Blood Pressure meds forever?
redraidergirl2009
Posts: 2,560 Member
I probably should have asked this when I was at the doctor eariler but are they something I'll have to take indefinitely? I have stage 2 hypertension and am only 24 and slightly overweight, not even obese and my bmi is 26 (measured, not estimated with calculators). I have gone under lots of testing to try and determine a cause but everything is normal. I am working on losing 10-15lbs so perhaps that will lower it a bit, but are these medications something I'll just always have to take if it doesn't go down on it's own? I'm hoping some weight loss and my new vegan diet will help, but I also don't like the idea of being on medication for it forever, though I do know the dangers I risk of stopping it
0
Replies
-
Probably not, if they are caused by fitness/diet. Fix your diet, start lifting some weights and doing some cardio and your blood pressure will improve.0
-
Do you know if you have sleep apnea? The health effects were discussed at a w/c seminar I attended -speaker stated sleep apnea often causes high blood pressure, low energy levels, weight gain, causing more sleep apnea, high blood pressure, low energy levels, weight gain and so on0
-
You need to see your doctor again. Make a list of questions before you go. Or maybe you could call the office and explain that you forgot to ask a few things. Maybe the doc can give you a quick call so you don't have to make another appointment?
I'm not ragging on you for asking the internet, just saying: Don't listen to random internet people about such a serious health issue (and I'm glad you realize it's serious). Good luck.Probably not, if they are caused by fitness/diet. Fix your diet, start lifting some weights and doing some cardio and your blood pressure will improve.
Um, don't tell someone with stage 2 hypertension to lift weights. Thanks.
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/weightlifting/AN006370 -
Probably not, if they are caused by fitness/diet. Fix your diet, start lifting some weights and doing some cardio and your blood pressure will improve.
I do plenty of Excercise and it hasn't affected my bp.0 -
You need to see your doctor again. Make a list of questions before you go. Or maybe you could call the office and explain that you forgot to ask a few things. Maybe the doc can give you a quick call so you don't have to make another appointment?
I'm not ragging on you for asking the internet, just saying: Don't listen to random internet people about such a serious health issue (and I'm glad you realize it's serious). Good luck.Probably not, if they are caused by fitness/diet. Fix your diet, start lifting some weights and doing some cardio and your blood pressure will improve.
Um, don't tell someone with stage 2 hypertension to lift weights. Thanks.
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/weightlifting/AN00637
I wasn't asking anyone here how to lower it if you'll notice, I was just wondering if other people have just been told to take for x amount of time or if it's something they will always have to take.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.0
-
I was on medication galore.
Lost 50 lbs - guess what?
Like magic I no longer needed meds for BP, cholesterol, sugar - NOTHING!
I am 74 lbs down and feel great. This may not be everybody's experience, but I never thought I would go without medication or sleep without a C-PAP.
Love it :drinker:0 -
I probably should have asked this when I was at the doctor eariler but are they something I'll have to take indefinitely? I have stage 2 hypertension and am only 24 and slightly overweight, not even obese and my bmi is 26 (measured, not estimated with calculators). I have gone under lots of testing to try and determine a cause but everything is normal. I am working on losing 10-15lbs so perhaps that will lower it a bit, but are these medications something I'll just always have to take if it doesn't go down on it's own? I'm hoping some weight loss and my new vegan diet will help, but I also don't like the idea of being on medication for it forever, though I do know the dangers I risk of stopping it
Definitely a good question for the doctor. Sometimes high blood pressure is just a genetic thing and nothing but the meds will help. My husband developed high bp at age 20 while in the Marine Corps. He's now 44, fit, runs competitive races and still has to take a small dose of pb meds. Hopefully you'll be able to come off it.0 -
I'm on blood pressure meds caused by my weight, and even having lost 65 lbs, my blood pressure only stays where it belongs when I'm careful to take my meds every day. I agree that you should get back in touch with your doctor. Anything we tell you is going to be generalizations. Not all HBP is weight related, and yours may not be, but I know in my case, my doctor has advised me to plan to take my little white pill for the rest of my natural life. Small price to pay for my health.0
-
In my experience, my doctor(s) have never put a "time constraint" on the BP meds. I've had the dosages adjusted based on my BP (and she typically checks liver functions once annually since I've been on the meds for about 5 years now). I am "pre-hypertensive" when not medicated (about 130/85) - with meds I've typically bee at about 115/75. I was diagnosed in 2007, while still active-duty militray and pretty physically fit - now that I've been exercising regularly again and have lost some weight, I'm hoping to either have dosage reduced or eliminated later this summer when I got for my next visit.0
-
It depends... If its genetic you are screwed! I was first diagnosed with high blood pressure at 25 and I was in good shape and a healthy weight. Over the years I gained weight and have since lost 30 pounds and am down to where I was at age 25. Still on meds. I just recently went to see a cardiologist to make sure everything else is ok.
If its due to your health state, then you may very well not need to take medication forever and once you are at a healthy weight and BMI you may be ok.
Good luck!0 -
I was first put on BP meds at age 17. Went to a ton of doctors about hypertension in youth, with no results. At that age I was very involved in high school athletics, like football and wrestling. I took the meds evey day until earlier this year, current age 42. With my weight loss and greatly improved level of fitness I was having dizzy spells. After a checking and recording my BP over several months and showing that data to my doctor it was determined that the meds were probably no longer needed. I went to half rate for a while and have been completly off for right at a month. Time will tell, but my BP checks have been right in the range acceptable.
This is my story, and like everything each person will react differently to a given medical condition. I posted this hoping to encourage anyone to keep up the work, it is a worth while battle, and good things can happen.0 -
I have been on beta blockers for arterial hypertension for the last 8 years, and I was a little overweight but not obese when diagnosed (the problem only came to light when I was changing gyms). My weight has dropped considerably in the last year, and although I have seen other health benefits, reduced high blood pressure has not been one of them, probably because this is a genetic disorder.
I take medication for this everyday, its rarely an issue, and does not stop me from doing anything. The only issues I do have with the medication is that I cannot take cold remedies, sleeping tablets nor can I wear a HRM. If I forget to take a tablet I will get a headache and I cannot sleep as I can feel my pulse racing.
I would suggest that you ask your doctor if it is absolutely necessary that you start taking meds as they are difficult to come off of. It may be that your doctor will suggest that you try to get your BP down to acceptable levels naturally before you need to resort to medication.
Good luck.0 -
You are still young, so odds are that weight loss and a proper diet will eventually bring your BP down to the point where you wont have to take meds. If you smoke, quit now. Putting that off is only going to hurt you when you finally do quit. And cut back on salt.
Im 48 and have had high BP since I was in my late 20's. (family history) Until just 3 years ago I rarely if ever took meds. I smoked, ate salty and fattening foods. And didnt exercise too often. Then I had what my doctor called a mild stroke. And I've been taking meds daily since. I also lost 60 pounds, but since my bp isn't coming down on it's own, I am probably gonna be taking lisenopril for ever. It sucks, because I have noticed that when I take my meds, I have a harder time getting my heart rate up. So I end up working out almost twice as hard to achieve the same results when using a heart rate monitor.
To top that off, I am still not used to taking pills. So I forget 2 to 4 times a week. It's at those times when the back of my eyeballs begin to ache, and I feel like someone is shoving a knife thru the back of my head that I remember the pills. So take those meds and hopefully you don't reach this point.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
That is 100% ludicrous. There are plenty of cases where eating a plant HEAVY diet help, cutting out the grains and other processed crap, but to discount meat in such a way is folly.
My sister was in the same boat, overweight most of her life and she turned to being a vegitarian, because everyone thinks it's healthy. Over the course of 10 years being a vegitarian and another 5 being a very strict vegan, she gained 100+ lbs. She had VERY high blood pressure, cholesterol was through the roof and was approaching type 2 diabetes as a permanant fixture in her life. She had mysterious aches and pains constantly and got injured everytime that she tried to loose weight through exercise.
She has since gone to a low carb/paleo style diet and has reversed ALL of these symptoms and also lost 80+ lbs in about a year. Her blood pressure went from 145/97 (!!!!!) to a solid 118/70.
My mother has similar issues, while not overweight, she has higher than normal blood pressure and cholesterol. She's been a vegan for the last 2 years. I've been low carb for over a year, and have cholesterol about 100 points lower than her and my last tested blood pressure was 112/66. Genetics may give a predisposition to have certain issues, but that does not mean that you have to settle for that being normal.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
That is 100% ludicrous. There are plenty of cases where eating a plant HEAVY diet help, cutting out the grains and other processed crap, but to discount meat in such a way is folly.
My sister was in the same boat, overweight most of her life and she turned to being a vegitarian, because everyone thinks it's healthy. Over the course of 10 years being a vegitarian and another 5 being a very strict vegan, she gained 100+ lbs. She had VERY high blood pressure, cholesterol was through the roof and was approaching type 2 diabetes as a permanant fixture in her life. She had mysterious aches and pains constantly and got injured everytime that she tried to loose weight through exercise.
She has since gone to a low carb/paleo style diet and has reversed ALL of these symptoms and also lost 80+ lbs in about a year. Her blood pressure went from 145/97 (!!!!!) to a solid 118/70.
My mother has similar issues, while not overweight, she has higher than normal blood pressure and cholesterol. She's been a vegan for the last 2 years. I've been low carb for over a year, and have cholesterol about 100 points lower than her and my last tested blood pressure was 112/66. Genetics may give a predisposition to have certain issues, but that does not mean that you have to settle for that being normal.
You can be a strict vegan and still eat all the wrong foods, such as refined 'white' foods which are just empty calories. Please read around what meat, animal produce and refined foods do to our bodies before calling this 'ludicrous'.0 -
People have forgotten what it means to eat 'naturally' because about 75% of the food in supermarkets are chemically altered foods. There is a massive difference to being a 'vegan' and living on a plant-based diet. You would absolutely NOT have high cholesterol if the correct foods were being eaten.0
-
Ok. Here we go. I have essential hypertension. That is hypertension where they cannot find the root cause, it's just the way you are. Sounds similar to yours but don't take that for granted. Your doctor should have ordered bloods (don't know which ones) but also renal ultrasound, cholesteral and 24 hour BP monitoring.
If they have not done this there could be a further cause.
When first going on meds for hypertension your doctor should be regularly monitoring your BP. This is essential to make sure you have a cocktail that is right for you. Use these appointments to set limits for your exercise. Once your BP is fully under control and has been for some time, provided you have no other health issues you should be good to go with whatever you want. BUT always check with your doctor.
Some BP meds have side-effects that may affect your desire to train or work hard anyway. These do pass and if they don't then get your doctor to change the med. There are plenty out there and they work in slightly different ways to a different extent person by person.
BP meds can take time to work effectively. For the first few months it is going to be difficult to tell whether any drop in your BP is going to be from diet or weight loss.
Following stabilisation of your BP (staying on the same medication) hopefully you will see a reduction in your BP from your lifestyle changes. I have. It's been slow going but it is creeping down. I lost 2 stone before joining MFP and it has taken a while. I'm getting to the point where my GP is happy to consider reducing the dosage on my meds. It will be a bit of trial and error, but like you I am keen to get off them if I can.
Monitoring your BP will be essential. I invested in a portable BP monitor, took it to the doctors to calibrate it against theirs to be sure of the results. Best thing I ever did. I suffer a little from white coat syndrome and know my BP tends to be lower than in the surgery.
Too low a BP can be as lethal as too high, but you are aware of the risks. Never cut your meds without monitoring and control with your doctor.
Oh and one other thing the absorption of BP meds tends to be severely slowed by grapefruit juice. Don't know why but they are. Make sure you read the documents that accompany yours.
As for diet, that is a personal thing but there are certain foods I was advised to cut back on. mainly to do with fat and salt. No surprises there, my diet at the time wasn't great. I haven't tried any special diets, just calory counted, used moderation and cut out those bad fatty, high sugar foods as well as starting on an exercise regime.
Good luck and feel free to friend me if you think I might be able to help0 -
It really depends on the cause of your high blood pressure. I have hereditary high blood pressure (EVERY other number has ALWAYS been normal, even at my highest weight, including cholesterol, triglycerides, blood sugar, hdl, and ldl). I will be on meds for the rest of my life, no matter how healthy I become. In fact, the more weight I have been losing, the higher my blood pressure has gotten. I just had to have my dosage raised last week. *sigh* For your sake, I hope yours is caused by your diet/fitness level, and that once those change, you will be able to come off of the meds.0
-
People have forgotten what it means to eat 'naturally' because about 75% of the food in supermarkets are chemically altered foods. There is a massive difference to being a 'vegan' and living on a plant-based diet. You would absolutely NOT have high cholesterol if the correct foods were being eaten.
Who has high cholesterol? I thought this thread was about high blood pressure / hypertension.0 -
People have forgotten what it means to eat 'naturally' because about 75% of the food in supermarkets are chemically altered foods. There is a massive difference to being a 'vegan' and living on a plant-based diet. You would absolutely NOT have high cholesterol if the correct foods were being eaten.
Who has high cholesterol? I thought this thread was about high blood pressure / hypertension.
Someone related to someone who replied to my previous post. Apologies, I should have quoted.0 -
If you're on hormonal birth control, you may want to talk to your doctor about alternatives. High blood pressure can be caused (or contributed to) by the pill/patch/ring. Some people find that coming off of birth control is enough to control their blood pressure. There are plenty of hormone-free alternatives (including the IUD which is MORE effective than the pill) if you are interested in exploring them!0
-
Maybe, maybe not. When I was at 179lbs I was maxed out on one med and taking one other, both for high blood pressure. I've lost almost 40lbs (weigh 142 now) and was able to drop the 2nd pill. I'm getting close to my goal weight and my blood pressure has not budged and I was depressed and told my Dr. I didn't understand why it hadn't gone down more. She explained to me that some people inherit a type of high blood pressure that usually begins in your late 40's, 50's and no amount of weight loss will change that. . I'm 50 years old and still hopeful that as I lose more weight it will continue to go down but I now realize it may not. I can however still do things to control it by taking my meds regularly, reducing stress and limiting my sodium. High blood pressure can and WILL damage your brain, heart, arteries, kidneys, etc. and KILL you. There are worse things to have to live with and you can LIVE with controlled high blood pressure.
You are young and it's not likely that you'd still have it after weight loss. Keep working towards being healthy, keep checking in with your Dr., keep taking your meds, etc. If you get to a point that you no longer need the meds, you'll know it. You will get dizzy and nearly pass out everytime you stand up! Be careful if that happens and if it goes on for more than a few days, call your Dr. to see if you can lower the strength of the meds, or go off them with his/her blessing.
Good luck and I pray it goes down for you.
Editing to add that when I was younger and even at 150+ lbs, I always had normal blood pressure. It was usally 120/80 or less. Then when I was 48, it went SKY HIGH for no reason. One day it was normal, the next it was 200/109! It stayed up there and over a few months was gradually controlled with the right doses of medication. I have had all the tests to see why it went up, kidney tumors, you name it and they found no reason. I think for me, it's going to be a lifetime of dealing with it but like I said earlier, there are much worse things to deal with healthwise. I'll take one that can be controlled with a pill and less salt.0 -
It depends. I was diagnosed with high blood pressure at 26 years old. At the time, I weighed 137lbs and ran 25 miles a week and had an impeccable whole foods, low sodium diet. For me, it's genetics that cause the high blood pressure. My diet wasn't a factor and there were no other secondary causes. I will be on the meds for the rest of my life. There are other young people in my family in the same boat.
you may loose 15lbs and your blood pressure may come down to a safe place. Or it may not. If your problem is genetics, then it won't come down with diet and exercise (that being said, a poor diet and lack of exercise can still make it worse).
Talk to your doctor. If you do have to be on meds forever, there are a lot of options out there and some have less side effects than others. It does suck to be young and know you need to take a pill everyday, but it would be a lot worse to damage your heart or kidneys by not treating it. High blood pressure is serious stuff and the sooner you take care of it, the less damage you will do to your body.0 -
Everyone on my fathers side of the family has high blood pressure problems. In Jan I was having some blood pressure issues out of no where (stress related). But my docter talk to me about my family history and things I could start doing now to get it under control and to maintain it. The best thing she recommended was the DASH diet- (Dietary Action to Stop Hypertension) and 30 minutes min. of daily excerise. I am back to normally and actually have some of the lowest blood pressures on file. We were able to see a difference in my blood pressure in a matter of weeks. The best part is everyrhing you need for it is downloadable. (http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/public/heart/hbp/dash/new_dash.pdf) I goggled everything - cost effective and instant.
I would definitely make another appointment with your Dr. to get additional information about your hypertension. Any additional recommendations he has for BP maintainance that wouldn't include medication. My physcian knows I only want to take medication if there is no alternative, so maybe he didn't think of recommending natural solutions for you.
Best of luck with your blood pressure!!! Hopefully you can get it under control quickly.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
That is 100% ludicrous. There are plenty of cases where eating a plant HEAVY diet help, cutting out the grains and other processed crap, but to discount meat in such a way is folly.
My sister was in the same boat, overweight most of her life and she turned to being a vegitarian, because everyone thinks it's healthy. Over the course of 10 years being a vegitarian and another 5 being a very strict vegan, she gained 100+ lbs. She had VERY high blood pressure, cholesterol was through the roof and was approaching type 2 diabetes as a permanant fixture in her life. She had mysterious aches and pains constantly and got injured everytime that she tried to loose weight through exercise.
She has since gone to a low carb/paleo style diet and has reversed ALL of these symptoms and also lost 80+ lbs in about a year. Her blood pressure went from 145/97 (!!!!!) to a solid 118/70.
My mother has similar issues, while not overweight, she has higher than normal blood pressure and cholesterol. She's been a vegan for the last 2 years. I've been low carb for over a year, and have cholesterol about 100 points lower than her and my last tested blood pressure was 112/66. Genetics may give a predisposition to have certain issues, but that does not mean that you have to settle for that being normal.
You can be a strict vegan and still eat all the wrong foods, such as refined 'white' foods which are just empty calories. Please read around what meat, animal produce and refined foods do to our bodies before calling this 'ludicrous'.
You can read all you want, and this thread is probably not the place to debate it, but cutting out meat from the diet of a human is just plain stupid, and defending it with pseudo science makes even less sense.
You can argue all day long that meat is bad for you, but there is no actual evidence of such in ways that are actually meaningful. You can skew any study to fit an agenda, but real world experience shows me otherwise. My mother is a VERY clean eater. The only thing processed that she even buys is organic dark chocolate and organic multi-grain bread. The rest of her diet consists of fruits and vegtables. Puzzle that one out professor...
We can certainly agree though that processed foods are horrible, and should be eliminated and "white" foods should be avoided. I'm all for a VERY heavy plant based diet, but meat should find its way to the table regularly, with all the fat, connective tissue and skin in tact for consumption.
It is not a coincidence that many of the vital vitamins and nutrients that humans need to live are FAT SOLUABLE. And the fact that you cannot get vitamin B12 from a plant source (unless man created and processed, which if your argument is to stay true to itself, processed foods and such should be avoided...). WIthout vitamin B12, or a severe deficiency of it, humans WILL DIE. This is not conjecture, but pure cold hard fact. Seems to me that to get that in a natural, unprocessed, not man made or assisted, you'll need to eat some meat.
I'm fine with vegans eating that way for moral purposes, if they believe strongly that animals should not be killed for their dietary needs, I get that, but to say that something like that is the healthiest way to eat in the face of facts that would state otherwise, in the face of the GAPING hole in the argument (missing vital nutrients that have to be supplemented and fortified into vegan foods) is not only niave, but quite frankly irresponsible.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
In my original post I said I just started a vegan diet0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
That is 100% ludicrous. There are plenty of cases where eating a plant HEAVY diet help, cutting out the grains and other processed crap, but to discount meat in such a way is folly.
My sister was in the same boat, overweight most of her life and she turned to being a vegitarian, because everyone thinks it's healthy. Over the course of 10 years being a vegitarian and another 5 being a very strict vegan, she gained 100+ lbs. She had VERY high blood pressure, cholesterol was through the roof and was approaching type 2 diabetes as a permanant fixture in her life. She had mysterious aches and pains constantly and got injured everytime that she tried to loose weight through exercise.
She has since gone to a low carb/paleo style diet and has reversed ALL of these symptoms and also lost 80+ lbs in about a year. Her blood pressure went from 145/97 (!!!!!) to a solid 118/70.
My mother has similar issues, while not overweight, she has higher than normal blood pressure and cholesterol. She's been a vegan for the last 2 years. I've been low carb for over a year, and have cholesterol about 100 points lower than her and my last tested blood pressure was 112/66. Genetics may give a predisposition to have certain issues, but that does not mean that you have to settle for that being normal.
You can be a strict vegan and still eat all the wrong foods, such as refined 'white' foods which are just empty calories. Please read around what meat, animal produce and refined foods do to our bodies before calling this 'ludicrous'.
You can read all you want, and this thread is probably not the place to debate it, but cutting out meat from the diet of a human is just plain stupid, and defending it with pseudo science makes even less sense.
You can argue all day long that meat is bad for you, but there is no actual evidence of such in ways that are actually meaningful. You can skew any study to fit an agenda, but real world experience shows me otherwise. My mother is a VERY clean eater. The only thing processed that she even buys is organic dark chocolate and organic multi-grain bread. The rest of her diet consists of fruits and vegtables. Puzzle that one out professor...
We can certainly agree though that processed foods are horrible, and should be eliminated and "white" foods should be avoided. I'm all for a VERY heavy plant based diet, but meat should find its way to the table regularly, with all the fat, connective tissue and skin in tact for consumption.
It is not a coincidence that many of the vital vitamins and nutrients that humans need to live are FAT SOLUABLE. And the fact that you cannot get vitamin B12 from a plant source (unless man created and processed, which if your argument is to stay true to itself, processed foods and such should be avoided...). WIthout vitamin B12, or a severe deficiency of it, humans WILL DIE. This is not conjecture, but pure cold hard fact. Seems to me that to get that in a natural, unprocessed, not man made or assisted, you'll need to eat some meat.
I'm fine with vegans eating that way for moral purposes, if they believe strongly that animals should not be killed for their dietary needs, I get that, but to say that something like that is the healthiest way to eat in the face of facts that would state otherwise, in the face of the GAPING hole in the argument (missing vital nutrients that have to be supplemented and fortified into vegan foods) is not only niave, but quite frankly irresponsible.
Vitamin B12 is a microbe that doesn't come from animals or plants:
http://ezinearticles.com/?The-Benefits-of-Eating-a-Plant-Based-Diet---The-Vitamin-B12-Deficiency-Myth&id=1764318
You still do not NEED meat to get this vitamin. I've heard and read form a number of sources that meat-eaters are more prone to B12 deficiency.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
In my original post I said I just started a vegan diet
Excellent! I still recommend that book though. It helps a lot with understanding what you need in your daily diet. Both informative and very motivating! Best of luck to you.0 -
Consider taking on a plant-based diet. Please don't cast this message aside, as countless studies have shown that eating meat and animal produce is one of the leading causes in all of these 'modern' diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, cancer etc. At least consider reading 'The Complete Idiot's Guide to Plant-Based Nutrition'. If diabetes can be reversed by taking on a plant-based diet then i'm pretty sure it'll fix your blood pressure problem.
That is 100% ludicrous. There are plenty of cases where eating a plant HEAVY diet help, cutting out the grains and other processed crap, but to discount meat in such a way is folly.
My sister was in the same boat, overweight most of her life and she turned to being a vegitarian, because everyone thinks it's healthy. Over the course of 10 years being a vegitarian and another 5 being a very strict vegan, she gained 100+ lbs. She had VERY high blood pressure, cholesterol was through the roof and was approaching type 2 diabetes as a permanant fixture in her life. She had mysterious aches and pains constantly and got injured everytime that she tried to loose weight through exercise.
She has since gone to a low carb/paleo style diet and has reversed ALL of these symptoms and also lost 80+ lbs in about a year. Her blood pressure went from 145/97 (!!!!!) to a solid 118/70.
My mother has similar issues, while not overweight, she has higher than normal blood pressure and cholesterol. She's been a vegan for the last 2 years. I've been low carb for over a year, and have cholesterol about 100 points lower than her and my last tested blood pressure was 112/66. Genetics may give a predisposition to have certain issues, but that does not mean that you have to settle for that being normal.
You can be a strict vegan and still eat all the wrong foods, such as refined 'white' foods which are just empty calories. Please read around what meat, animal produce and refined foods do to our bodies before calling this 'ludicrous'.
You can read all you want, and this thread is probably not the place to debate it, but cutting out meat from the diet of a human is just plain stupid, and defending it with pseudo science makes even less sense.
You can argue all day long that meat is bad for you, but there is no actual evidence of such in ways that are actually meaningful. You can skew any study to fit an agenda, but real world experience shows me otherwise. My mother is a VERY clean eater. The only thing processed that she even buys is organic dark chocolate and organic multi-grain bread. The rest of her diet consists of fruits and vegtables. Puzzle that one out professor...
We can certainly agree though that processed foods are horrible, and should be eliminated and "white" foods should be avoided. I'm all for a VERY heavy plant based diet, but meat should find its way to the table regularly, with all the fat, connective tissue and skin in tact for consumption.
It is not a coincidence that many of the vital vitamins and nutrients that humans need to live are FAT SOLUABLE. And the fact that you cannot get vitamin B12 from a plant source (unless man created and processed, which if your argument is to stay true to itself, processed foods and such should be avoided...). WIthout vitamin B12, or a severe deficiency of it, humans WILL DIE. This is not conjecture, but pure cold hard fact. Seems to me that to get that in a natural, unprocessed, not man made or assisted, you'll need to eat some meat.
I'm fine with vegans eating that way for moral purposes, if they believe strongly that animals should not be killed for their dietary needs, I get that, but to say that something like that is the healthiest way to eat in the face of facts that would state otherwise, in the face of the GAPING hole in the argument (missing vital nutrients that have to be supplemented and fortified into vegan foods) is not only niave, but quite frankly irresponsible.
Vitamin B12 is a microbe that doesn't come from animals or plants:
http://ezinearticles.com/?The-Benefits-of-Eating-a-Plant-Based-Diet---The-Vitamin-B12-Deficiency-Myth&id=1764318
You still do not NEED meat to get this vitamin. I've heard and read form a number of sources that meat-eaters are more prone to B12 deficiency.
I don't know where you get your info, or the person writing that article, but it all looks like vegan propoganda to me. Here's another link that shows the foods with the most vitamin b12...imagine my shock when they were all animal based and anything remotely vegan as the word "Fortified" in front of it.
http://www.healthaliciousness.com/articles/foods-high-in-vitamin-B12.php
And here is a vegan resource for B12, and again notice that unless it is a fortified grain, you're really not getting it from anywhere plant based. Oh, wait you can, from certain plants as long as they are grown in MANURE, which is an animal by product...go figure.
http://www.vrg.org/nutrition/b12.htm
Here's another vegan source that tells you basically to eat yeast or dirt (paraphrasing of course) or use supplements or fortified foods...again not a natural occrence of the vitamin.
http://www.vegancoach.com/vegan-vitamin-B12.html
The list goes on and on, and I could past links all day to sources that are vegan in nature.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions