Is 1500 calories too little to eat to lose weight?
Replies
-
Nope. Have you seen the pictures of the people in Sub-Sahara Africa?
0 -
You could move to Texas and eat whatever you wanted just by walking to the mailbox.steponebyone wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »
Gym machines are notorious for over-stating calorie burns.
Hmm, that sounds more like an opinion than a fact to me.
I have the same informed opinion based on lots of experience around here, as well as reading about the topic.
If you are an experienced, skilled swimmer, then yes you could be burning 500 calories from that. I doubt you are from the elliptical in an hour, and brisk walking won't burn calories at that rate.
That's why people recommend eating back only half until you see results and can adjust. You should eat back some, though.
If you think the machine is right for you, totally fine to start with eating them all back, though, and just adjust down if you don't like the results.
Thatlemurcat12 wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »
Gym machines are notorious for over-stating calorie burns.
Hmm, that sounds more like an opinion than a fact to me.
I have the same informed opinion based on lots of experience around here, as well as reading about the topic.
If you are an experienced, skilled swimmer, then yes you could be burning 500 calories from that. I doubt you are from the elliptical in an hour, and brisk walking won't burn calories at that rate.
That's why people recommend eating back only half until you see results and can adjust. You should eat back some, though.
If you think the machine is right for you, totally fine to start with eating them all back, though, and just adjust down if you don't like the results.
OK thsteponebyone wrote: »Timelordlady85 wrote: »omg, apples have no calories hooray! j/k, but I input my activity level and stats in MFP and aim for half my exercise calories back. How are you tracking your calories burned? I use a polar chest strap, I noticed that MPF tends to over estimate calorie burns.
That sounds reasonable. Last night I went to bed SUPER hungry, so I probably need to add 200 lbs when I burn that much. For me, I'm big on using different machines at the gym, and they have the amount on them of calories burned.
gym machines don't know who you are, individually, even if you put in your information. I have a Fitbit Charge HR and an elliptical that I entered all my personal statistics into. My Fitbit is very accurate at tracking my calorie burns during my workouts, and my elliptical is consistently giving me readouts of 100 calories higher than my Fitbit for my workouts. You can't trust gym machines. MFP's estimates aren't much better. Get either a Fitbit or a heart rate monitor with a chest strap if you want to be accurate with your workout calorie burns.
I might consider getting one! I heard they're great. & yeah that makes sense about the gym machines, but I do try to stick to higher intensity ellipticals. The stair machine also makes me sweat like crazy, so I know it's burning something. But thanks everyone for the input. I think I need to find a more reliable method of finding out how many calories I burn, or just stick to swimming and Zumba of course!
For the most part people answered my questions. Lol. This post turned ridiculous and entertaining real fast. But also, just remember some people have grown up thinking different things about nutrition, so like me we are still learning. If you comment, "Just no", that isn't going to help at all, especially since I had a valid and perfectly reasonable question. Thanks for all who didn't butcher it though.
Just as a point of information
A fitbit is not good on ellipticals
A HRM is only good if steady state cardio
Sweat does not equate to calorie burn unfortunately ...I kinda wish it did
0 -
DeguelloTex wrote: »
You could move to Texas and eat whatever you wanted just by walking to the mailbox.steponebyone wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »
Gym machines are notorious for over-stating calorie burns.
Hmm, that sounds more like an opinion than a fact to me.
I have the same informed opinion based on lots of experience around here, as well as reading about the topic.
If you are an experienced, skilled swimmer, then yes you could be burning 500 calories from that. I doubt you are from the elliptical in an hour, and brisk walking won't burn calories at that rate.
That's why people recommend eating back only half until you see results and can adjust. You should eat back some, though.
If you think the machine is right for you, totally fine to start with eating them all back, though, and just adjust down if you don't like the results.
Thatlemurcat12 wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »steponebyone wrote: »
Gym machines are notorious for over-stating calorie burns.
Hmm, that sounds more like an opinion than a fact to me.
I have the same informed opinion based on lots of experience around here, as well as reading about the topic.
If you are an experienced, skilled swimmer, then yes you could be burning 500 calories from that. I doubt you are from the elliptical in an hour, and brisk walking won't burn calories at that rate.
That's why people recommend eating back only half until you see results and can adjust. You should eat back some, though.
If you think the machine is right for you, totally fine to start with eating them all back, though, and just adjust down if you don't like the results.
OK thsteponebyone wrote: »Timelordlady85 wrote: »omg, apples have no calories hooray! j/k, but I input my activity level and stats in MFP and aim for half my exercise calories back. How are you tracking your calories burned? I use a polar chest strap, I noticed that MPF tends to over estimate calorie burns.
That sounds reasonable. Last night I went to bed SUPER hungry, so I probably need to add 200 lbs when I burn that much. For me, I'm big on using different machines at the gym, and they have the amount on them of calories burned.
gym machines don't know who you are, individually, even if you put in your information. I have a Fitbit Charge HR and an elliptical that I entered all my personal statistics into. My Fitbit is very accurate at tracking my calorie burns during my workouts, and my elliptical is consistently giving me readouts of 100 calories higher than my Fitbit for my workouts. You can't trust gym machines. MFP's estimates aren't much better. Get either a Fitbit or a heart rate monitor with a chest strap if you want to be accurate with your workout calorie burns.
I might consider getting one! I heard they're great. & yeah that makes sense about the gym machines, but I do try to stick to higher intensity ellipticals. The stair machine also makes me sweat like crazy, so I know it's burning something. But thanks everyone for the input. I think I need to find a more reliable method of finding out how many calories I burn, or just stick to swimming and Zumba of course!
For the most part people answered my questions. Lol. This post turned ridiculous and entertaining real fast. But also, just remember some people have grown up thinking different things about nutrition, so like me we are still learning. If you comment, "Just no", that isn't going to help at all, especially since I had a valid and perfectly reasonable question. Thanks for all who didn't butcher it though.
Just as a point of information
A fitbit is not good on ellipticals
A HRM is only good if steady state cardio
Sweat does not equate to calorie burn unfortunately ...I kinda wish it did
It's going to 40 celcius here soon. I'll be sweating before I even get of bed...
0 -
livcrabtree wrote: »Okay so, 3500 calories is equivalent to 1 pound. Exercise is a key element to losing weight, but diet is just as important. Calories are not necessarily the key to dropping pounds, but in fact what you eat is significant. If you eat 1500 calories of junk food a day, or 2000 calories of healthy food a day, you're certainly more likely to loose it by eating healthier. Cutting back on calories can be hard as you're not used to it, so aim for 6 meals a day: breakfast, morning snack, lunch, afternoon snack, dinner and night snack. Snacks are essential as they'll prevent craving junk food during the day. Try and snack on apples as they're equivalent to 0 calories as your body burns off the amount of calories in them trying to digest it.
Remember 3500 calories = 1 pound. Therefore if you're eating 1500 calories a day, it would be ideal if you could burn off 200, which would make you lose it faster!
I hope this helped, good luck
None of this is accurate. A calorie is a calorie is a calorie when it comes to weight loss. Junk and Healthy food are all in the perception.
Nutrition wise, foods are different, but weight loss wise 1500 calories = 1500 calories, 2000 calories = 2000 calories, no matter where they come from.0 -
steponebyone wrote: »
Don't trust those machines, their counts are overestimated. About 75% of that amount is more accurate.0 -
Supposedly the calorie estimates from machines are from cycling - but it has to be properly maintained/calibrated.
I think 1500 sounds low. I go for 1300-1400 on inactive/upperbody strength training days, and 1600-1700 on cardio days. At 128 and 5'4", I lose weight on that. (Then I stop logging and go to 133.)
Underestimate your exercise calories, but not to the extent that you're hungry and weak. Just listen to your body and watch the scale and your clothing size. BTW, heavy duty cardio actually kills my appetite.
I'm 5'4" and lightly active, so you definately should be eating more. (Well, probably)
Good luck!0 -
Oop I meant best calorie estimates.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions