BMR
SaintsGal
Posts: 62
This may seem a silly question but I'm confused
My BMR is 1550 so I try to net 1550 calories a day. However, does that not mean I am not eating anything because my BMR uses these calories?
Please explain if I have got this wrong
x
My BMR is 1550 so I try to net 1550 calories a day. However, does that not mean I am not eating anything because my BMR uses these calories?
Please explain if I have got this wrong
x
0
Replies
-
Your body uses more than your BMR calories. If you're eating your BMR and your exercise, what you have left to contribute to your deficit is roughly your 'activity level' calories, so if sedentary, around .2 x BMR or 300 calories a day. But of course it's all just estimates.0
-
Ok so say my maintenance calorie goal was 2500. Does that mean I could eat 2500 with no exercise, then minus my 1500 BMR to leave 1000. Would that mean I had another 1500 calories to eat?
Please explain if I am wrong
x0 -
Ok so say my maintenance calorie goal was 2500. Does that mean I could eat 2500 with no exercise, then minus my 1500 BMR to leave 1000. Would that mean I had another 1500 calories to eat?
Please explain if I am wrong
x
I'm not sure where you got your numbers, but let's say your correct.
You eat 2500 calories, burn 1500 BMR, burn another 1000 through activities, leaving you with zero. That's good - if you eat another 1500 then you'll have 1500 EXTRA calories that will be stored as fat.0 -
Quote:
You eat 2500 calories, burn 1500 BMR, burn another 1000 through activities, leaving you with zero. That's good
OK but then wouldn't your body be running on zero calories which is not good?
Sorry once again I just don't understand as BMR is calories burnt by the body if you were to do nothing so these calories are burnt regardless
x0 -
No, it's not running on zero calories. It's running on 2500 calories! What do you think your body needs calories for, exactly?
Your BMR is the calories needed to run your body. You need calories to run your organs and so forth (BMR) and you need calories to fuel your activities. There IS NO OTHER need for calories.0 -
AS I'VE SAID I'M SORRY IF PEOPLE ARE LOSING PATIENCE I AM JUST STRUGGLING TO GET MY HEAD AROUND THIS.
So if ate around 2000 calories daily, and my BMR is 1500 would I be netting 500 or 2000 calories?
x0 -
AS I'VE SAID I'M SORRY IF PEOPLE ARE LOSING PATIENCE I AM JUST STRUGGLING TO GET MY HEAD AROUND THIS.So if ate around 2000 calories daily, and my BMR is 1500 would I be netting 500 or 2000 calories?0
-
AS I'VE SAID I'M SORRY IF PEOPLE ARE LOSING PATIENCE I AM JUST STRUGGLING TO GET MY HEAD AROUND THIS.
So if ate around 2000 calories daily, and my BMR is 1500 would I be netting 500 or 2000 calories?
x
Okay, but you ar hung up on that word "Net"......as I explained in your other thread about Maintenance calories: just eat till you get to zero at the bottom of your Food Diary. Stop looking at the "Net" ....if you don't understand BMR or Maintenance calories, please do some research. It's been explained, but maybe we don't use the right words for you to understand.0 -
So although you need to eat your BMR calories you don't actually burn them as such?
x0 -
So although you need to eat your BMR calories you don't actually burn them as such?
x0 -
Ok I think I may need to do more research because I am struggling to understand why if you ate 1500, and your BMR burn was 1500 why you cannot eat these calories back? Because if your BMR calories are burnt why are these not taken off your calorie intake for the day?
Thank you for your help I am just not understanding this at all
x0 -
OK just answer this question: what do you think you need calories for? What does your body do with them?0
-
Our bodies needs some calories just to operate — to keep your heart beating and your lungs breathing. As a kid/teen, our bodies also needs calories to help us to grow and develop.
The chemical side of it I'm not too sure about but that's a general thing we got told at school (that was a couple of years ago now though)0 -
Our bodies needs some calories just to operate — to keep your heart beating and your lungs breathing. As a kid/teen, our bodies also needs calories to help us to grow and develop.0
-
Ok so that is BMR so would our bodies burn this amount of calories even if we didn't eat anything?
x0 -
Ok so that is BMR so would our bodies burn this amount of calories even if we didn't eat anything?
x0 -
Our bodies needs some calories just to operate — to keep your heart beating and your lungs breathing. As a kid/teen, our bodies also needs calories to help us to grow and develop.
And that is the definition of BMR.
Maintenace calories (also called Total Daily Energy Expenditure or TDEE) is your BMR plus whatever number of calories you use doing stuff other than breathing, growing hair, staying warm etc. Like for instance, you walk to the mailbox, you take a shower, you fix lunch, you go to school or work, you walk to the bathroom. All that extra movement and activity needs more calories. How many more depends on how much you do in the day. It can be anywhere from 250-1000 MORE than your BMR.
Your weight-loss calorie recommendation is calculated by eating more than your BMR and LESS than your TDEE. Don't eat less than your BMR. Eat less than your Total Daily Energy Expenditure. Myfitnesspal figures all this for you. Don't make it complicated, just use the Food Diary as it is set up.0 -
Don't worry I'm not going to starve myself I was just asking haha
But if our bodies were to burn that amount of calories even if we weren't eating that would mean we would be at, in my case -1550 calories for the day?
This is where I get confused so thank you ElizabethRoad for trying to help
x0 -
I give up. Good luck.0
-
Okay, I will try.
BMR = the calories your body burns lying in bed breathing, organs operating, etc. Let's say your BMR is 1500.
TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) = the TOTAL calories your body burns doing everything it does in a day - sleeping, breathing, your organs working, walking, sitting, and exercising. Since we've said your BMR is 1500, this would be your BMR (1500) plus however many calories you burnt doing your daily activities, lets say this is 1000.
So TDEE = BMR (1500) + Daily Activities (1000) = 2500 calories
So 2500 - This is how many calories you need to maintain your weight. So if you eat less, you will lose weight, and if you eat more, you will gain weight.
I hope that made sense! Feel free to message me if you have any more questions!0 -
To answer your other question - If you didn't eat anything, yes, your body would still burn all of your BMR calories so you would be at -1500 calories.
Initially! the human body is very adaptable and your BMR will actually decrease to survive on less calories. Eating so little would be harmful to your health, your weightloss would most likely slow, and just generally I wouldn't recommend it. lol.
This is why you never want to eat below your BMR calories.
So lets say your BMR is again, 1500, and you burn 1000 calories doing activities. So your total burn for the day would be 2500. The absolute least you should eat this day would be 1500 calories, though many would recommend eating 2000 calories so you have a reasonable calorie deficit of 500/daily, which means you would lose 1 lb a week.0 -
Your body uses calories for maintaining your organs (BMR) and fueling your daily activities. You eat more than you need for those things, it will be stored as fat. I'm sorry but I really can't make it any simpler than that.0
-
Hi Kekl,
I have added you and sent you a message
x0 -
There are two numbers you look at when you are looking at your body and how much it is burning with out doing exercise.
First one: Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR)
There is your BMR which like others have mention is the calculated absolute approximate minimum calories your body needs to function doing nothing but resting all day.
Second one: (TDEE) Total Daily Energy Expenditure
http://www.quickbmr.com/what-is-tdee.html
Is basically your BMR multplied by a activity Multiplier for your normal everyday activities not including exercise.
You need to calculate your TDEE and minus off your calorie deficate from this number but don't go under your BMR. If you exercise you need to eat most of those calories also.
you can accuratly calculate your BMR, TDEE and your modified calorie goal at this site:
http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/0 -
BMR is what your body would burn if you literally just sat there being alive. No moving, no doing anything at all just existing and breathing. As a living breathing human that is functioning and typing at your computer and or phone... you are burning more than your bmr.
If you burn 500-1000 calories by excercising, walking to your car, talking to people, going to work etc.... then yes you could eat 2000to 2500 calories a day and just maintain your current weight depending on your level of activity.
Just keep in mind that everyone's body and metabolism etc is different it's not as simple as the number game. If what you're doing is working good when it doesn't work or stops working re evaluate.0 -
Ok so say my maintenance calorie goal was 2500. Does that mean I could eat 2500 with no exercise, then minus my 1500 BMR to leave 1000. Would that mean I had another 1500 calories to eat?
Please explain if I am wrong
x
It might be simpler to ignore BMR. If you maintain your current weight at 2500, then anything you eat less than that will contribute to weight loss. (Your BMR is the main part of that 2500.)
To lose roughly 1 lb/week, eat around 2000. To lose roughly 2 lbs/week, eat around 1500. Under this method, do not 'eat back' exercise, just eat 1500-2000.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions