Is night eating bad if you're within your calorie goal?

KristinaMarieOH
KristinaMarieOH Posts: 121
edited December 24 in Health and Weight Loss
A friend of mine sent me a voice recording titled, "Motivational Monday Chalene Johnson 3 Must Follow Rules to Lose Weight this Week". Her first rule is to not eat within 3 hours of going to bed. I've heard this same rule from Oprah's fitness guy and other sources. If you're staying within your calorie goal, is it still a bad idea to eat within less than 3 hours of going to bed? Are they referring to people that overeat at night? Or is there still some reason to not eat right before bed? I like to eat late at night {staying within my calorie goal} so this would be a very hard thing for me to give up.

Replies

  • LoraF83
    LoraF83 Posts: 15,694 Member
    I eat late at night (had dinner at 10:30pm last night....went to bed at 11:30). Personally, I have not had any issues with late night eating. As long as it's within my calorie goals, that's all I worry about!
  • JesterMFP
    JesterMFP Posts: 3,596 Member
    It doesn't matter what time you eat. It\s only a problem if late-night eating gives you indigestion, or if eating later causes you to binge and go over your calorie goal.
  • Shrinking_Moody
    Shrinking_Moody Posts: 270 Member
    I don't think it really matters. We eat later at night too - sometimes 730 or 8pm dinners depending on my husband's work schedule that day and so far I haven't had any issues.
  • PhilipByrne
    PhilipByrne Posts: 276 Member
    It's a myth, ignore it. Stay within calorie limits and you'll be fine.
  • dls06
    dls06 Posts: 6,774 Member
    We are all different. I eat most of my calories at night. It hasn't hurt me. I'm not a morning eater.
  • momofthreesons
    momofthreesons Posts: 162 Member
    I have lost 17lb doing this since the last week in April. I eat the majority of my daily calories between 5:30pm and 10pm. I am a night eater.... its just what I do. I try to hit all the essential nutrients and I am within my calories each day. I also exercise at least 30 minutes a day (walking) and do toning with my weights every other day.
  • myofibril
    myofibril Posts: 4,500 Member
    Are they referring to people that overeat at night?

    Yes, pretty much this. If you impose a rule that no eating should occur x amount of hours before bed the likelihood is the person will simply end up eating less overall through out the day. Many people tend to over eat in the evening.

    If you stay within your calorie goals it makes no difference if you eat before bed, after bed, in bed, on the bed, under the bed....
  • I dont think that it matters either, I was always worried about this but it doesnt seem to be a problem...I work shifts so my eating times change some depending on my work schedule and it doesn't really matter. Im still new but so far not an issue. Good Luck!
  • CatchMom11
    CatchMom11 Posts: 462 Member
    It's a trial and error type of thing... test it out and see what works best for you. I've had to try to eliminate my late night snack because no matter how well I'm doing, if I have a late night snack, it sticks with me. It's not an absolute science; everyone is different and so it becomes trial and error.
  • GalaxyDuck
    GalaxyDuck Posts: 406 Member
    I don't think it will do anything to either rev up or slow down your metabolism, which is why most people think about doing it. For myself however, I notice that if I eat after dinner & before bed, I do not sleep very well. I either end up taking forever to fall asleep, or I wake up often during the night. Especially so if I've eaten something with sugar in it. Because I value a good night's rest and having energy the next day, I try not to indulge in too much before-bed snacks.

    Everybody is different though! If you don't notice it causing sleep problems for you, I'd say go for it! But it may require a little self-experimentation for you to know for sure (i.e. don't snack before bed for two weeks, then snack before bed and see if you notice a difference).
  • milkyskinn
    milkyskinn Posts: 126 Member
    Are they referring to people that overeat at night?

    You got it right there. A large chunk of my calories is consumed after 5pm in my case (around 6-800 of them!) Although I have dinner around a normal hour (5.30pm), I always workout at night, so I have something (healthy!) along with coffee at 7.30pm, and then eat again between 10-11pm when I usually go to bed between 11.30 and 00.30 :)

    The key is to stay within goals, and not overeat. They're mostly referring to people who 'just get munchies', aka the people who have already hit their calorie goals and have had enough but just have cravings, and usually don't eat healthy snacks around that hour, either.
    Don't worry about it! Calorie goals and what kind of food it is matters so much more. Plus, when you're sleeping, your digestion is optimal because your body isn't doing anything else!
  • LarStar
    LarStar Posts: 102 Member
    There are a few reasons people say not to night, but if they don't bother you then it's not really an issue.

    The don't eat at night rule has been spread and misinterpreted. Generally by that time of day, the average person is at their calorie max and any additional eating is likely to be over. If your tracking your calories and you're within them, it won't be a problem.

    Another one is indigestion. If you eat late at night and go to bed shortly after, the food or acids from your stomach might come back up as you recline. Generally you should wait about 90-120 minutes before laying down after eating a full meal. If you are going to go to sleep right after eating, it is a good idea to keep your chest and head elevated above your stomach to avoid reflux.

    Also, if you have a full stomach, you might not sleep as well. The drawback is that if you don't sleep well and wake up tired, you will be more likely to crave carbs the next day as a way of boosting your system/sugar. Try to avoid foods like heavy meats, acidic or caffeinated drinks like coffee, and spicy foods and you should sleep just fine.

    If you within your calories, then Go Ahead and eat. :)
  • kathyms13
    kathyms13 Posts: 497 Member
    i untill last few days never eat breakfast, but i do like supper before i go to sleep. i dont see the problem but others go on about it.
  • jfan175
    jfan175 Posts: 812 Member
    I love going to bed with a full belly. I sleep like a baby, and it hasn't interfered with my weight loss.
  • Are they referring to people that overeat at night?

    Yes, pretty much this. If you impose a rule that no eating should occur x amount of hours before bed the likelihood is the person will simply end up eating less overall through out the day. Many people tend to over eat in the evening.

    If you stay within your calorie goals it makes no difference if you eat before bed, after bed, in bed, on the bed, under the bed....

    Hahaha, this is great! :wink:
  • MrsFolk
    MrsFolk Posts: 205
    I eat late at night, but I'm making smarter choices. I'll have a banana or yogurt or a piece of toast with peanut butter :) As long as you don't overdo it, there's nothing wrong with eating at night :)
  • Fergie2154
    Fergie2154 Posts: 59

    If you stay within your calorie goals it makes no difference if you eat before bed, after bed, in bed, on the bed, under the bed....


    ^Love this :)
  • It does not make a difference when you eat if you are eating. I would not recommend eating high amounts of carbs at night since you are not being active during the night.
  • mmapags
    mmapags Posts: 8,934 Member
    It doesn't matter what time you eat. It\s only a problem if late-night eating gives you indigestion, or if eating later causes you to binge and go over your calorie goal.

    What Jester said!
  • hothodgie
    hothodgie Posts: 258 Member
    I usually eat most of my calories between 5 and 10 at night. I don't do any heavy carbs though at night. I have been doing fine.
  • Talaysen
    Talaysen Posts: 4 Member
    Not to pointlessly revive an old thread, however,
    I was curious about this same thing, and when I should be eating meals, found a really good article that covers this topic:
    http://www.acaloriecounter.com/diet/how-many-meals-a-day-when-how-often-should-you-eat/

    Really useful information. I was always under the misconception that eating late at night was "terrible" for you, same as skipping breakfast.

    I'm not a big breakfast person, food upsets my stomach first thing in the morning.
    That article explains how it was assumed that, since many overweight people eat late at night or skip breakfast, it's an attributing factor to why they are overweight.

    It explains the myths and misconceptions about metabolism, and how your eating affects it.
    The overall concept is that the people who were overweight and skipped breakfast, or overweight and ate at night generally had other very poor eating habits that were the actual cause of the weight problems.

    I've started to realize how much truth there is to that, now that I'm actually controlling what I eat.
    I would skip breakfast, skip lunch, then around 3PM eat something, 4PM eat something, 7-8PM, 11 PM, and sometimes even around 2 or 3 AM.

    The real issue was each of those "feedings" was roughly ~800 - 1200 calories per sitting.
    Not to mention the additional calories from beer or wine, or worse (soda + whiskey).
  • marcenepea
    marcenepea Posts: 364 Member
    Are they referring to people that overeat at night?

    Yes, pretty much this. If you impose a rule that no eating should occur x amount of hours before bed the likelihood is the person will simply end up eating less overall through out the day. Many people tend to over eat in the evening.

    If you stay within your calorie goals it makes no difference if you eat before bed, after bed, in bed, on the bed, under the bed....


    I'm pretty sure if you eat under the bed the calories don't count. :blushing:
  • AbsoluteNG
    AbsoluteNG Posts: 1,079 Member
    It's true that eating late at night is bad for you but it applies only towards carbs. Eating carbs before you go to bed will reduce your HGH proteins.
  • anaquay
    anaquay Posts: 150 Member
    Glad you revived this thread because I've been pondering on this very subject. I've never been a morning eater and usually don't bother eating anything for about 4 to 6 hours after waking. I've been saving up for a juicer so I can get something down me in the mornings because I believed the hype about breakfast being so important. I've been staying under my calorie goal when I'm eating at night and I'm happy to know that this isn't a problem.

    Thanks :smile:
  • Talaysen
    Talaysen Posts: 4 Member
    Glad it was useful.

    @AbsoluteNG - Could you provide something that definitely indicates that eating carbs before bed affects the release of human growth hormones? Everything I've read indicates that concept is a misconception based on incomplete information.

    A good article on eating carbs at night:
    http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/carbs-at-night-fat-loss-killer-or-imaginary-boogeyman.html

    A much more scientific article, with actual hard data backing the conclusion:
    http://nutridylan.com/2012/04/24/growth-hormone-and-nighttime-carbs-much-ado-about-nothing-12/

    We'll jump straight to the 'Conclusion', review the data if you wish:

    "The fact of the matter is that those who fear carbs at night are basing their fear off of one piece of information that holds little scientific backing. Hopefully by now I’ve convinced you that GH regulation is a complex system with many factors that each plays a role. To say that carbs at night will reduce the capacity to build muscle is completely ludacris and unfounded – that is unless that meal is part of a diet which comprises 175% of your daily needs. So, in the end, there is no scientific evidence whatsoever to suggest that carbs consumed at night will reduce one’s goal of gaining muscle, and I doubt there ever will be. The main thing to keep in mind is that there is much more to building muscle than splitting-hairs. The people who care the most about this stuff are the ones who should care the least, and those who capitulate to stupid misinformation like that are worse off than they were when they knew nothing at all. If you learned nothing, remember this:

    Lift heavy, eat right, rest up, and most importantly don’t concern yourself with trivial aspects of dieting that are at best speculative and at worst completely false. Dichotomous thinking never did anyone any good. Ever."

    TL;DR

    If you don't have solid data backing up your ideas, it's what we call 'Broscience'.
    Spreading incorrect info causes people to form bad habits. ;)
This discussion has been closed.