We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
What the heck am I doing wrong?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c9ddc/c9ddcd72c49b551c3a8300ebadc7f554d9f043b5" alt="nephilim13"
nephilim13
Posts: 6 Member
Hello everybody,
I would like to tell you my short(?) story, before explain my problem. I dropped out of P.E. at school at the age of 12 and haven't done anything proper in sports since then. At the age of 20 I was at approx 85 - 90 kg at 185 cm and I was happy with it, I gained a bit until the age of 25, but nothing worth mentioning. However I stopped smoking at that age and in under 6 months I gained approx 25 kg.
Now, this year I was finally fed up with all the picking at me and started exercising. Luckily I work in an environment where quite a lot of fitness buffs work, so I asked around if they could give me some advise on how to start properly. I knew that after 20 years of no exercise, I had to start slowly and so I did. I started on 15 February and weight-in at 124.4 kg.
Now here is what I have done:
- until March 29th I walked at a good pace on the treadmill for 20 mins. and continued on the cross trainer for another 20 mins.
- until April 21st I did 2 x 20 mins on the cross trainer (cross ramp 10, resistance 11, strides/min 110)
On April 21st I received a fitness plan and a proper introduction from a colleague of mine. I said, that I couldn't see any results, my weight hadn't changed and I felt even bigger than before. Ever since that day I have been exercising like a mad man, well, at least I thought I did ;-)
Now, I currently exercise as follows (the following in three repetitions):
Even Days:
- Cross Trainer (cross ramp 4, resistance 12, strides/min 120) [pulse ~130]
- Lat Pull @ 50 kg - 12 reps
- Abs Trainer @ 70 kg - 12 reps
- Leg press @ 90 kg - 12 reps
Odd Days:
- Cross Trainer (cross ramp 4, resistance 12, strides/min 120) [pulse ~130]
- Sit Ups - 12 reps / 3 sets / 1 min break
Weekends are off.
Now, I am not very good in changing many things at once so I decided I gave MFP a try and let it help me keep track of my food. I should mention that I grew up on a farm and there was always(!) meat on the table and salad was ... well I guess you get my point.
Anyway, I tracked what MFP told me and I usually finish a day at 800 - 1000 kcal remaining. However, I come from a Coca Cola addiction and went down from at least 2.5 l per day to approx. 0.5 l per day.
I started this exercise at 124.4 kg with a waist of 122 cm (I don't care much for the rest). As of today I am at 125.3 kg and 117 cm and I only have one question: WTF? Sorry for my foul mouth, but I trained 3 months now and I don't really see corresponding results. I am shocked to say the least.
Feel free to ask as many (silly) questions as possible, I will answer them truthfully, I JUST WANT TO LOOSE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE!!!! Volume more than weight, to be honest.
Please help?!
I would like to tell you my short(?) story, before explain my problem. I dropped out of P.E. at school at the age of 12 and haven't done anything proper in sports since then. At the age of 20 I was at approx 85 - 90 kg at 185 cm and I was happy with it, I gained a bit until the age of 25, but nothing worth mentioning. However I stopped smoking at that age and in under 6 months I gained approx 25 kg.
Now, this year I was finally fed up with all the picking at me and started exercising. Luckily I work in an environment where quite a lot of fitness buffs work, so I asked around if they could give me some advise on how to start properly. I knew that after 20 years of no exercise, I had to start slowly and so I did. I started on 15 February and weight-in at 124.4 kg.
Now here is what I have done:
- until March 29th I walked at a good pace on the treadmill for 20 mins. and continued on the cross trainer for another 20 mins.
- until April 21st I did 2 x 20 mins on the cross trainer (cross ramp 10, resistance 11, strides/min 110)
On April 21st I received a fitness plan and a proper introduction from a colleague of mine. I said, that I couldn't see any results, my weight hadn't changed and I felt even bigger than before. Ever since that day I have been exercising like a mad man, well, at least I thought I did ;-)
Now, I currently exercise as follows (the following in three repetitions):
Even Days:
- Cross Trainer (cross ramp 4, resistance 12, strides/min 120) [pulse ~130]
- Lat Pull @ 50 kg - 12 reps
- Abs Trainer @ 70 kg - 12 reps
- Leg press @ 90 kg - 12 reps
Odd Days:
- Cross Trainer (cross ramp 4, resistance 12, strides/min 120) [pulse ~130]
- Sit Ups - 12 reps / 3 sets / 1 min break
Weekends are off.
Now, I am not very good in changing many things at once so I decided I gave MFP a try and let it help me keep track of my food. I should mention that I grew up on a farm and there was always(!) meat on the table and salad was ... well I guess you get my point.
Anyway, I tracked what MFP told me and I usually finish a day at 800 - 1000 kcal remaining. However, I come from a Coca Cola addiction and went down from at least 2.5 l per day to approx. 0.5 l per day.
