which 1 of these 3 plans is best?

Options
I have narrowed my research down to 3 workouts and im not sure which one will be best for me to follow i think really i have narrowed it down to 2 because i think the "full body" routine (workout 1) should be elimanated next.
Please pick one of these workouts that will be the best for muscle and strength growth because my goal is to bulk up gain muscle and to gain strength.
So please vote workout 1, 2 or 3 to help me decide which plan to follow.
It's a long read this one so thank you all in advanced.


WORKOUT 1:


Full-body 3 times week. M-W-F etc. 2 days rest per week.
Tuesday/Thursday do abs.

(2hours MAX)
Legs - Squat - 3 sets of 10 (45kg)started on 30
Calves - calve raises - 3 sets of 15 (24kg) started on 16
Thighs - 3 set squat jump - 3 sets of 10 (12kg) OR Leg extensions 3 sets of 20/15 (25kg)
Shoulders - push press above head - 3 sets of 6 (40kg)
Chest - bench press - 3 sets of 10 (50kg)
Back - one arm dumbell row - 3 sets of 10 (27kg)
Biceps - Preacher curl - 3 sets of 6 (16kg)
Biceps - ez bar curl - 3 sets of 8 (25kg)
Triceps - skull crusher - 3 sets of 6 (12kg)
Traps - Barbell shrug - 3 sets of 6 (60kg)
Traps - Barbell Shrug - 3 sets to failure
Dips - 3 sets of 12
Chin up - 3 sets of 10



WORKOUT 2:


5 weight split session per week, 1 and a half - 2 hours per day:

Monday:Legs/abs
legs:
Squats- 3 sets, 10 reps
Calf raises - 3 sets, 15 reps
Dumbell squats - 3 sets, 10 reps
dumbell step ups - 4 sets, 6 reps
leg extensions - 3 sets, 20 reps
deadlift - 3 sets, 8 reps

abs:
Lay on floor leg raise (weighted)- 2 sets, 12 reps
Lay on floor leg raise - 3 sets,20 reps
cross crunch - 4 sets, 12 reps
Incline sit ups - 4 sets, 10 reps
Lay on bench leg raise - 3 sets, 10 reps
Plank - sets to failure.

Tuesday: Chest
Barbell incline bench press - 4 sets, 6 reps
Dumbell bench press - 4 sets, 6 reps
Dumbell flat bench flyes - 4 sets, 6 reps
Dumbell squeeze press - 4 sets, 6 reps
Bench press - 4 sets, 6 reps
Bent arm dumbell pullover - 4 sets, 6 reps
barbell shrug - 3 sets, 6 reps
barbell shrug - 3 sets 1 rep to failure.
Press ups - 50 reps.

Wednesday: Back/abs
Back:
Straight arm lat pulldown - 4 sets, 8 reps
Bent over barbell row - 4 sets, 8reps
one arm bent over barbell row - 4 sets, 6 reps
T-bar row - 3 sets, 6 reps
Incline reverse dumbell flye - 5 sets, 6 reps
Barbell shrug - 4 sets, 6 reps
Barbell shrug - 3 sets to failure
sitdown lat pull down - 5 sets, 10 reps.

Abs:
Lay on floor leg raise (weighted)- 2 sets, 12 reps
Lay on floor leg raise - 3 sets,20 reps
cross crunch - 4 sets, 12 reps
Incline sit ups - 4 sets, 10 reps
Lay on bench leg raise - 3 sets, 10 reps
Plank - sets to failure.

Thursday: REST

Friday: Shoulders/abs
Shoulders:
Push press above head - 4 sets, 6 reps
front weight disc raise - 4 sets, 6 reps
side arm dumbell raise - 3 sets, 6 reps
front dumbell raise - 3 sets, 6 reps
lying rear delt raise - 4 sets, 6 reps
overhead tricep extnsion - 4 sets 6 reps
dumbell shrug - 3 sets, 6 reps
dumbell shrug - 3 sets to failure
Press ups - 50 reps

Abs:
Lay on floor leg raise (weighted)- 2 sets, 12 reps
Lay on floor leg raise - 3 sets,20 reps
cross crunch - 4 sets, 12 reps
Incline sit ups - 4 sets, 10 reps
Lay on bench leg raise - 3 sets, 10 reps
Plank - sets to failure.


Saturday: Arms
Preacher curl - 5 sets, 6 reps
Incline bicep curl - 4 sets, 6 reps
Hammer curls - 4 sets, 6 reps
standing dumbell curls - 4 sets, 6 reps
skull crushers - 4 sets, 6 reps
ez bar curl - 4 sets, 6 reps
Tricep dips - 4 sets, 10 reps
chin ups - 3 sets , 10 reps
dumbell shrug - 4 sets, 6 reps
dumbell shrug - 3 sets to failure.




WORKOUT 3:


Push/Pull workout plan:


5 weight sessions per week, 1 hour per day structured as follows:

Day 1: PUSH A/CORE
Day 2: PULL A
Day 3: LEGS
Day 4: PUSH B/CORE
Day 5: PULL B
Day 6: REST
Day 7: REST

Day 1: PUSH A/CORE = Chest, Shoulders & Triceps + Core

Exercise 1: Incline Dumbbell Bench Press
Sets: 1 warm-up set at 40% working weight, 1 warm-up set at 60% working weight. Then 3 working sets at working weight
Reps: 8-10 reps for all sets (including warm-up sets)

Exercise 2: Dumbbell Lateral Raises
Sets: Sets: 1 warm-up set at 60% working weight.
3 working sets at working weight with a drop-set on the third working set
Reps: 10-12 for all sets

Exercise 3: Flat Dumbbell Flies
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 12-15

Exercise 4: Close-Grip Flat Barbell Benchpress
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 8-10

Exercise 5: EZ-Bar Tricep Skullcrushers
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 6: Tricep Dips
Sets: 3 working sets
Reps: 8-10,


Day 2: PULL A = Back, Traps, Shoulders & Biceps

Exercise 1: One-Arm Bent-Over Dumbbell Rows
Sets: 1 set at 40% working weight, 1 set at 60% working weight. Then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 8-10 reps for all sets

Exercise 2: Lat-Pulldown
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 3: Rear Delt Flies
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight with a drop-set on the third working set.
Reps: 12-20

Exercise 4: Dumbbell Shrugs
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 5: EZ-Bar Bicep Curls
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 6: Alternating One Arm Dumbbell Curls
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10 per arm


Day 3: LEGS = Glutes, Quads, Hamstrings, Calves

Exercise 1: Free Weight Barbell Squats
Sets: 1 set at 40% working weight, 1 set at 60% working weight. Then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 8 reps for all sets

Exercise 2: Straight-Legged Deadlifts
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 3: Dumbbell Lunges
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12 per leg

Exercise 4: Leg Extensions
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 5: Standing/Seated Calf Raises
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 12-20


Day 4: PUSH B/CORE = Chest, Shoulders & Triceps + Core

Exercise 1: Flat Dumbbell Bench Press
Sets: 1 set at 40% working weight, 1 set at 60% working weight. Then 3 working sets at working weight
Reps: 8-10 reps for all sets (including warm-up sets)

Exercise 2: Dumbbell Lateral Raises
Sets: 1 set at 60% then 3 working sets at working weight with a drop-set on the third working set.
Reps: 10-12 for all sets

Exercise 3: Incline Dumbbell Flies
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 12-15

Exercise 4: Overhead Barbell Shoulder Press
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 8-10

Exercise 5: Overhead Dumbbell Tricep Extensions
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10

Exercise 6: Tricep Dips
Sets: 3 working sets
Reps: 8-10,


Day 5: PULL B = Back, Traps, Shoulders & Biceps

Exercise 1: Barbell Rows
Sets: 1 set at 40% working weight, 1 set at 60% working weight. Then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 8-10 reps for all sets

Exercise 2: Wide Grip Pullups
Sets: 3 working sets
Reps: 8-10,

Exercise 3: Rear Delt Flies
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight with a drop-set on the third working set.
Reps: 12-20

Exercise 4: Barbell Shrugs
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 5: Dumbbell Hammer Curls
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets.
Reps: 10-12

Exercise 6: Dumbbell Preacher Curls
Sets: 1 set at 60% working weight, then 3 working sets at working weight.
Reps: 10 per arm

Rest Days: day 6 and 7.




«1

Replies

  • kazane1
    kazane1 Posts: 264 Member
    Options
    rybo wrote: »
    If I was absolutely forced to chose one of the posted plans, I'd pick 3. But I don't feel that is a particularly good program either.

    Go to the sticky thread about which program to follow. There are a lot better ones there to choose from.

    Okay I think i might do that then lol any recommendations? Or is it down to preference? Thanks
  • kazane1
    kazane1 Posts: 264 Member
    Options
    Some of the routines involve certain exercises that I don’t have access to like cables and other things, so would it be sufficient to pick a plan from the sticky thread and then for the exercises I can’t do just do alternatives for?
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,483 Member
    Options
    Yes, if no cable machine etc is available replace with another exercise that uses the same muscle group in the same way
    Ie: cable row, replace with bent over row,
    Lat Pull Down, pull up, cable push down, tricep extension.

    Choose a simple programme, any of the 3x5, 5x5 versions, or AllPro. You only need the compound moves to begin with. Don't over complicate it. The ones you posted have far too much happening for a beginner. (If you are not a beginner my apologies)

    Cheers, h.
  • Okiludy
    Okiludy Posts: 558 Member
    Options
    Starting Strength and Strong Lifts 5x5 are basic barbell programs. They don't require much beyond a barbell, rack, bench, and something to do chin-ups on. They are both full body 3 days a week and work if you follow the program and don't try to change it. I like Stating Strength more but either of them works just fine.
  • kazane1
    kazane1 Posts: 264 Member
    Options
    I’ve chosen the the “phat” workout plan to follow so I’ll just scrap these other plans and make a few changes to the “phat” workout because I don’t have all the equipment. It’s just I paid for one of those workout plans and it wasn’t really working for me but I felt like I was wasting my money just disposing of it. And the split training workout I got of bodybuilding dot com and made a few alterations to it so I thought that one might be okay. But Yeahh I have been lifting for over a year now so I’m not so much a beginner and I like the sound of the “phat” work out so I’m going to give that plan a go. Anyone tried that plan, or is currently doing it themselves?
    Thanks for all the advice everyone!
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,483 Member
    Options
    kazane1 wrote: »
    I’ve chosen the the “phat” workout plan to follow so I’ll just scrap these other plans and make a few changes to the “phat” workout because I don’t have all the equipment. It’s just I paid for one of those workout plans and it wasn’t really working for me but I felt like I was wasting my money just disposing of it. And the split training workout I got of bodybuilding dot com and made a few alterations to it so I thought that one might be okay. But Yeahh I have been lifting for over a year now so I’m not so much a beginner and I like the sound of the “phat” work out so I’m going to give that plan a go. Anyone tried that plan, or is currently doing it themselves?
    Thanks for all the advice everyone!

    You may have been lifting for over a year, but your lack of understanding of how this all works, asking about a separate ab program, puts you in the beginner category. I'm nervous about the modifications you're going to make to PHAT...is it going to end up looking like one of the other workouts you'd cobbled together?

    Totally agree with you.
    @kazane1, what was your programme for your previous year of lifting, and were you satisfied with the results?

    I still think you need a basic programme with the basic lifts and little or no accessory work.

    Cheers, h.
  • Wheelhouse15
    Wheelhouse15 Posts: 5,575 Member
    edited February 2018
    Options
    You are getting way to specific for a novice lifter. As recommended above get on a good novice program that focuses on overall development. I can't remember who said it but it's very true, novice lifters shouldn't worry about working on specific weakness and your splits are really getting too specific. Also, you say you don't have a cable machine so how are you doing pull downs?
  • Wheelhouse15
    Wheelhouse15 Posts: 5,575 Member
    Options
    kazane1 wrote: »
    I’ve chosen the the “phat” workout plan to follow so I’ll just scrap these other plans and make a few changes to the “phat” workout because I don’t have all the equipment. It’s just I paid for one of those workout plans and it wasn’t really working for me but I felt like I was wasting my money just disposing of it. And the split training workout I got of bodybuilding dot com and made a few alterations to it so I thought that one might be okay. But Yeahh I have been lifting for over a year now so I’m not so much a beginner and I like the sound of the “phat” work out so I’m going to give that plan a go. Anyone tried that plan, or is currently doing it themselves?
    Thanks for all the advice everyone!

    You may have been lifting for over a year, but your lack of understanding of how this all works, asking about a separate ab program, puts you in the beginner category. I'm nervous about the modifications you're going to make to PHAT...is it going to end up looking like one of the other workouts you'd cobbled together?

    I have the same concerns, OP you need to get a proven workout that fits your goals. You don't have the background to be changing things up yet.
  • sgt1372
    sgt1372 Posts: 3,978 Member
    edited February 2018
    Options
    None of the above.
  • goatg
    goatg Posts: 1,399 Member
    Options
    What's wrong with a separate ab program? *runs from thunder
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,483 Member
    Options
    goatg wrote: »
    What's wrong with a separate ab program? *runs from thunder

    Nothing in the greater scheme of things, but if you have read the OP's recent posts he is looking to start a new programme, and may be over complicating things.

    He would do better concentrating on the new programme without additional work.
    The programme itself will be taxing and give him enough ab work to begin with, once established he can choose to add in accessory work.
    Just my read on this particular instance.

    Cheers, h.
  • goatg
    goatg Posts: 1,399 Member
    Options
    Thanks, H. Good to know!

    Reading his program is like looking at Chinese, for me. Not that I don't recognize bits and pieces, but it's a lot of information I have to think through; this isn't my language.

    It is really curious to me, however, that he seems to really be pounding body groups (e.g., chest day in workout # 2). Whenever I lift, I usually superset different muscle groups (e.g., if I'm doing back & bis, I might superset a wide grip lat pull down + bicep curls with a twist, or whatever). But I guess different approaches for different goals?

    Nice to meet you. C.
  • steveko89
    steveko89 Posts: 2,216 Member
    Options
    PHAT and PHUL are both good and fairly similar programs that will help with improving strength and have enough hypertrophy to satisfy you. Modify as needed based on equipment but don't go crazy thinking you need more accessory volume, any program on that stickyed list has been around and developed that way for a reason. Focus on improving your compound lifts and the rest will come. Generically, be patient; don't expect a new lifting program to fix everything instantly, especially if you're not eating requisite to your goals.
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,483 Member
    Options
    goatg wrote: »
    Thanks, H. Good to know!

    Reading his program is like looking at Chinese, for me. Not that I don't recognize bits and pieces, but it's a lot of information I have to think through; this isn't my language.

    It is really curious to me, however, that he seems to really be pounding body groups (e.g., chest day in workout # 2). Whenever I lift, I usually superset different muscle groups (e.g., if I'm doing back & bis, I might superset a wide grip lat pull down + bicep curls with a twist, or whatever). But I guess different approaches for different goals?

    Nice to meet you. C.

    I'm guessing if you are super setting you are working in a more mid range, than heavy. (This is because I can't superset heavy)

    OP is looking at lifting heavy with a year of undetermined lifting under his belt, and by what he has written, has little understanding of what he is doing.
    A simple approach would benefit him more than the one he is wanting to take.

    Keep reading these boards and the links the good folk here provide. You will learn more than you ever thought you wanted to know.

    (I am just a recreational lifter, who reads a lot, including Chinese B))

    Cheers, h.
  • goatg
    goatg Posts: 1,399 Member
    Options
    goatg wrote: »
    Thanks, H. Good to know!

    Reading his program is like looking at Chinese, for me. Not that I don't recognize bits and pieces, but it's a lot of information I have to think through; this isn't my language.

    It is really curious to me, however, that he seems to really be pounding body groups (e.g., chest day in workout # 2). Whenever I lift, I usually superset different muscle groups (e.g., if I'm doing back & bis, I might superset a wide grip lat pull down + bicep curls with a twist, or whatever). But I guess different approaches for different goals?

    Nice to meet you. C.

    I'm guessing if you are super setting you are working in a more mid range, than heavy. (This is because I can't superset heavy)

    OP is looking at lifting heavy with a year of undetermined lifting under his belt, and by what he has written, has little understanding of what he is doing.
    A simple approach would benefit him more than the one he is wanting to take.

    Keep reading these boards and the links the good folk here provide. You will learn more than you ever thought you wanted to know.

    (I am just a recreational lifter, who reads a lot, including Chinese B))

    Cheers, h.


    You are absolutely right! All my reps are 8-12 (except occasionally heavier squatting). Intense volumes of cardio and muscle gains don't really go hand-in-hand.

    Thanks for the advice and playing translator ;)