Need discussion: should BMI "standard" for men be different from women?

choligeetu
choligeetu Posts: 22 Member
edited July 2015 in Goal: Maintaining Weight
So I measure myself as 167cm, 57kg, which means my BMI is around 20. The BMI seems perfect and "standard", but my family and all my friends say that I look too thin. They say I will be better if I gain 5-6kg. So I wonder if the "standard" and "the healthy range" should be slightly different for men from women?
j3zylfc3nmui.jpg
This was 6 years ago when I weighed 92kg;

cwg9tm84du3z.jpg
And this is now I weigh 57kg.

Replies

  • Cocoa1020
    Cocoa1020 Posts: 197 Member
    I think you look amazing!!! the people telling you that you are too thin are so used to seeing you as heavier so in comparison you look thin... and women tend to have a higher BMI then men. we got boobs and a bigger butt thats mostly fat lollol
  • Josalinn
    Josalinn Posts: 1,066 Member
    So BMI is really just a loose, basic guideline and should be used as such. Women are different from men physically and naturally have more fat so yes it does need to be different.

    You look great and they will get used to the new you. =)
  • choligeetu
    choligeetu Posts: 22 Member
    Josalinn wrote: »
    So BMI is really just a loose, basic guideline and should be used as such. Women are different from men physically and naturally have more fat so yes it does need to be different.

    You look great and they will get used to the new you. =)

    Many thanks! So do I think and I'll keep on going...
  • nxd10
    nxd10 Posts: 4,570 Member
    edited July 2015
    You look very trim. However, I bet your family is reacting to the thinness in the bottom of your face, which is very different than it was when you were heavier. I think you look fantastic.

    Almost all of our families and friends tell us we're too thin when we hit a healthy weight. It takes them a while to get used to it.
  • accidentalpancake
    accidentalpancake Posts: 484 Member
    Height is a more critical factor that needs to be addressed, as the BMI calc currently is very inaccurate (from a healthy range perspective) for taller individuals.

    I'd say you look plenty healthy, and certainly not to thin.
  • AsISmile
    AsISmile Posts: 1,004 Member
    Have to agree with the others. You look great. Definitely not too thin.

    I am torn on the whole BMI thing. I completely agree that it doesn't work for people that have a considerable muscle mass, however I personally think it is a pretty good indicator for being underweight.
  • MelissaPhippsFeagins
    MelissaPhippsFeagins Posts: 8,063 Member
    You look good. BMI is a flawed measurement for everything except life insurance actuaries who invented it. There is correlation between morbid obesity and severely underweight and actual morbidity. Otherwise go with what your own doctor tells you and don't worry about what other people say. I have been between 155 & 160 for 18 months except for a brief bout of sickness that took me to 153. Yesterday, someone at work asked me if I have stopped eating altogether. Um, not even close...I think I have eaten ice cream 4 out of the last 7 days.
  • choligeetu
    choligeetu Posts: 22 Member
    MelissaPhippsFeagins wrote: »
    You look good. BMI is a flawed measurement for everything except life insurance actuaries who invented it. There is correlation between morbid obesity and severely underweight and actual morbidity. Otherwise go with what your own doctor tells you and don't worry about what other people say. I have been between 155 & 160 for 18 months except for a brief bout of sickness that took me to 153. Yesterday, someone at work asked me if I have stopped eating altogether. Um, not even close...I think I have eaten ice cream 4 out of the last 7 days.

    Although I preferred a vegan diet since about two years, sometimes I have cravings for eggs and dairy...then I eat them, probably once per month or two months lol

Categories