Exercise Machine and MFP difference in calorie burn?

Does anyone know how many calories the machines are off rather than using MFP or a heart rate monitor? I wish I could afford one but right now I can't :(

Replies

  • Angie_1MR
    Angie_1MR Posts: 247
    A friend of mine uses a HRM and told me to cut the burn the machine tells you in HALF! That sucks, doesn't it?
  • sportybrewerschick
    sportybrewerschick Posts: 170 Member
    A friend of mine uses a HRM and told me to cut the burn the machine tells you in HALF! That sucks, doesn't it?

    OH MY GOSH! really?!
  • Angie_1MR
    Angie_1MR Posts: 247
    That's what she told me, I about fell over!! I don't know how true it is, but I have found her to be reliable when it comes to things like that.
  • kamoira23
    kamoira23 Posts: 193
    Yeah, I've found that my HRM is usually about half of what the estimates on MFP and the machines say. :/
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    Calorie burn depends upon several factors: height, weight, gender, age, and fitness level. Some machines ask you to input some of this info ... other machines use defaults.

    You have 2 choices: Adjust MFP or machine numbers down to factor in the overstatement, or invest in a heart rate monitor (chest strap is most accurate).
  • guapogringo
    guapogringo Posts: 201
    I am sure it depends on the machine and the HRM. My treadmill reads about 110% of what my HRM reads. Of course the HRM is set up specifically for me, age, weight, etc. Nothing will be 100% accurate. Go here and enter your speed & time and see what is says and let us know

    http://www.fitnessmagazine.com/weight-loss/caloric-needs-calculator/?ordersrc=googleslinks01caloriesburned&s_kwcid=TC|6020|how%20many%20calories%20did%20i%20burn%20calculator||S|b|8238031618
  • kristen_lynn
    kristen_lynn Posts: 75 Member
    i've found that MFP overestimates and the machines underestimate. this is just me personally, it's gonna vary with everyone depending on a lot of different factors -- your weight, height, age, how hard you exercise, resting heart rate, etc.... i resisted getting a HRM for a long time, and i finally found one on sale at wal-mart for $50 and it was worth EVERY penny. it's so valuable to know when precisely you're in your calorie-burning zone, and so motivational when you look at your little watch and it says you're 30 calories away from the next 100 mark, instead of quitting, you'll find yourself powering through to round up :) keep an eye on sales, and check ebay/amazon. it's an investment in your health! totally worth it in my humble opinion.