I started this exercise at 124.4 kg with a waist of 122 cm (I don't care much for the rest). As of today I am at 125.3 kg and 117 cm and I only have one question: WTF? Sorry for my foul mouth, but I trained 3 months now and I don't really see corresponding results. I am shocked to say the least.
Feel free to ask as many (silly) questions as possible, I will answer them truthfully, I JUST WANT TO LOOSE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE!!!! Volume more than weight, to be honest.
Please help?!
0
Replies
-
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/3047-700-calories-a-day-and-not-losing
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/6556-the-answers-to-the-questions
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/9433-expectations
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/10589-for-those-confused-or-questioning-eating-your-exercise-calo0 -
Thanks dls for the quick reply. Now I read through these topics and here are some "counter" arguments:
a) Eat your calories because MFP says so:
I do! MFP tells me to eat 2300 kcal. I have an input of ~2100. However MFP also tells me I lost 1200 while excercising.
b) Eat proper food:
Well, yeah! I don't do breakfast, but I have a proper dinner and a somewhat decent lunch. I used to be the lunch=McDonald's type of guy, but I changed that to, well lunch=Subway. i know I could do a lot better.
c) Weight vs Volume, or Scale vs measuring tape:
5-8 cm in 3 months. That does not sound right. Or do I not exercise enough?
Actually, c is my whole point. I have done this for 3 months now and I think the visible and measurable progress is way to low and I don't know why. I don't want a revolution, but I am doing so much more than before, it just has to be more visible.
I don't drink alcohol, I cut down own Coke, I eat less and healthier, I exercise like as if my stronger and fitter evil-twin is plotting to kill me. And I only lost 5 cm. Having seen quite a few of the success stories here, I just feel ... ashamed(?)
Cheers and THANK YOU0 -
Can't see your diary and I'm no expert anyway... but my best guess is that you're having issues with over/ underestimating.
Food is the super important area not to underestimate.
Be as honest as you can be and OVERestimate your food intake if you're EVER unsure.
Goodluck xxx0 -
I've been reading online that 1-3 tsp of apple cider vinegar before every meal can help promote weight loss because it boosts metabolism and promotes a feeling of fullness. I personally heat up 1 cup of water, add 2 tsp of honey and 2 tsp of apple cider vinegar. It tastes like regular hot apple cider to me so I can drink it. I just started this the other day so I can't confirm everything I've read about it especially when it comes to weight loss, but I do think there are some definite health benefits. It's important to buy organic, unpasturized apple cider vinegar. Bragg's is the brand that I use. I suggest doing some research on it and then deciding for yourself if it's worth a try
I wish you the best in your weight loss journey!
0 -
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/3047-700-calories-a-day-and-not-losing
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/6556-the-answers-to-the-questions
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/9433-expectations
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/10589-for-those-confused-or-questioning-eating-your-exercise-calo
I love that you post these. They should be a "must read" for everyone who signs up.0 -
Input
I used to eat a e.g. whole chicken and two small french breads for lunch. I cut that in half and feel fine.
I haven't been to McDonald's, Burger King, KFC or any other fast food parlor, besides Subway twice, in over a month.
I used to drink 2.5 l of Coke and am down to 1 can.
I don't do any alcohol.
I don't eat any chocolate any more.
if I eat chips, I eat one small pack instead of a big one.
etc. etc. etc.
Output
I burn at least a thousand kcal more on a single day than I used to.
Now shouldn't all that be enough to see more than the few cm I described?0 -
@jjelizalde: I agree, but is it so wrong to follow the simple routine of "eat less/proper and exercise more". I mean I don't want to loose 5 kg, I want to go down 30 kg. Not in 6 months of course, that would be stupid, but I have a lot to loose and I am not loosing it.0
-
Have you seen a doctor? dietitian? Maybe one could shed some light on your situation.0
-
@jjelizalde: I agree, but is it so wrong to follow the simple routine of "eat less/proper and exercise more". I mean I don't want to loose 5 kg, I want to go down 30 kg. Not in 6 months of course, that would be stupid, but I have a lot to loose and I am not loosing it.
That's not wrong at all. Sometimes you have to make adjustments to find what works for your body and reading/researching different methods can be beneficial. That's the point of MVP - support and information.0 -
Okay, I will change to more "green" stuff then. I hope that is of some help. I spoke to some of our fitness buffs at work and they couldn't see anything wrong with what I am doing, besides some food issues.
In MFP I explicitly drive a "conservative" approach. Let's say I cannot find "homemade fries", but "mcdonald's fries" I use these, because I think they will have more calories. If the cardio machine says I burned 500 kcal and MFP tells me it is 600 kcal, I use the lower value. However, it matches most of the time, so not too many worries there.
Thank you for your support, that was exactly what I needed.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.9K Getting Started
- 260.4K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 440 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.7K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions