We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Sugar Counter?

lcmartin
lcmartin Posts: 163 Member
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
WOW! I've only had breakfast and I'm already over my daily sugar intake by 12? Now I didn't have a "normal" breakfast, but it wasn't bad. I was on the run, so I stopped by Starbucks and got the Perfect Oatmeal with nuts and brown sugar. Now I probably should have skipped the brown sugar, But what surprised me was my drink!! I ordered a Sugar Free Vanilla latte with skim milk....that had 22 grams. MPF has me set at only 24g a day! UGH!

As I recap the week...I was always over in Sugar or Protein. Anybody have any suggestions for lower sugar foods? Seems like everything has sugar in it.

Replies

  • Mindful_Trent
    Mindful_Trent Posts: 3,954 Member
    Keep in mind that milk has natural sugar in it (Lactose) - much like sugar from fruit or vegetables, this sugar isn't something you should be overly concerned about. Since you ordered a drink that was "sugar free" it shouldn't have had any added sugars in it, so the whole 22g should be natural sugar. Natural sugar comes packaged with other good stuff - fiber, vitamins, other nutrients, etc., whereas added sugar is more "empty" calories with no nutritional value. Sugar from milk, fruits and veggies is much different than sugar from a candy bar.

    Personally, I don't count milk or fruit/veggie sugars when I'm comparing my daily sugar totals to my limits. Unfortunately right now, food labeling isn't required to differentiate between added and natural sugar.
  • jowily
    jowily Posts: 189 Member
    Since a Latte is mostly milk - your sugar count would be high. Might be better to have coffee with a bit of cream. It is a natural sugar - but it's still a sugar, as in fruit (lactose and fructose respectively). Some oatmeals have a lot of sugar as well (not just the brown sugar you put on top). I am more focused on calories and salt, and then sugar from natural sources (ie yogurt, fruit, etc) and trying to stay away from processed foods with sugar in them (and if I need sugar, I am using truvia (stevia) or sun light crystals (stevia and natural sugar) and trying to avoid most other sweeteners.
  • lcmartin
    lcmartin Posts: 163 Member
    Thanks. That makes me feel better. I thought I was making a "good" choice, then was freaked out! So for lunch, I decided to have 1/2 c of lowfat 1% cottage cheese, 3.5oz chicken breast and some red/yellow/orange bell peppers....so now it's showing that I'm way over in my protein. Is it necessarily bad to be over in Protein?
  • Mindful_Trent
    Mindful_Trent Posts: 3,954 Member
    Thanks. That makes me feel better. I thought I was making a "good" choice, then was freaked out! So for lunch, I decided to have 1/2 c of lowfat 1% cottage cheese, 3.5oz chicken breast and some red/yellow/orange bell peppers....so now it's showing that I'm way over in my protein. Is it necessarily bad to be over in Protein?


    Do a search for protein - there have been TONS of posts the past few weeks about this. To sum it up, most MFP-ers think the site suggests a pretty low % of protein (I've upped mine to 25%, with 55% carbs and 20% fat) and most people seem to exceed the MFP recommended amount. Unless you're eating a long-term diet with very high protien levels (like 50%) there shouldn't be any problem.
  • PinkDog
    PinkDog Posts: 68 Member
    How do you have things broken down? You can go a little over in protein, but too much is still too much. What is your total daily calorie allottment?

    For 1500 calorie diet on a healthy person it should be:

    40% Carbohydrates (150g)
    30% Proteins (113g)
    30% Fats (50g)

    Sugars -- max of 60g per day (try to keep at least 40g from 'good, natural' sugars as accountant_boi said)

    Sodium -- under 2500 unless you are hypertensive then under 2000

    Personally, I also find sugar the HARDEST one to limit -- it can be your whole day gone from one thing! Good luck!
    Hope that helps! :)
  • lcmartin
    lcmartin Posts: 163 Member
    Thanks for all your quick answers. Here's what my MFP has me set at:

    Calories: 1210
    Carbs: 166
    Fat: 40
    Sugar 24
    Protein: 45
    Fiber: 14

    Maybe I should do some research and re-evaluate those numbers?
  • Mindful_Trent
    Mindful_Trent Posts: 3,954 Member
    How do you have things broken down? You can go a little over in protein, but too much is still too much. What is your total daily calorie allottment?

    For 1500 calorie diet on a healthy person it should be:

    40% Carbohydrates (150g)
    30% Proteins (113g)
    30% Fats (50g)

    Sugars -- max of 60g per day (try to keep at least 40g from 'good, natural' sugars as accountant_boi said)

    Sodium -- under 2500 unless you are hypertensive then under 2000

    Personally, I also find sugar the HARDEST one to limit -- it can be your whole day gone from one thing! Good luck!
    Hope that helps! :)

    40% in carbs actually seems pretty low - it would be considered a low-carb diet. Most figures I hear say that "normal" carb intake should be around 50 or 55% of daily calories with fat 20-30%.

    In the end, everyone has different needs - the 55% carbs, 25% protien and 20% fat has worked for me so far, so I'll keep at it. If you're doing lots of intense workouts and trying to build muscle, a higher protien % might be warranted. You can try experimenting and see which combination seems to work best for you (in terms of weight-loss, energy, general 'how do you feel', etc.)

    One thing - the MFP Fiber amounts are definitely too low! I've read women are recommended to get around 25g of fiber a day.
  • le098098
    le098098 Posts: 1
    There's a really good dedicated Sugar Counter app here:

    https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sugar-counter-how-to-shop/id889832288?mt=8
This discussion has been closed.

Categories