We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Protein Shakes and Bars! Question?

raayfrancy
raayfrancy Posts: 100
edited December 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
Hey! This might sound like a silly question(s)... but protein shakes and bars won't make me bulk up over time, will they?
Also, would it be a bad idea to eat a (muscle milk) protein bar after having a protein shake earlier that day?

I work out every day.
I just don't want to get a masculine build! Haha.. So I had to ask.

Replies

  • sabotai
    sabotai Posts: 25
    They are fine, protein heals and is very smart for after workouts. It would only bulk you up if you ate a lot with it and did heavy lifting and needed it for muscle healing. I actually started losing more weight when I started using protein after my workouts.
  • raayfrancy
    raayfrancy Posts: 100
    They are fine, protein heals and is very smart for after workouts. It would only bulk you up if you ate a lot with it and did heavy lifting and needed it for muscle healing. I actually started losing more weight when I started using protein after my workouts.

    Ohhh! Makes sense. I eat/drink them as a meal, each, on its own. Thank you so much! (:
  • AFitJamie
    AFitJamie Posts: 172 Member
    Women have to work very hard to build muscle and it is *very* unlikely that you would 'bulk up'. Particularly if you are here to lose weight, then you are eating at a calorie deficit. Your body isn't going to build any significant amount of muscle at all when you are eating at a deficit. You need to eat *excess* calories to add muscle mass in any amount. the body simply doesn't create excess muscle while eating at a deficit,

    Supplements should be that - yes I use them, but they are not as good as the 'real thing' they should supplement your diet. Chicken is a great protein.

    Also... I haven't researched this is years so I don't know the current view, but there was a concept floating around a few years ago that your body would burn fat better if it had a 'positive nitrogen balance' which was to mean you were taking in enough protein... That may all be 'bioscience' now, but I find eating more protein helps me... However, I suspect it has more to do with protein being filling and thus I consume fewer overall calories I think...
This discussion has been closed.