doctor's has a great website that has recipes for each cycle.
If you cannot be strict with your food choices for a short amount of time then this diet is probably not for you.
Many options out there for us we just need to find what works for US!0 -
I just borrowed this book from the library. I'm very interested. I'm already doing the low carb thing and the weight its coming off very slowly. But I want it to come off a little quicker. So I'm going to give it a try. It sounds easier than what I'm doing now. It's just a matter of whether our not it actually works. I will find out soon enough!0
-
I had to have some major dental work done... a dental implant for my top front tooth... so now I am only allowed soft foods until it heals. Once it does, I'm going to go back to strictly following this diet!0
-
Diets don't work and are temporary. It's all about healthy eating habits and lifestyle changes. If you can't do something 365 days a year you will have a life long struggle of getting in shape. This is a marathon not a sprint. Don't look for quick fixes because they don't work. Make small changes and then keep on building off of that. You will maintain your results and be much better in the long run.
:flowerforyou: Couldn't agree more0 -
I did it! I lost 18 lbs on it. It was pretty tough, but it gave me a jump start on my weight loss. I don't follow it anymore, but I would do it again.
0 -
I've never done this diet before, but I can see how it can be a way to jumpstart you into a healthier lifestyle.
Hope all works out well for you, and here's to getting healthy :flowerforyou:0 -
I've been doing the 37 Year Diet, and I feel great!0
-
A ton of my FB friends are doing it and I read it over. The whole thing scared the bejeezus out of me and I said, no thanks... will stick to what works for me. I am a crazy cranky b!tch when you start limiting my food groups the way they have it set out. I likes me some apples.0
-
If you cannot be strict with your food choices for a short amount of time then this diet is probably not for you.
If the people doing the diets were strict with their food choices, they wouldn't need to be doing the diet.
Eat less than or equal to what you expend. No need to make it more difficult than it is.0 -
I started this before going to Florida to see my husband and lost 3 pounds in the 4 days I had done it. Even though I didn't follow it exactly while I was in Florida, I didn't gain any weight back- so I am starting back today at where I left off Day 5- I actually have enjoyed this diet so far- so I will continue to update the results- also you may want to join the group for 17 day dieters- here is the link:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/1409-17-day-dieters-unite
Good luck!!0 -
I started this before going to Florida to see my husband and lost 3 pounds in the 4 days I had done it.
This is water weight.
3 pounds of fat is 10,500 calories. Over 4 days, that would mean a 2625 calorie deficit per day. Unless you exercised like crazy, you did not do this. And if you exercised like crazy, your diet would not matter.0 -
A ton of my FB friends are doing it and I read it over. The whole thing scared the bejeezus out of me and I said, no thanks... will stick to what works for me. I am a crazy cranky b!tch when you start limiting my food groups the way they have it set out. I likes me some apples.
You can have apples...and pears, and plums, and blueberries, and oranges, and strawberries.
No refined sugar though, so it's not for everybody.0 -
I used this last year. It was a great way to lose some weight quickly so that I felt the results and was motivated to continue. It is difficult because it is limiting in the begining, however if you are able to stick with it, it is worth it. I love 15lbs on cycle one. I continued to lose and when I eventually moved into the final cycle was able to keep it off for a year. i am considering doing it again to try to lose the last bit of weight i want to drop. I think that it is a nice diet because it adds the foods you are limited back in and is something you can follow for the rest of your life just to live in a more healthy way.0
-
I just completed Cycle 1 and lost about 7 lbs!
I've continued the lifestyle change and think that this book is a great way to jumpstart your diet and introduce you into healthy portions and choosing carbs wisely. Also- to prove this is sustainable to those who stick to it.. I've lost another 2 lbs since getting off of the first 17 day cycle.
Please do not pay attention to all of those who are criticizing. In their defense- yes, the name "17 Day Diet" makes it sound like its something you only do for 17 days and then BAM... you're done... no more diet or exercise. Personally I DESPISE the word diet.
However, please do your research and check out the book from a local library or go to a bookstore. Its not only for 17 days... its a LIFESTYLE CHANGE.... and the book is a great way to help those out who have been looking for a way to change their eating habits but did not have the proper guidance. I blogged about my experience, go to my profile and check it out if you would like or email me if you have any questions.0 -
Please do not pay attention to all of those who are criticizing.
Please do not pay attention to the people advocating fad diets.
If it calls itself a "diet" and tells you that you absolutely cannot eat certain foods, it's a fad diet. This is not a sustainable lifestyle change.0 -
How about a medical professional's opinion?Please do not pay attention to all of those who are criticizing.
"Despite the plan's title, you will not lose weight quickly and keep it off after being on this plan for only 17 days.
Alternating between cycle 1 and cycle 2 might prevent boredom, but it really is just a strategy to cut calories and give you staying power to stick with the plan.
Although the evidence is lacking to substantiate Moreno’s weight loss theory of metabolic adjustment to burn fat, the principles of the diet are the foundation of all good diet plans: Cut calories; eat healthy foods; limit sugars, alcohol, and refined starches; and get regular exercise. That's solid advice that will lead to successful weight control.
Eat fruit whenever you want and add a once-daily multivitamin mineral to fill in nutritional gaps and the 17 Day Diet could be your answer to long-term weight control."
Kathleen Zelman, MPH, RD, http://www.webmd.com/diet/features/17-day-diet-review?page=3
You don't need to follow the silly guidelines of the diet. Just eat sensibly.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions