If You Can't Spot Reduce Why Can We Spot GAIN?
DaveRCF
Posts: 266
We are all well aware of the mantra "You Can't Spot Reduce" but here's the thing; we seem to be able to spot gain so why not spot reduce?
Case in point, my wife is in great shape; 5'11", 130 lbs, great upper body muscle definition, virtually no fat above the waist. Yet, and it frustrates her to no end, she has the dreaded saddle bags. She clearly does not have a uniform fat percentage over her body (and I would be surprised if a caliper test would give the same reading for every part of the body on most people).
So what gives? Honestly curious, not trying to be a smart *kitten*.
Case in point, my wife is in great shape; 5'11", 130 lbs, great upper body muscle definition, virtually no fat above the waist. Yet, and it frustrates her to no end, she has the dreaded saddle bags. She clearly does not have a uniform fat percentage over her body (and I would be surprised if a caliper test would give the same reading for every part of the body on most people).
So what gives? Honestly curious, not trying to be a smart *kitten*.
0
Replies
-
Your body is predisposed to storing fat in certain locations..........and also more inclined to hold on to it in those places.
So in men for example....fat will more readily be stored around the lower belly and in women thighs/bum and under the arms. This will be the hardest to get rid of and the easiest to add to.
Genetics i'm afraid.0 -
By spot gain do you mean induce hypertrophy to certain muscle groups? Which is not the same thing as losing fat0
-
@ Hendrix you really know your ****, I don't even have to use Google anymore. LOL0
-
You cannot target a specific location for fat loss or gain. If your wife could actually "spot gain", then she would be able to pick and choose where she gained her body fat. If spot reduction is choosing where you lose body fat, then spot gaining would be choosing where you gain it.
I would bet that you wife, like many people, would happily chose a different location for extra body fat gains if she was able.0 -
Maybe "spot reduce" is the wrong term, but when I was younger, I did the Abs of Steel workout and it helped tremendously. I believe that certain body types benefit from certain exercises, and that doing the wrong exercises can make our bodies out of proportion.0
-
Where fat is stored/gained first/lost last, etc, is determined by genetics.0
-
Genetics. You lose in your problem area last and gain there first. It's not a purposeful spot gain like you would want a purposeful spot loss. I get my genes from my mom, we have giant *kitten* and little waists, I gain in butt and thighs. My sister's genes from from my dad, she has pancake booty, but you can see her weight fluctuation in her belly.0
-
Some spots on both men and women are more prone to store more fat, and due to several reasons (.e.g., low blood flow to that area) it's harder to burn fat from those areas. Tis just the way we're built...0
-
I have been told that you lose weight first where you gained it last. I think that is pretty true.
If you were 100 lbs over weight and wanted to lose weight in your belly you cannot target that spot to burn first. Your body is just going to start burning fat where it "chooses". How it makes those "decisions" is where I think my first comment comes in to play and it all comes down to genetics.
You also cannot in theory spot gain, cause you can't say I am going to eat a ton of food over the next couple of months and put it on in my skinny legs for example. That would take one serious jedi mind trick.
So in the end your body adds and removes at its discretion based on you.0 -
that's not spot gaining. that's just genetics.
spot reducing or spot gaining is about the belief that you can use certain foods or certain exercises to specifically designate where you want the fat to go to or leave from.0 -
We are all well aware of the mantra "You Can't Spot Reduce" but here's the thing; we seem to be able to spot gain so why not spot reduce?
Case in point, my wife is in great shape; 5'11", 130 lbs, great upper body muscle definition, virtually no fat above the waist. Yet, and it frustrates her to no end, she has the dreaded saddle bags. She clearly does not have a uniform fat percentage over her body (and I would be surprised if a caliper test would give the same reading for every part of the body on most people).
So what gives? Honestly curious, not trying to be a smart *kitten*.
That's why caliper measurements are done on multiple sites and the results are determined by the sum of the skinfolds, not a measurement from any one area.
The fat distribution pattern you described is not uncommon.0 -
If you could spot gain, every woman in the world would be walking around with F cups or bigger.0
-
If you could spot gain, every woman in the world would be walking around with F cups or bigger.
I was just going to type this.....Maybe not F cups but the same sentiment! :laugh:0 -
If you could spot gain, every woman in the world would be walking around with F cups or bigger.
i'ev never known any woman to say she wanted to be an F cup unless she was way larger and wanted to get rid of some :laugh:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions