Dessert off limits?

tsakara7
tsakara7 Posts: 3
edited December 19 in Food and Nutrition
I read an article about weight loss and was a bit skeptical whan it said that you can still have desserts even when trying to lose significant amounts of weight (not just 5 or 10 lbs). I have sworn off all sweets because I thought it was necessary to limit or eliminate sugar as much as possible. I am currently not using any added sugar in any of my foods. Do you think its possible to eat sweets/desserts at all while trying to lose weight?
«1

Replies

  • mayerel
    mayerel Posts: 254 Member
    If it weren't, I wouldn't!! I still eat sweets, something sweet everyday!! In fact a had cookies today!! :noway: Calories in, calories out.

    You just need to control the portion size and often something smaller and richer can be more satisfying than something bigger, think a smaller piece of dark chocolate vs. a Hersey's bar!
  • neanderthin
    neanderthin Posts: 10,262 Member
    Sure you can, unless you have a problem controlling your portions.
  • cyclerjenn
    cyclerjenn Posts: 833 Member
    I love my sweets, if I were to cut out all foods I love, I would hate this. Just spend a little more time working out so you can enjoy the foods you like. The key is moderation!
  • riadastfu
    riadastfu Posts: 69
    Calories are what matter. The source, not so much.

    Remember that guy in the news who lost a lot of weight being on a "Cookie Diet"? ANd the guy who lost 27 lbs on the "Twinkie Diet" (whose cholesterol actually became better LOL) http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html.
  • Absolutely. Dieting isn't supposed to be a temporary solution -- "I'll get to X weight and then I can eat whatever I want again!" -- it's meant to be a lifestyle change. So, the way you eat and the stuff you eat while on a diet is meant to be how you're gonna eat even after you lose weight.

    So if you look at that and think "I'll never get to eat a pizza/chocolate bar/piece of cake/fries EVER AGAIN!" you are setting yourself up for failure. The more you deprive yourself, the more you will wear down your willpower and make it steadily harder to stay the course.

    Dieting is more about learning to moderate your food intake. Instead of eating half a package of Oreos, eat one. Instead of a giant slice of cake and a side of ice cream at the birthday party, share a slice with someone else and skip the ice cream. Or vice versa.

    Know your weaknesses, though, and definitely stay away from those until you get used to eating differently. If you LOVE a particular brand of sweet/chips/soda/cocktail what have you, and know you're not going to be able to stop at "just one", then avoid it.

    The best way to add treats into your diet is to plan your meals out ahead. I've included a soda for lunch into my meal plan and not gone over my daily calories because I tracked what I'd eat before I ate it. :) Plan around these treats, and it'll release the guilt and allow you to enjoy it, and reduce the chance of binging. You've already written down how much you can eat!
  • student94
    student94 Posts: 120 Member
    I eat sweets and lose. I'm all about moderation. My typical desserts are things like: no sugar added baked apples, banana 'ice cream', a serving of my favorite sugar cereal, or a piece or two of candy.
  • RunHardBeStrong
    RunHardBeStrong Posts: 33,069 Member
    I've lost 104 lbs and still eat sweets most everyday. Just a bit but I still have them, there are days I eat more than a bit. It still comes down to burning more calories then you take in.
  • melsinct
    melsinct Posts: 3,512 Member
    Absolutely. Dieting isn't supposed to be a temporary solution -- "I'll get to X weight and then I can eat whatever I want again!" -- it's meant to be a lifestyle change. So, the way you eat and the stuff you eat while on a diet is meant to be how you're gonna eat even after you lose weight.

    Exactly. If you treat this as a "diet" that is temporary, guess what will happen when you get to your goal weight and declare the diet over? You'll gain it all back! You need to learn how to eat REASONABLE portions of the not so good for you stuff while balancing it out with the healthy stuff.

    For the record, I lost 30 pounds and have been maintaining that loss for 3 months now, all while never giving up desserts, wine, potato chips, etc. Do I have that stuff every day? Absolutely not. But I sure make room for it here and there.
  • kandi810
    kandi810 Posts: 70 Member
    Buy a box of angel food cake and a box of your favorite flavor of cake. Put both into one ziploc and shake them together really well. In a LARGE coffee mug put 3 Tablespoons of cake and 2 Tablespoons of water. Mix until frothy. Microwave for one minute. OMIGOSH so good and 140 calories for strawberry cake!
  • Spanaval
    Spanaval Posts: 1,200 Member
    No one would want to be around me if I don't satisfy my sweet tooth. Not much point to being thin/fit and b*tchy.
  • myfitnessnmhoy
    myfitnessnmhoy Posts: 2,105 Member
    I read an article about weight loss and was a bit skeptical whan it said that you can still have desserts even when trying to lose significant amounts of weight (not just 5 or 10 lbs). I have sworn off all sweets because I thought it was necessary to limit or eliminate sugar as much as possible. I am currently not using any added sugar in any of my foods. Do you think its possible to eat sweets/desserts at all while trying to lose weight?

    Yes, yes, and emphatically HELL YES!!!!!

    Sorry. Let me calm down a bit. Just finished a heavy workout. To earn dessert.

    Look, this site isn't about losing weight. Well, OK, it is, but it's about LEARNING HOW to lose weight in a way that will allow you to KEEP the weight off.

    If you give up anything "for your diet", then you'll go back to it "after your diet". And if you go back to it, I absolutely 100% guarantee you will go back to YOUR OLD WEIGHT that you just put all this work into getting rid of.

    Call me Mr. Yo-Yo. I have 30+ years of experience in this. I'm a card-carrying, hard-barrelling, beer-gutted middle aged idiot who has been struggling with weight since I was eleven years old. I lose 40 pounds on a "diet", I gain 50 over the next year. I work my tushie off and lose 60, I gain 50 back. Three years later, I'm the same person I started as, only with battle scars for all the hard work I put into "dieting". I've never resorted to pills or gimmicks, thank goodness, but I've done the "iron man tough it out exercise more deny everything" diet more times than I can remember.

    This is a lifestyle change. Your diet has to become both reasonable and something you can live with for the rest of your life. Make huge sacrifices now, and I guarantee you'll be back here a year after you reached your goal weight with a post entitled "starting over". I could write it for you now, if you like. I've got it memorized. "this time, I will deny myself even more and lose the weight even faster!"

    Eat dessert, as long as you can find a way to fit it in your caloric budget. Because when you reach your goal, you're going to want dessert, and you'll know exactly how much of it you can eat without gaining the weight back.
  • Brandicaloriecountess
    Brandicaloriecountess Posts: 2,126 Member
    I eat dessert everyday, I just make it low cal and control the portion.
  • myfitnessnmhoy
    myfitnessnmhoy Posts: 2,105 Member
    Calories are what matter. The source, not so much.

    This is very true. Having said that, balancing fat and carbs and proteins in reasonable proportions does make it a whole lot easier to keep within those caloric budgets without hunger, and of course there are long-term implications to starving yourself of specific nutrients.

    But as far as pure weight loss, it's all about calories in - calories burned.
  • laceylou0702
    laceylou0702 Posts: 226 Member
    I still eat sweets, pizza, ect. I have found that some good treats are fudgesicles, chocolate almonds, I have been finding fun size Charleston Chews (yummo) or I have a bite size piece of candy here and there. I rarely buy or keep that stuff in my house tho because I have LITTLE CONTROL! Oh I also get a kids sized ice cream cone with a cake cone again it's not done every day.
  • laceylou0702
    laceylou0702 Posts: 226 Member
    Buy a box of angel food cake and a box of your favorite flavor of cake. Put both into one ziploc and shake them together really well. In a LARGE coffee mug put 3 Tablespoons of cake and 2 Tablespoons of water. Mix until frothy. Microwave for one minute. OMIGOSH so good and 140 calories for strawberry cake!

    ^^Are you an angel??? That is awesome!!!!!!!!
  • medaglia_06
    medaglia_06 Posts: 282 Member
    If I cut everything out I would stick with it. I still eat sweets (and salty snacks) I just make sure they fit into my calories for the day (or I exercise more to burn them off). Either way, I'm losing just fine :)
  • MissC787
    MissC787 Posts: 175 Member
    The last few days I have been sick, and have struggled eating all of my calories. Regaurdless of all that I planned on having a small piece of cake today. It is my Birthday. So.... why not? :)
  • odonogc
    odonogc Posts: 223 Member
    It's not fun, but I think cutting out sweets is the most important thing I did when getting to my goal weight. For me, the less i have them, the less i want them, and I really wanted to get out of the habit of needing something sweet every day.

    Now that I'm in maint, I'm playing around with small amounts of sweets, but it makes me nervous to be honest!!
  • UponThisRock
    UponThisRock Posts: 4,519 Member
    I can, but I'm special. All you mere mortals can't do what I do.
  • ShannonMpls
    ShannonMpls Posts: 1,936 Member
    I've had a sweet treat after dinner virtually every night since I've started. And as you can see from my ticker, it's not been a problem.
  • myfitnessnmhoy
    myfitnessnmhoy Posts: 2,105 Member
    Dessert before: 1 full pour of Merlot (12-13 ounces). 1 small bowl of dark chocolate chips. 1-2 cookies. 1 shot whiskey (single-malt if possible).

    Dessert now: 1 5-ounce pour of the same Merlot. Between 10 and 40 dark chocolate chips (5 calories a whack, and YES I count them). 1 cookie if I have lots of calories left.

    Dessert in maintenance after I get my 1000 calories back: 1 5-ounce pour of Merlot. 40 dark chocolate chips. 1 cookie. 1 shot whiskey.

    The only thing I've given up is the shot of single-malt, but I've already purchased a smaller shot glass and worked out the calories for a sweet, sweet nightly shot from the very expensive bottle of single malt I'm going to buy myself when I reach goal.

    My diet is for life. My life includes dessert.
  • Oh man, if dessert was off limits I'd be in huge trouble! Total depravity = failure, at least for me. It just makes me want it more.

    So...I've found some super low calorie - and DELICIOUS!! - substitutes. Try Skinny Cow brand...all of their stuff is delicious, from the candy bars to the ice cream sandwiches...and not one thing I've tried was more than 140 calories (I do believe there are some ice cream bars that are 150 calories, but even still, for dessert, that's pretty low).

    Also, I just tried a Fiber One brownie today, and it was only 90 calories, and soooo good!!
  • sarah44254
    sarah44254 Posts: 3,078 Member
    Somedays all I eat is sugar and candies. Chocolates and ice creams.

    I still lose weight. Yep.

    Just not as healthy as I could be. Not as healthy as I want to be. But definitely a smaller weight.
  • timadotcom
    timadotcom Posts: 653 Member
    Anyone who is friends with me knows that I am an ice-cream-aholic and I do not mean the low fat kind either... an ice cream session usually contains 600 - 800 cals worth of this sweet goodness.... but I just make sure that my workouts account for this. My diary is open for viewing... and I have still lost weight!
  • UsedToBeHusky
    UsedToBeHusky Posts: 15,228 Member
    Sugar does not interfere with your weight loss. Neither do carbs or fats or protein. You want to watch your sugar if your body is insulin resistant... and sugary sweets have a tendency to be high in calories so you really can't do a lot at one time. But you don't have to swear off of sugar to lose weight. I refuse to give up chocolate. Also, there are lots of recipes for desserts that are low calorie or sugar free. Eating sweets while attempting to lose weight is all about self control. If you can eat one or two fun-size candy bars and not scarf down the whole bag, then you are alright. If sweets lead to binging, then you might want to avoid them.
  • flyingwrite
    flyingwrite Posts: 264
    I eat some type of dessert every day, sometimes twice a day. If we go out, I might eat half a piece of pie instead of the whole piece or if I've worked really hard that day/week, I'll have the whole piece. I eat different desserts than I used to, but at the end of the day, I feel good about what I eat and how much weight I've lost. To me, THAT's what matters.
  • Tropical_Turtle
    Tropical_Turtle Posts: 2,236 Member
    Why deny yourself? That is a great way to set yourself up for failure. Just allow sweets into your calories for the day.
  • KyleB65
    KyleB65 Posts: 1,196 Member
    Yes, you can eat some sweets and still lose weight.

    I have done so.

    However, quantity, quality and frequency all come into play here.

    I LOVE Oero cookies! So, every now and then I will have 2 - 3 with a glass of milk. The milk is now 1% and the 2 - 3 cookies is down from the 6 - 8 at a time I used to eat.

    And, my wife and children will bring home other sweet treats that I will try as well. Ice Cream, donuts, cake, etc. But, my portions are small.

    In addition, I have found that I have replaced my old desert sweet tooth with a fruit sweet tooth. I have no science to back it up but I believe that these whole food natural forms of sugar are much better for my system than any of the processed sugars and syrups used in fabricated and boxed foods.
  • dmest
    dmest Posts: 98 Member
    I eat dessert everyday but keep the portions small. Dove dark chocolate promises are great. I also like Trader Joe's mini ice cream cones, Godiva Dark Chocolate pearls and See's lollipops. All are very satisfying treats that can easily be added into your daily calories. The Godiva pearls are super low in calories if you want a tiny treat.
This discussion has been closed.