Cheat Days?

Jesusjohnjames

Is it okay to have cheat days, when trying to lose pounds.
i eat 1000-1200 cals a day.
today I cheated by having Cereal, so im at like 1400 cals today. Should I do this once a week.

Liftng4Lis

Since the minimum you should be eating is 1200 PLUS exercise calories, you're just making up for the under eating during the week. Actually, you could eat 1400 a day everyday and still lose. Remember, MFP's deficit is already built into that 1200.

malibu927

If you feel like it, go ahead. Though I fit the foods I love into my calories, including cereal once or twice a week.

Edit: now that I've looked at your diary, that's not even close to a cheat day. You should be hitting your goal every day, and eating as little as you've recorded consistently can damage your body.

debubbie

I think as you long as you are netting above 1200 calories each day that you will be okay if you go over a few calories every once in awhile. The big thing is to make sure that your cheat day doesn't get out of hand and that you consume way more calories that will derail your weight loss for the week.

You also may want to evaluate the amount of calories you are eating if you are only eating 1000-1200 calories a day, less than 1200 calories a day can have health risks involved.

ogmomma2012

People suggest more like cheat MEALS rather than a whole day. So have one meal be a cheat, it won't throw anything off track.

grandmothercharlie

The most I "allow" myself is an occasional day where I might eat back some of my exercise calories. I try not to do that except special occasions.

Now, have I cheated? Yes. Do I do it regularly? No. Losing weight is slow enough without making it slower. Also, if I cheat, I tend to REALLY cheat. Can't seem to control myself to just a couple hundred calories like you did.

However, if you can have a 200 calorie cheat once a week, and it will make it easier for you to stick with the program, then by all means, have a little treat.

FYI: There are no "Cheat Police." It only affects you!

lemonlionheart

Eating 1400 when your goal is 1800 isn't 'cheating'. Eat more

Asher_Ethan

How long have you been doing 1200 - 1000 calories a day? I really feel you should be eating more but every body is different.

Jesusjohnjames

I logged 1180, THEN I have had 3 bowels of KIX cereal, with sugar sooo good.

Jesusjohnjames

I think I should do this every SUNDAY.

malibu927

Jesusjohnjames wrote: »

I logged 1180, THEN I have had 3 bowels of KIX cereal, with sugar sooo good.

3 bowls with sugar added? That's going to be a LOT more than 200 calories. Are you using a food scale?

Jesusjohnjames

I'm so Scared, but I will just have to hit the gym more, I guess this week.
Monday I will work out & Eat Clean. I never eat this much and I have great self control. My goal is to lose 29lbs, I'm half way there. I got 17 more to go.

ana3067

1400 calories isn't a cheat day. There is no such thing as cheat days - when you are maintaining, will eating ice cream mean you're cheating?

Eat now how you plan to eat when you are maintaining, just a little bit less. This is a lifestyle change, not a temporary fix. It's fine to eat above your calorie goal, you may just lose a bit slower. 1200 calories is quite low for most people and likely unnecessarily low.

eating "clean" means nothing for weight loss. Eat up to your goal, at the very least eat below your maintenance needs every day, to prevent weight gain.

lemonlionheart wrote: »

Eating 1400 when your goal is 1800 isn't 'cheating'. Eat more

This. eat to your caloric goal.

Jesusjohnjames

OMG just had 2 pieces of birthday cake. Im in trouble so Yes, I am working out hard tomorrow. 1 hour in the Am, 1 hour in the pm.

malibu927

Are binges common for you? If so, have you spoken with a professional about them?

Jesusjohnjames

No, I don't binge lol. I workout hard and eat right.

Jesusjohnjames

I dont even weigh my self often i weigh in like once every 6 weeks.

jnv7594

Eating three bowls of cereal and two pieces of cake in a short amount of time may be considered a binge to some. I doubt it will do any damage since you are undereating to begin with, but chances are the reason you are indulging in that cake in those bowls of cereal is because you're depriving yourself other days. If you want cake, then have some, but work a piece into your calories so you don't overeat on it later...same with the cereal and other foods you enjoy. Labeling certain foods as forbidden or considering yourself "in trouble" when you eat them is a recipe for failure down the road. You need to find an eating plan that's sustainable. It's not healthy to eat the limited calories you are, especially considering you are not eating back exercise calories.

elphie754

These posts sound dangerously close to disordered eating

ana3067

Jesusjohnjames wrote: »

OMG just had 2 pieces of birthday cake. Im in trouble so Yes, I am working out hard tomorrow. 1 hour in the Am, 1 hour in the pm.

... you think you are "in trouble" from birthday cake? At most you just ate up to your maintenance needs.

I think you need to back away from logging because you are entering dangerous territory here. None of this seems all that healthy from a physical and mental POV.

ana3067

jnv7594 wrote: »

Eating three bowls of cereal and two pieces of cake in a short amount of time may be considered a binge to some. I doubt it will do any damage since you are undereating to begin with, but chances are the reason you are indulging in that cake in those bowls of cereal is because you're depriving yourself other days. If you want cake, then have some, but work a piece into your calories so you don't overeat on it later...same with the cereal and other foods you enjoy. Labeling certain foods as forbidden or considering yourself "in trouble" when you eat them is a recipe for failure down the road. You need to find an eating plan that's sustainable.

Especially because we have no idea what 3 bowls and 2 slices means. This could be a slice:


or this could be a slice;


And agree with the rest of your post. Also that OP, you are not only depriving yourself of individual items you enjoy, but of calories that you need to be eating. Stop under-eating.

devil_in_a_blue_dress

If you ate up to your 1800 goal regularly, eating 3 bowls of cereal and 2 slices of cake, might not be something you care to do.

Liftng4Lis

ana3067 wrote: »

Especially because we have no idea what 3 bowls and 2 slices means. This could be a slice:

um what is this a booger?
or this could be a slice;

I'll have one of this one, only chocolate please.

ana3067

Liftng4Lis wrote: »

ana3067 wrote: »

Especially because we have no idea what 3 bowls and 2 slices means. This could be a slice:

um what is this a booger?
or this could be a slice;

I'll have one of this one, only chocolate please.

if only it were a real cake ;(

esjones12

Troll or needs to seek professional help for possible eating disorder. Or at the VERY least learn the proper way to use MFP and the basics of measuring food and weight loss.....

Jesusjohnjames

hahaha you guys are soo funny.
My plan is to have 1 day a week I eat whatever I want. Im going to just ensure i workout that day.
Today I ate 1100 cals, 1 hour of cardio. I am doing great I will not starve to lose weight, I don't want to be Flabby abby lol

ana3067

Jesusjohnjames wrote: »

hahaha you guys are soo funny.
My plan is to have 1 day a week I eat whatever I want. Im going to just ensure i workout that day.
Today I ate 1100 cals, 1 hour of cardio. I am doing great I will not starve to lose weight, I don't want to be Flabby abby lol

orly? 1100 calories without eating back the hour of cardio seems like starving to me, especially with roughly 10lbs to lose.

Robbnva

And here I'm deciding if a 1900 calorie birthday meal is worth it or not... Yeah, eating to hit your daily goal isn't a cheat day

Robbnva

Jesusjohnjames wrote: »

hahaha you guys are soo funny.
My plan is to have 1 day a week I eat whatever I want. Im going to just ensure i workout that day.
Today I ate 1100 cals, 1 hour of cardio. I am doing great I will not starve to lose weight, I don't want to be Flabby abby lol

Seriously, if your diaries are accurate, you are totally not eating enough. I can't imagine how you are even losing anything

BWBTrish

.

Robbnva

Jesusjohnjames wrote: »

I logged 1180, THEN I have had 3 bowels of KIX cereal, with sugar sooo good.

now you have me craving a huge bowl (4/5 servings) of captain crunch