down zero lbs zero inches!
wladysiak
Posts: 11 Member
I have not missed one day of P90x3 unless it is a rest day. I also run 2-3 miles in the same day. I'm eating clean with alot of protein. I have also been juicing with weight loss whey protein right after a hard workout. I've lost nothing and coming up on my first 30 day block with P90...I have a heart rate monitor and average 2800 calls burned in a day with my workouts and average 1300-1500 steps daily..... What is wrong here?
0
Replies
-
A quick peek at your diary - it looks like you're not weighing your food on a scale.
The lack of a food scale combined with your lack of results, tells me that it's most likely due to eating more than you think.
Get a food scale, weigh everything. You'll be surprised, I promise.0 -
Is your food journal public? Maybe water retention, you seem to do a lot. Or not eating enough. Juice has a TON of calories.0
-
You eat to much.
All of that workout stuff is awesome but none of it is going to make you lose a single pound of fat if you do not eat at a deficit0 -
wlady I had to lose the carbs and replace them with good fats. I bet your health has improved even if you did not lose anything.0
-
You only have a couple of weeks logged. It takes longer, be patient.0
-
I don't understand, you said you're juicing but the past 4-5 days I haven't seen anything about juicing. And Friday you didn't log at all. I don't know WTF you're doing saying you burn 2800 calories 5x's a week, and your journal shows less than 1000 calories consumed on all but one day I looked at. Either you are not logging correctly (which I hope is true) or you have an eating disorder.-1
-
Weigh your food. You are eating more than you think.0
-
Even with a heart rate monitor, you might be over estimating calorie burn. There may be some mis-calculation with food input on the items that you are not weighing and measuring so that your recorded deficit is not a true deficit. You may be masking some weight loss through increased water retention due to working your muscles hard; sodium; hormones.0
-
What's wrong? You're eating too much.
You're missing the "deficit" part of "caloric deficit".
0 -
In for the defecit
0 -
Myfitness pal is telling me to eat 1340. Is that with a deficit? My Tdee is 2800.... How many calories do I eat then. I write everything I eat down in a journal. Not always on here. I keep track of everything and I use a scale along with measuring spoons. Keeping track of all my calories is tough. I don't use juice either in my smoothie. Whey protein with water and fresh fruit.0
-
Myfitness pal is telling me to eat 1340. Is that with a deficit? My Tdee is 2800.... How many calories do I eat then. I write everything I eat down in a journal. Not always on here. I keep track of everything and I use a scale along with measuring spoons. Keeping track of all my calories is tough. I don't use juice either in my smoothie. Whey protein with water and fresh fruit.
If you're using a scale, you're doing it wrong. I really think your intake is the issue.
Yes, MFP has the deficit built in.
How did you figure your TDEE?0 -
My TDEE is around 2800 as well, being only lightly active and extremely obese by BMI index. I think your TDEE would be more, so yes 1340 calories is a BIG deficit. PLUS your exercise calories. Maybe your scale needs to be recalibrated?0
-
So I'm eating too much at 1340? Tdee was done online calculator... Do you have a way to figure it out? When I don't work out my armband averages 2200 cals from midnight to midnight.0
-
Eating clean means nothing. Log and eat at a deficit.
You are not logging daily and your goal is ridiculously low for the estimated daily burn, and you aren't even meeting your goal every time you log. I'm assuming you do not log everything and/or you are eating more than you realize. Your sodium is also high on many occasions so that contributes to weight retention. You are also using generic recipes, and I'm guessing you are not weighing your food despite sometimes using entries requiring weighted measurements.
So all in all you are not logging properly.0 -
1340 would give you a deficit, if your TDEE is 2800. However, your TDEE may not be 2800 and you may be eating more than 1340. Even with a food scale, there are ways to get an inaccurate calorie count, such as recording an incorrect calories per ounce number, or removing some low calorie portion of the food before weighing it, etc.0
-
So I'm eating too much at 1340? Tdee was done online calculator... Do you have a way to figure it out? When I don't work out my armband averages 2200 cals from midnight to midnight.
The issue is you don't really understand how different the TDEE method is from the NEAT method (which is what MFP uses).
TDEE includes your exercises. MFP does not.
So if you're going to use the TDEE method, you need to adjust your calorie goals on here manually, to be TDEE - your %.
If you're going to use the MFP method, you need to log your exercises and eat a portion of those calories back.
You need to pick a method to use.0 -
Myfitness pal is telling me to eat 1340. Is that with a deficit? My Tdee is 2800.... How many calories do I eat then. I write everything I eat down in a journal. Not always on here. I keep track of everything and I use a scale along with measuring spoons. Keeping track of all my calories is tough. I don't use juice either in my smoothie. Whey protein with water and fresh fruit.
How did you figure your TDEE, it sounded like you came up with this number from wearing your HRM all day?
Use a food scale, also be consistent I looked back and just 3 or 4 days ago you didn't log anything.
Your exercise burns seem high too.0 -
Go to settings
Check your age, gender, weight is correct
Set your activity level as it describes ...if you have a desk job you're sedentary etc (ignore workouts)
Set your goal weight loss rate, over 75lbs to lose choose 2lb a week, less? Choose lower
MFP gives you calories ...that's your daily amount excluding workout
When you exercise add it in exercise, double click on calories and half them - Edit you have an HRM, does it have a chest strap? If doing steady-state cardio then log those calories, anything else log 50-75%
That is how many calories you eat that day
Weigh and log all solid food on MFP and it gives you a calories left
Start there, get used to it then you can refine it0 -
Yes I wear my hrm all the time.... I'm going to stick with the 1340 with my workouts. I just did my Tdee online and came up with 2200 .0
-
TimothyFish wrote: »1340 would give you a deficit, if your TDEE is 2800. However, your TDEE may not be 2800 and you may be eating more than 1340. Even with a food scale, there are ways to get an inaccurate calorie count, such as recording an incorrect calories per ounce number, or removing some low calorie portion of the food before weighing it, etc.
Nobody is saying 1340 calories is to much, we are saying that you are eating more calories then you are burning. TDEE calculator are an estimate and you need to first use and apply it correctly, then log accurately. Then constantly fine tune it.0 -
Active... I work as a medical assistant and work out 1 HR a day0
-
Yes I wear my hrm all the time.... I'm going to stick with the 1340 with my workouts. I just did my Tdee online and came up with 2200 .
HRMs are not meant to give you your overall TDEE - they are to monitor your heart rate, they can give pretty close estimates on steady state cardio for calorie burns, anything else it's not accurate.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/872212-you-re-probably-eating-more-than-you-think
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants0 -
herrspoons wrote: »
Yeah I'd use lightly active for that. My opinion, of course.
I'm sticking with this though: you're eating more than you think. You have something like 38 chips logged, a medium apple, 1/2 cup of refried beans - if you a have a food scale, use it. Because right now, you're not.0 -
0
-
It's a wrist band. Tracks my HR and steps. Shows when I am active and when I am not. I'm just asking for advice and guidance to go forward. I'm not looking to be attacked because I calculated wrong. I love fitness and being healthy. I have been this way for yrs. Just putting on unwanted inches and confused. Maybe I am eating way too much. I thought I was tracking correctly. Maybe counting calories is harder than I thought0
-
Nobody is attacking you, people are trying to help
The customary response to advice and help is "thank you"0 -
It's highly unlikely that your TDEE is 2800. The efficiency of the human body is surprising. Looking through your exercise diary I see things like logging 350 Calories for a 30 minute walk @ a 15 minute mile pace. Unless you weigh 400lb that is pure fiction. That's about what I'd burn about running 30 minutes at an 8 minute mile pace.
HRMs are lousy at estimating calorie burn, even when properly calibrated. They give good figures for steady state cardio, but that's about it.
Dial back your estimated daily burn, dial back your food intake accordingly, and the pounds will start dropping.0 -
You came here because what you're currently doing isn't working. Listen to the advice of these good people and you'll be losing weight in no time xx0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions