Thoughts and advice please...
suzeexoxo
Posts: 170 Member
According to TDEE -20% I should consume 1640 calories for weightloss. My BMR is around 1550. I normally eat about 1300 but I'm not losing much weight I'm kinda stuck. I I work out 5x per week and burn about 300 calories on the days I work out. I tried eating today close to TDEE -20 % but feel stuffed. I'm afraid of gaining weight! Am I doing the right thing by eating calories according to TDEE -20 %?
0
Replies
-
I thought you said your TDEE says you should consume 1640 for weight loss?
My advice is that you eat that amount and eat back your exercise calories.0 -
MyChocolateDiet wrote: »I thought you said your TDEE says you should consume 1640 for weight loss?
I did say that. But I normally eat 1300. I've been under eating for a while now and today was the first day of eating close to 1640. I'm just afraid to gain weight eating that many calories.0 -
It's okay to be afraid, but do it anyways
0 -
+1girlviernes wrote: »It's okay to be afraid, but do it anyways
0 -
girlviernes wrote: »It's okay to be afraid, but do it anyways
Thanks I will I hope it works!0 -
Yes, eat your 1640 calories. It works.0
-
I'm doing the TDEE approach but I don't eat back the exercise calories because it is already calculated into that allowence. I'm at about 1673 and work out about 5 days a week.0
-
This is incorrect if OP is including exercise into her calculation, which TDEE does. If this is the case, only eat to 1640. If this is NOT including exercise, then log and eat back calories (this is your NEAT/net calculation).MyChocolateDiet wrote: »I thought you said your TDEE says you should consume 1640 for weight loss?
My advice is that you eat that amount and eat back your exercise calories.
I used to do TDEE, switched to NEAT and eat back exercise cals, has been working better for me in terms of having more exercise freedom.
and.. you will not gain weight on 1600 cals, OP. No one's maintenance is that small that 1600 would be over their maintenance and cause a gain, unless they've really screwed up their metabolism from under-eating.0 -
With TDEE, and being at -20% of that number, you should definitely eat that whole number . If you got your TDEE by inputting proper workouts, do not eat the calories back. But if you didn't, then you should. All depends on your settings.0
-
^^^^^MyChocolateDiet wrote: »I thought you said your TDEE says you should consume 1640 for weight loss?
My advice is that you eat that amount and eat back your exercise calories.
THIS
Sometimes, less is actually more...and more is actually less.
0 -
I was plateaued for a couple of months eating a low calorie diet, and working out 5x a week like yourself. I started IIFYM and upped my caloric/carb/protein intake by a fair amount and instantly started dropping pounds. I'm the strongest, leanest and meanest I've ever been... Eating WAY more
0 -
Ideally, eat as many calories as you can to lose. After 5 months of trying it the lower calorie way, I'm on a diet break. I have AWESOME energy at the gym now and am making some serious progress on my lifts. When I start again, I will be following the highest caloric intake possible, while still meeting my goals.0
-
Thanks everyone your feedback really helps!0
-
This is incorrect if OP is including exercise into her calculation, which TDEE does. If this is the case, only eat to 1640. If this is NOT including exercise, then log and eat back calories (this is your NEAT/net calculation).MyChocolateDiet wrote: »I thought you said your TDEE says you should consume 1640 for weight loss?
My advice is that you eat that amount and eat back your exercise calories.
I used to do TDEE, switched to NEAT and eat back exercise cals, has been working better for me in terms of having more exercise freedom.
and.. you will not gain weight on 1600 cals, OP. No one's maintenance is that small that 1600 would be over their maintenance and cause a gain, unless they've really screwed up their metabolism from under-eating.
The bolded part is just wrong. I'm a 5'1", 52 year old, 132 pound sedentary woman and I maintain on less than 1600 a day. A lot of shorter, older women need less than 1600 a day to maintain. And I have not screwed up my metabolism from under-eating.0 -
This is not true.No one's maintenance is that small that 1600 would be over their maintenance and cause a gain, unless they've really screwed up their metabolism from under-eating.
OP, I don't know your deal and suggest you consult with a doctor. Make sure you have no health issues ("feeling fine" doesn't count), get a target weight and daily calorie amount. Everyone should see a doctor for a physical once a year and when beginning a weight loss journey. Every expert will tell you so.
Then, eat as much as you can while losing. The number varies from person to person and can't be done with generalized formulas, of which there are so many. The exact formula that all the experts agree on...doesn't even exist.
So, I certainly do not pretend to have the answer, lol. But with a little guidance and some trial and error, you'll find the answer for you.
0 -
This is not true.No one's maintenance is that small that 1600 would be over their maintenance and cause a gain, unless they've really screwed up their metabolism from under-eating.
OP, I don't know your deal and suggest you consult with a doctor. Make sure you have no health issues ("feeling fine" doesn't count), get a target weight and daily calorie amount. Everyone should see a doctor for a physical once a year and when beginning a weight loss journey. Every expert will tell you so.
Then, eat as much as you can while losing. The number varies from person to person and can't be done with generalized formulas, of which there are so many. The exact formula that all the experts agree on...doesn't even exist.
So, I certainly do not pretend to have the answer, lol. But with a little guidance and some trial and error, you'll find the answer for you.
Thanks for your suggestions. I am in good health. I just had a physical about a month ago.
0 -
What did the doctor say about your weight?
This is not true.No one's maintenance is that small that 1600 would be over their maintenance and cause a gain, unless they've really screwed up their metabolism from under-eating.
OP, I don't know your deal and suggest you consult with a doctor. Make sure you have no health issues ("feeling fine" doesn't count), get a target weight and daily calorie amount. Everyone should see a doctor for a physical once a year and when beginning a weight loss journey. Every expert will tell you so.
Then, eat as much as you can while losing. The number varies from person to person and can't be done with generalized formulas, of which there are so many. The exact formula that all the experts agree on...doesn't even exist.
So, I certainly do not pretend to have the answer, lol. But with a little guidance and some trial and error, you'll find the answer for you.
Thanks for your suggestions. I am in good health. I just had a physical about a month ago.
0 -
I've lost 15 lbs since my last physical which was last year ago so she said I'm on the right track. All my lab work is good.
I just feel it's weightloss is coming off too slow. She didn't really have any other suggestions for me other than keep eating healthy abd work out, which is what I have been doing.
[/quote]
Thanks for your suggestions. I am in good health. I just had a physical about a month ago.
[/quote]
What did the doctor say about your weight?
[/quote]
0 -
** clarification ** I had a physical 1 mth ago and prior to that a year ago.0
-
For anyone that is curious here are my stats:
5'5, female, 36 yr, wt. 176lbs w/clothes and shoes. Workout for 5x per week 25 min T25.0 -
Then just keep it up. If you eat healthy food and you exercise, you'll lose the weight. Trust your doctor and yourself. Congrats on your loss so far!I've lost 15 lbs since my last physical which was last year ago so she said I'm on the right track. All my lab work is good.
I just feel it's weightloss is coming off too slow. She didn't really have any other suggestions for me other than keep eating healthy abd work out, which is what I have been doing
It does come off slowly, but as long as it keeps coming off, you win. Next year, you'll be at your goal.
0 -
Then just keep it up. If you eat healthy food and you exercise, you'll lose the weight. Trust your doctor and yourself. Congrats on your loss so far!I've lost 15 lbs since my last physical which was last year ago so she said I'm on the right track. All my lab work is good.
I just feel it's weightloss is coming off too slow. She didn't really have any other suggestions for me other than keep eating healthy abd work out, which is what I have been doing
It does come off slowly, but as long as it keeps coming off, you win. Next year, you'll be at your goal.
Thanks for your feedback!
0 -
For comparison sake, I'm 33yo 5'8" and 163/4 lbs. I lift 4x a week for about an hour each and that is my only exercise. My TDEE for maintenance is 2450 calories with NO eating back exercise calories.
Given your stats 1600 calories sounds perfectly reasonable for a 20% calorie reduction so as long as you are 100% certain that you are measuring everything correctly, go with 1600 calories for a month and watch what happens.
I can tell you that when I started over a year ago my calorie allowance was MUCH lower then it is now and I have pretty much UPPED my calorie intake continuously over the last year as I got more confident with my tracking and what I was doing.
The poster who said to figure out how to eat AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE while still losing weight is 100% correct.0 -
QueenBishOTUniverse wrote: »For comparison sake, I'm 33yo 5'8" and 163/4 lbs. I lift 4x a week for about an hour each and that is my only exercise. My TDEE for maintenance is 2450 calories with NO eating back exercise calories.
Given your stats 1600 calories sounds perfectly reasonable for a 20% calorie reduction so as long as you are 100% certain that you are measuring everything correctly, go with 1600 calories for a month and watch what happens.
I can tell you that when I started over a year ago my calorie allowance was MUCH lower then it is now and I have pretty much UPPED my calorie intake continuously over the last year as I got more confident with my tracking and what I was doing.
The poster who said to figure out how to eat AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE while still losing weight is 100% correct.
Thank you! This really helps0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions