Personal Trainers???

Ok so given my recent plateau, my brother said he was willing to pay for some PT sessions for me! But I am not really sure who or how to choose one. I was just wondering if anyone had any advice...

Thanks in advance.

Replies

  • Subtitles
    Subtitles Posts: 6 Member
    Look at credentials and experience. Way too many personal trainers have a weekend certification course under their belt and that's it. Unless they have YEARS of experience on top of that, avoid them. Go for a trainer with formal education-Diploma or degree. That does NOT mean they will be more expensive either. Though it's not always the case, more often then not trainers at big box gyms don't have anywhere near the knowledge that a trainer at a smaller gym would.

    Shop around, talk to the trainer and make sure you'll be comfortable with them, along with the facility they work out of.
  • drewols
    drewols Posts: 77
    As with all professions, there are good and bad. However, I do feel a good personal trainer can be a smart investment for a lot of people (especially if someone else is paying!)

    The previous poster offered some good suggestions, and I would definitely ask for references. Also, it will be very helpful for you to be clear about your issues, questions and goals when meeting with the trainer in the beginning.
  • 4myhealth77
    4myhealth77 Posts: 77 Member
    If I were you, I'd skip bix box gyms like LA Fitness, etc. Find a personal training center. They are a dime a dozen around where I live, but they are more attentive to you and you will get more for your money. Also, ask for a first time comp session from them to see how you feel with them before putting down your money. Most trainers will give you a first time free session.
  • NoSpandex
    NoSpandex Posts: 54
    I can give you the following advice based on my personal mistakes and successes:

    A good rule of thumb is never use a trainer who is employed at the gym. Always choose one that has their own studio / business and is not affiliated with a gym. Check their credentials and any online reviews about them or their business as well as their standing with the better business bureau. Choose one that specializes in your goal (weight loss, bodybuilding, etc). A compatible personality is a MUST (I had one that was super perky and wanted to high five me every few minutes, and had to drop her after the first session). Good luck!
  • mike_littlerock
    mike_littlerock Posts: 296 Member
    thats a tough one.. trainers vary in experience level (as noted by the above poster) but also in technique. Some focus on what YOU need, but I see tons of trainers that do whats easiest for THEM, and give every person they train the exact same workout.. that is just plain LAZY in my opinion.

    beyond their level of personalization, and beyond their personality (which is a factor), I personally want someone who is knowledgeable about how the body functions and can spot when I am making an error, can give alternatives if the base movement is too easy or too hard for me, and is constantly watching to make sure I am doing the movement in a safe way.

    working based on your limits is a biggie for me. some trainers are a bit sexist in my book and will be far too easy on women (you poor delicate flower, you must not exert yourself.. giving you only cute pink barbell workouts, and unstable surface cutesie workouts). for men, particularity with a male trainer, they often try to proove what a good trainer they are and push the client TOO far.. or, allow the client to use too much weight instead of the rule being that you push till form failure.. that is, you stop when they can not do anymore reps with perfect form. use sloppy form and you are likely to get hurt. I think that man or woman, they should push you hard, but not beyond your limits.

    style is another huge issue. do you use the trainer that uses a program that is lifted from ones i used 30 years ago? or something too modern. does your trainer consider 10-15 minutes on a treadmill a "warm-up" or do they have you do a foam rollout followed by a dynamic warmup?

    Picking a trainer is tough. and I know many people that have been through a few before finding one they love. Be picky, you are the customer and if you dont like it, then fire them. be cautions about locking into a long term contract with a trainer if it limits you to that individual.. if its a bigger gym and you can pick between several, thats less risky.

    ask LOTS of questions. be an educated consumer.

    Good Luck!
  • sunnyside1213
    sunnyside1213 Posts: 1,205 Member
    Off Topic, but is anyone else having technical problems with the site? It won't let me add new foods.
  • barefootbeauty
    barefootbeauty Posts: 188 Member
    I agree with whomever said to stay clear of trainers from big gyms -- my experience with them has never been good.

    I found a trainer that had years of experience and was starting her own studio. She came to my house and created a custom, home workout for me and then I saw her once a week...then once a month. Best. Investment. Ever. And cheaper than paying for a gym membership and a trainer.

    Good luck!
  • Well I am a personal trainer and I always ask what the client wants to accomplish, not what I want because my goals are not important theirs are. I have my own studio and or either I meet them at their place or choice of place. I do not charge an outrageous amount either. I agree the gym trainers charge a lot for their knowledge and service. I believe in the satisfaction for the client not myself or the money. I love the job not the money ;)
    I also think its important for the client and trainer to be compatible. If I feel we mismatch I will not continue to train them its for the best. I think both should be comfortable with each other.
    I also give the first 2 workouts free to see where we stand, if we are compatible. These are just my few cents in things. :)
  • chipmunkee
    chipmunkee Posts: 18 Member
    Thanks for all you comments! This has been lots of help. There's a lot more to think about than I came up with so THANK YOU!


    My bf and I have spent most of the evening looking through local trainers...We've contacted a few and most of them have offered to meet up/trial sessions. Fingers crossed...
  • ChristinaBarnhouse
    ChristinaBarnhouse Posts: 274 Member
    bump :)
  • Pedal_Pusher
    Pedal_Pusher Posts: 1,166 Member
    Your brother is willing to pay? Sounds like a setup to me.................
  • mike4him
    mike4him Posts: 16
    Look for years experience..and talk to people that have used them..referrals..My wife has over 20 years experience and she gives personal training at the YMCA and they only charge clients $10 per hour..which is extremely reasonable compared to how much they used to charge when she worked at private gyms or did training personally.
    She used to work at gyms where they used to charge their clients $30-$50 per hour and that was 10 years ago. A good experienced trainer can make or break your difference in getting healthier..The other good thing about an experienced trainer..they will work with you in all ways...diet, excercise and overall health and put together a program or give you good advice or refer you to great books/podcasts, etc.
  • bump :)

    I've never had an experience with a trainer that led to any real break throughs, and I don't know anyone who has, either. Personally, I just read and learn obsessively, keep monitoring any changes I make and the impact they have. If you've been at it for a while, it's unlikely that you're going to find a trainer who knows that much more than you. I'm not saying there aren't some real all stars out there, but you have to find them and then pay them - and if they're really really good, they're going to be pricey.
  • dad106
    dad106 Posts: 4,868 Member
    Having gone through three PT's and finally getting it right, here is my 2 cents.

    I do my personal training through my gym(X-sport fitness) and my current trainer has 3 certifications, is going for his 4th and has been in the business for 5 years. How he trains himself, is how he trains me.. and wouldn't dream of having me do an exercise that he hasn't tried himself first. So there are good trainers at box gyms... but you have to hunt them out!

    Ask about credentials, make sure personalities match and ask if you can observe them with other clients or talk to other clients. If it's a decent trainer, he/she will let you.

    Edited to add: I lost 30 pounds and 6 sizes under trainer guidance, along with MFP and doing cardio on my own.. so they are worth it, but you need to find the correct one!
  • Nutrition1st
    Nutrition1st Posts: 216 Member
    Check their credentials and ask for references. I get most of my new clients b/c of referrals. If they just hold the baseline certification for training, then I would look on. My specialty certs are in endurance training and advance sports nutrition. So I wouldn't expect a body builder to hire me b/c I don't have a specialty in that area. If you belong to a gym talk to the training manager and let them know your needs and they will try and match you with a suitable trainer. Even then I would observe that potential trainer and watch what they do. Are they engaging with their clients, or counting reps and peeking at the girls in Zumba. Are the spotting their clients or are they talking with everyone who walks past.

    I'd be happy to help you find someone in your area and advise you on things to look for. Just inbox me if interested.

    E
  • akaporn
    akaporn Posts: 231 Member
    I do not have a trainer. But I know a bunch of celebrity friends who have ones. We talked a bit. this is my take.

    1) Referal List of current clients
    2) The one who can inspire you
    3) the one who will spend enough time on you.
    4) The one that will assist you with your diet plan.
    5) The one who share the same interest/activity/hobby (mine would be soccer)
    6) Most importantly, the one whom you feel comfortable being around.

    You'll be surprise that most of the time, they are not too expensive as you might have thought. I live near Hollywood, CA. Tons of them. Some of them even will do it for almost free just knowing that I am going to succeed any way and it would be good referral for them. The one whom I used to go to did a group session in an extreme soccer-related theme twice a week. And one of my friends mentioned that we burned about 2,000CAL /session (HRM). He only charged $5/ 2Hr for rental of the facility. Too bad I live far from him because most of the gang hangout everyday at a local gym and they have been kicking *kitten*.

    You just have to keep looking. And, Good Luck.
  • lilmissymoo90
    lilmissymoo90 Posts: 324 Member
    Oh you lucky ducky :) I would love a pt ! The closest I get is the wii game ea active 2 :) I find it gives me a good workoutevery day and leaves me sore! But then I'm incredibly unfit !
  • sho3girl
    sho3girl Posts: 10,799 Member
    bump to read later -

    note to OP lucky you with generous brother
  • Swissmiss
    Swissmiss Posts: 8,754 Member
    Wow, would your family like to adopt me?:laugh:
  • Azdak
    Azdak Posts: 8,281 Member
    A compatible personality is a MUST (I had one that was super perky and wanted to high five me every few minutes, and had to drop her after the first session). Good luck!

    I had to laugh when I read that. Not that there is anything wrong with "super perky"--but it's not for everyone. Like you, it would drive me nuts.

    The "anti-perky" folks are the ones who come to me at our center.
  • DavPul
    DavPul Posts: 61,406 Member
    If I were you, I'd skip bix box gyms like LA Fitness, etc. Find a personal training center. They are a dime a dozen around where I live, but they are more attentive to you and you will get more for your money. Also, ask for a first time comp session from them to see how you feel with them before putting down your money. Most trainers will give you a first time free session.

    Totally agree with this. The PTs in a Ballys or LA Fitness are usually still trying to gain experience. Do an online search of independent trainers in your area. Just being an independent isn't a guarantee, but it usually means they have enough satisfied clients to have gone out on their own. Interview them the same as you'd interview a nanny for your kid and select the one you have the best feeling for.