Seriously DONT get it
Curleycue0314
Posts: 245 Member
Okay so I am beyond frustrated this week and very confused by the whole thing!!!!! I am new to MFP, but not to a calorie counter. So like all other calorie counters that i have used i logged my exercise and what i ate. I didn't go over my dailey goals, but i don't think i should be eating soooooo much. I feel like i'm eating all day long! I actually gained a pound this week not lost 1.5 like my set up is! Serously, if i'm working out 60 minutes 3 times a week why am i supposed to eat 2300 cal a day! my BMR is 1700! Please someone explain this to me! BEYOND FRUSTRATED!!! AND sincerly wondering if MFP has it set up correctly for me. I get the concept, but have yet to see the results from the whole thing! READY TO GIVE UP!
0
Replies
-
I personally do not eat my exercise calories. I eat the 1200 calories that they set for me and that is it. I know we are getting told differently, but it just doesnt work for me. I have also found out that on the weeks I do only strength training and do not do cardio, then I do not lose weight. I have to have my cardio to get the scale moving.0
-
Have you set your activity level to include your exercise?
If you have used your exercise to set yourself as moderately active, and then tracked it, you're counting it twice. That might be why you're getting a high number of calories.0 -
I'm doing mostly Cardio right now - 2 spin classes a week and a scultpting class with 15 min of cardio afterward. There are some weeks I work out 5 days, again mostly Cardio with some strength training after0
-
Is that 2300 before or after exercise? If it is before it does seem high. Also, what are your activity levels and goals set to? I'm 5'8", 160, lightly active and with a 1lb/week weight loss goal it sets my daily calories to 1530, which is just over my BMR. When I first started I was at 1200 calories/day, then upped to 1400 (all before exercise, eating back most of my exercise calories). Your numbers do seem a little high, so you might double check your settings.
That said, there are many reasons your weight could be up 1.5 pounds. I weigh in daily and can have that kind of increase or more overnight, so it could be water or related to your menses somehow.0 -
How are you calculating your exercise burns? There's a good chance you're over estimating without the aid of a good HRM, some math, and a VO2 "score". I would also recommend a food scale. I've found that most people tend to under estimate food and over estimate exercise.
-M0 -
I find that MFP does give a few too many calories if you're looking to lose weight. I'm looking to lose 2 pounds a week so I've been trying to eat no more then 1300-1400 calories a day, even if i do exercise. Try doing that for a week and see where you end up, it's been working great for me, hopefully you'll notice a difference!0
-
I know everyone says eat your exercise points but I would definitely gain if I ate them all. For one thing, when I wear a heart monitor to exercise it shows that MFP is way too generous (with me anyways) as far as calories burned. I usually burn significantly less than MFP says I'm burning. I'm older and not in great shape so I probably don't exercise as hard as some folks here though.
I usually try to add some of my exercise points back (maybe 300 max) but not all of them.
I also find it confusing that MFP asks what your activity level is and bases your calories on that - then adds exercise calories back. It seems like double dipping to me. Maybe they are talking about general activity rather than exercise per se. Still - I put my activity level to sedentary and then when I add my exercise it seems to come out about right - about 1500 calories a day. I'm old and short so that's about right for me.
Good luck!!
Debbie0 -
Okay so I am beyond frustrated this week and very confused by the whole thing!!!!! I am new to MFP, but not to a calorie counter. So like all other calorie counters that i have used i logged my exercise and what i ate. I didn't go over my dailey goals, but i don't think i should be eating soooooo much. I feel like i'm eating all day long! I actually gained a pound this week not lost 1.5 like my set up is! Serously, if i'm working out 60 minutes 3 times a week why am i supposed to eat 2300 cal a day! my BMR is 1700! Please someone explain this to me! BEYOND FRUSTRATED!!! AND sincerly wondering if MFP has it set up correctly for me. I get the concept, but have yet to see the results from the whole thing! READY TO GIVE UP!
Reset!
Go back through the setup wizard, set your lifestyle to sedentary, and log your exercise as your exercise so you have to burn it to earn it.
MFP can be inaccurate about calorie burn, often overstating it. 60 minutes of full-on burn for me (216 pounds, 40+ years old) is about 800 calories. The site is giving you 600 calories for a spinning class and 15 minutes of cardio - which may or may not be accurate for your weight and age. There are many "how many calories do I burn at a given heart rate" calculators out there that you can enter your weight, age, height, and heartrate and it will give you a reasonable guess. Work out on a cardio machine that measures heart rate, learn what you burn, and go from there. Or get a heart rate monitor.
I'm 6' 3", 216LB, over 40, lifestyle at "sedentary", and the site has me at 1,450 net calories a day with a 2-pound-a-week weight loss. I found MFP was overestimating some of my exercise and about right on others. Once I got the calories of my "burn" correct, I found that I was losing weight at the pace I set.0 -
i do not log in my exercise i just use the 1290 given to me.0
-
So many people say eat back exercise calories but it depends from person to person... i ORIGINALLY was eating only 1200 until i hit a plateau and then i up'd to now 1628....and neither time do i eat back exercise calories and I work out 6days a week for a minimum of 45min and I am losing just fine again0
-
There could be a number of reasons. Please don't give up! I do think your calorie intake is pretty high, can't be totally certain of this since I am not certified in fitness. I started on MFP at 163 pounds and was set to "lightly active" lifestyle and my calorie allowance was 1480. (losing 1 pound a week) I do notice since I weigh myself almost every day that during my period and ovulation I could gain 2 pounds and it's hard to lose during those 2 times of the month. However it's "water retention" and the 2 pound gain does come off as soon as that time of the month is over. It's just not a good feeling knowing that at certain times of the month I can't really "lose" any substantial weight. But again, it's better than the alternative. If I didn't track my calories there would be no hope for me to lose.
Good luck and don't give up!!0 -
Is that 2300 before or after exercise? If it is before it does seem high. Also, what are your activity levels and goals set to? I'm 5'8", 160, lightly active and with a 1lb/week weight loss goal it sets my daily calories to 1530, which is just over my BMR. When I first started I was at 1200 calories/day, then upped to 1400 (all before exercise, eating back most of my exercise calories). Your numbers do seem a little high, so you might double check your settings.
That said, there are many reasons your weight could be up 1.5 pounds. I weigh in daily and can have that kind of increase or more overnight, so it could be water or related to your menses somehow.
That is TOTAL, my Goal is 1440 NET0 -
That is TOTAL, my Goal is 1440 NET
So if your goal is 1440 you're getting an 850 calorie burn from exercise? That's not beyond the bounds of possibility for 60 minutes but it does seem high.0 -
That is TOTAL, my Goal is 1440 NET
So if your goal is 1440 you're getting an 850 calorie burn from exercise? That's not beyond the bounds of possibility for 60 minutes but it does seem high.
My 850 today would be from an hour long Spin class and 10 min of Elliptical training- so 70 min.0 -
It's different because I'm a guy, but my target calories is 1840 a day and my goal is set to lose 2 lbs a week. I work out 7 days a week, about 60 minutes a day.
All I can say is eating right and working out regulary will in the long term always pay off, so hang in there! I've lost over 100 lbs. As for a couple pounds, the scale can be deceptive at times. Go ahead and weigh yourself every day but your progress on the scale won't always be accurate. That has a lot to do with water weight which comes and goes. Remember, you can step on the scale and lose or gain five pounds, but that is NOT all fat.
During my weight loss, one day the scale would say I lost three or four pounds, the next day it would say I gained three or four pounds but I was always losing fat. So don't pay so much attention to the scale, in the end it will pay off.
I think working out three times a week is not enough if you want to lose weight. I say work out five times a week.
Are you staying under your sodium limit? Are you on target with your carbs to fat to protein? This is important in losing weight not just counting calories.
I, myself stick to my 1840 calories a day and ignore the added calories after my workouts. Sometimes I do 2x the workout (120 minutes) and I eat a little bit more, but my average net calories a day is just under 1000. Sorry, I have to say I haven't weighed myself lately but I lost about one to two inches on my waist in the last two months.
I think your settings is to high, maybe you can start over on entering your info and goals? Hang in there!!!!!0 -
try and eat at your BRM + eat 2/3 of your exercise calories back
this has so far worked best for me
also do you have a hrm for exercise?
i find that people over estimate when they go by what the internet/machines just tell them
for example when i run on the treadmill it'll tell me i burnt 150 calories when in realisty its only like 500 -
Way too much conflicting and incorrect information here.
1. Set your activity level here. Most people are lightly active. Sedentary is often a little low for most people.
2. Set your goal to lose 1 lb per week. This creates a deficit for you. You eat this number of calories on rest days. It is a goal, not a limit.
3. When you exercise, eat all or most of you exercise calories. If that adds up to eating 2300 calories per day, then that is what you eat.
Make sure you are accurately tracking your food here (a food scale is helpful). Make sure you are accurately measuring your calorie burns (like with a heart rate monitor).
It is simple. Don't let yourself or anyone else make it that hard. And don't go starving yourself at 1200 calories per day. You are exercising now, and becoming a more fit and healthy person. You need the food.0 -
maybe 2300 is your maintenance. 2100 is mine but I'm eating between 1400 and 1620 (1700-1800 on days I have an hour long work out) Eat your BMR, if it doesn't work for you, you don't have to eat back all your exercise cals. I don't. I just eat when I'm hungry and try to make good choices.0
-
I have been doing this for 2 week. I have an office job, so I said i was sedentary. The only exercise I have been doing is walking my dog in the morning, and cleaning. It has given me 1,450 calories a day, and I stick to that. And you HAVE to eat back your exercise calories, or it isn't healthy weight loss. I am 6' and currently weight 204. I have lost 8 pds in the 2 weeks I have done this.
The real answer is to ask your doctor.0 -
Way too much conflicting and incorrect information here.
1. Set your activity level here. Most people are lightly active. Sedentary is often a little low for most people.
2. Set your goal to lose 1 lb per week. This creates a deficit for you. You eat this number of calories on rest days. It is a goal, not a limit.
3. When you exercise, eat all or most of you exercise calories. If that adds up to eating 2300 calories per day, then that is what you eat.
Make sure you are accurately tracking your food here (a food scale is helpful). Make sure you are accurately measuring your calorie burns (like with a heart rate monitor).
It is simple. Don't let yourself or anyone else make it that hard. And don't go starving yourself at 1200 calories per day. You are exercising now, and becoming a more fit and healthy person. You need the food.
^ Exactly!0 -
I'm new to the MFP also. I started on the 2nd and I dont eat back what they give after exercising. I only eat my original daily calories.0
-
My 850 today would be from an hour long Spin class and 10 min of Elliptical training- so 70 min.
[/quote]
That's probably over shooting it a bit. I don't think many women can burn more than 10 calories a minute due to the lack of testosterone. Don't get panicked though, just scale back a bit this week and see how your body reacts. We're talking about the rest of your life, so a few weeks of experimentation won't mean much in the scheme of things.0 -
I agree with this, you have to set your lifestyle to sedentary or you will count your exercise twice.... and I still don't eat all my exercise calories back. But that can be very individual and also be careful and check that you really do burn as much as MFP says you do for the different exercises!Okay so I am beyond frustrated this week and very confused by the whole thing!!!!! I am new to MFP, but not to a calorie counter. So like all other calorie counters that i have used i logged my exercise and what i ate. I didn't go over my dailey goals, but i don't think i should be eating soooooo much. I feel like i'm eating all day long! I actually gained a pound this week not lost 1.5 like my set up is! Serously, if i'm working out 60 minutes 3 times a week why am i supposed to eat 2300 cal a day! my BMR is 1700! Please someone explain this to me! BEYOND FRUSTRATED!!! AND sincerly wondering if MFP has it set up correctly for me. I get the concept, but have yet to see the results from the whole thing! READY TO GIVE UP!
Reset!
Go back through the setup wizard, set your lifestyle to sedentary, and log your exercise as your exercise so you have to burn it to earn it.
MFP can be inaccurate about calorie burn, often overstating it. 60 minutes of full-on burn for me (216 pounds, 40+ years old) is about 800 calories. The site is giving you 600 calories for a spinning class and 15 minutes of cardio - which may or may not be accurate for your weight and age. There are many "how many calories do I burn at a given heart rate" calculators out there that you can enter your weight, age, height, and heartrate and it will give you a reasonable guess. Work out on a cardio machine that measures heart rate, learn what you burn, and go from there. Or get a heart rate monitor.
I'm 6' 3", 216LB, over 40, lifestyle at "sedentary", and the site has me at 1,450 net calories a day with a 2-pound-a-week weight loss. I found MFP was overestimating some of my exercise and about right on others. Once I got the calories of my "burn" correct, I found that I was losing weight at the pace I set.0 -
That is TOTAL, my Goal is 1440 NET
So if your goal is 1440 you're getting an 850 calorie burn from exercise? That's not beyond the bounds of possibility for 60 minutes but it does seem high.
My 850 today would be from an hour long Spin class and 10 min of Elliptical training- so 70 min.
How are you estimating your calories burned? Do you use a heart rate monitor? For me, MFP often overestimates my calories burned. If I do 45 minutes on my stationary bike, MFP tells me it's something like 600 calories, but the bike came with a chest strap HRM built into it and it would give me about 275 for that same 45 minutes. MFPs calories burned are just estimates and aren't necessarily going to be accurate. If I were you I'd invest in an HRM, or only eat back about half of the exercise calories for awhile and see if that makes a difference.0 -
I think there's a good trend here of responses. We all believe the estimated calories burned during exercise varies for many people. I think you could easily eat 1800-2000ish calories, feel good and see results.0
-
First, if you weren't exercising before and are now working out for an hour or more, it's very possible that the weight gain is due to water retention in your muscles. You're working them harder than they're used to so it's kind of akin to spraining an ankle - when that happens, fluid builds up and your ankle swells, right? Same thing happens with your muscle tissues, it's just not as obvious to the naked eye. Make sure you're drinking plenty of water, and even drink a bit extra on workout days, and once the workouts are routine, you won't retain that fluid as much.
Also, as someone else mentioned, track your sodium if you're not already. A couple high sodium days can throw your weight WAY off. You can't know the cause if you're not tracking it. And again, plan and react correctly with water. If you know you're making something high in sodium or going out to eat, drink plenty of water that day and keep drinking a little extra for the next day or two until your levels are stable again. I can usually tell because my rings are tight, my eyes are a bit dry and as long as I start drinking water right away, I'll pee like 6 times before lunch.
And, the other source of water retention is TOM - be conscious of your cycle. Some also retain a bit more than usual during ovulation. Just something to keep in mind.
As far as your exercise calories go, if you think that's too much food you have a couple options. One, only eat back 1/2 to 2/3rds of the calories MFP gives you - the number might be a bit high anyway. Two, start planning for your workout days by getting in a few more calorie dense meals/snacks like nuts.0 -
I've been eating 1200 calories and only eating my exercise calories back every now and then.
If I eat above that, I gain or stay at the same weight. I'm not lifting weight right now though, so I might be able to add calories back in once I do that.0 -
And, the other source of water retention is TOM - be conscious of your cycle. Some also retain a bit more than usual during ovulation. Just something to keep in mind.
This is me. The week after I usually drop 3 or 4 pounds in water weight.0 -
How are you estimating your calories burned? Do you use a heart rate monitor? For me, MFP often overestimates my calories burned. If I do 45 minutes on my stationary bike, MFP tells me it's something like 600 calories, but the bike came with a chest strap HRM built into it and it would give me about 275 for that same 45 minutes. MFPs calories burned are just estimates and aren't necessarily going to be accurate. If I were you I'd invest in an HRM, or only eat back about half of the exercise calories for awhile and see if that makes a difference.
that is the biggest discrepancy I have seen anyone state as far as actual calories burned vs MFP stated...I really hope that's not true...I at least thought the estimates were in the ball park o_O0 -
I don't trust the MFP exercise calculator, so I just set my calories to custom and use the Fat2Fit # (I think it is TDEE-20%) for calories and I don't log my exercise (which is at least 60 minutes 3x a week plus walks almost daily). That gives me a high window (1970 daily, I am 160 and 5'7).
I also set my macros to 45(carbs)/30(Fat)/25(Protein), otherwise I won't eat nearly enough protein.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions