to do or not to do Bypass surgery ?
Replies
-
Remember that the surgery is not a fix all. Make sure you know the after math of these surgeries. Smaller portions is a must or you may become physically ill. I knew one gal that after the surgery any breads, pasta, or cakes would make her puke.
Unless your weight is so bad your told without extreme weight loss now, your going to die soon, I'd work on life changes without the surgery.
Like changes are a must or this weight will return.0 -
I want to thank everyone that answered me. In a way I know many of youn are right. My lifestyle with unhealthy carbs, fast foods , and emotional eating has been going on and off. It is up to me to make that decision or not with surgery or without. .to make those changes happen. The reason I asked is because I have seen people with the surgery they lose weight and they are eating so unhealthy in which it looks they may gain all the weight back. I thought or I think maybe with surgery I have no way out and I must do it no matter what. However, the question I should be asking myself is; do I really want to change My relationship with food? Do I really have the will power of doing it? Because it's true I can have the surgery and yet eat wrong. That's where it will get ugly. Yes, I will lose the weight however, if I don't change my eating habits . Nothing ain't going to change. ...I have lots to think about. If I am going to go through this or not. Thank you all0
-
Why are you asking now ?
Ann Surg. 2010 Aug;252(2):319-24. doi: 10.1097/SLA.0b013e3181e90b31.
Long-term results of laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy for obesity.
Himpens J1, Dobbeleir J, Peeters G.
Author information
Abstract
OBJECTIVE:
To determine the mid- and long-term efficacy and possible side effects of laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy as treatment for morbid obesity.
SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA:
Laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy is still controversial as single and final treatment for morbid obesity. Some favorable short-term results have been published, however long-term results are still lacking.
METHODS:
In the period between November 2001 and October 2002, 53 consecutive morbidly obese patients who, according to our personal algorithm, were qualified for restrictive surgery were selected for laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy. Of the 53 patients, 11 received an additional malabsorptive procedure at a later stage because of weight regain. The percentage of excess weight loss (EWL) was assessed at 3 and 6 years postoperatively. A retrospective review of a prospectively collected database was performed for evaluation after 3 years. Recently, after the sixth postoperative year, patients were again contacted and invited to fill out a questionnaire.
RESULTS:
Full cooperation was obtained in 41 patients, a response rate of 78%. Although after 3 years a mean EWL of 72.8% was documented, after 6 years EWL had dropped to 57.3%, which according to the Reinhold criteria is still satisfactory. These results included 11 patients who had benefited from an additional malabsorptive procedure (duodenal switch) and 2 patients who underwent a "resleeve" between the third and sixth postoperative year. Analyzing the results of the subgroup of 30 patients receiving only sleeve gastrectomy, we found a 3-year %EWL of 77.5% and 6+ year %EWL of 53.3%. The differences between the third and sixth postoperative year were statistically significant in both groups. Concerning long-term quality of life patient acceptance stayed good after 6 + years despite the fact that late, new gastro-esophageal reflux complaints appeared in 21% of patients.
CONCLUSIONS:
In this long-term report of laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy, it appears that after 6+ years the mean excess weight loss exceeds 50%. However, weight regain and de novo gastroesophageal reflux symptoms appear between the third and the sixth postoperative year. This unfavorable evolution might have been prevented in some patients by continued follow-up office visits beyond the third year. Patient acceptance remains good after 6+ years.0 -
I used to believe in surgery, but I've seen a few things that have changed my own mind -
1. I used to volunteer with a woman who over 15 years had had a gastric balloon, then a band, then 2 x bypasses. After all that, she was back at her start weight within years of each. She had health problems, couldn't absorb minerals properly and couldn't eat normally, yet was still overweight. It had somehow impaired her liver function and she was always a bit yellow as well.
2. My sister had a gastric band. Lost weight (not all of it, probably 42lbs over a year) then gained it all back. She's still paying the surgery off now. She lost more weight when she met her husband who isn't so interested in food.
I feel the biggest obstacle we face in losing weight isn't the food or the exercise - it's our mind.
I'm reading two books right now that really hit the nail on the head with me. One is by Judith Beck called The Beck Diet solution. She is a psychologist - her book is really amazing and is actually quite funny in parts. She gives you a 12 week programme to retrain your habits. You get 1 simple task a day to do. The other book is by Tom Venuto and is called The Body Fat solution. He is a genius! His book covers the background in fat loss and the emotional side, but also gives you a home work out routine and an eating plan too. I've followed his advice for a week and home workout and lost 6lbs and shrunk an inch all over too.
I'd really recommend exploring these books whilst you consider the surgery.
I wish you luck whatever path you choose.
0 -
Here's my thinking on the subject. First, you have to lose some weight before you can have the surgery. If you can lose that weight on your own, you can lose more weight on your own. Also, you have to make major changes to your eating after the surgery. If you can make those changes, you can make those major changes without the surgery.
Why not give yourself a year of doing it without the surgery, but living "as if" you'd had the surgery? Ask your doctor to help you follow the post-op plan, without having to actually be post-op. If you stick with it, great! You don't need surgery. If you can't stick with it, it means you probably wouldn't have been successful with the surgery either.
This is exactly what I did. For two weeks I ate as if I was post-op. And it was tough. I decided that if I wanted to eat that Big Mac or that piece of chocolate cake that I wanted that option. All I had left to do was schedule my surgery date and it was a done deal. I was paying out of pocket for the surgery and decided that if I could lose the weight on my own that I would use that money for plastic surgery and that's what I have done. Was it easy losing the weight? At first, no. After I learned the concept of CICO and moderation that's when it became easier. I still have about 10 pounds that I want to lose and those are being stubborn but I have the rest of my life to do it. I will be glad to chat with you or be friends if you like. I'm not very vocal on the boards but would love more friends. Take care and good luck.0 -
Ok my opinion......surgery won't help! I also know someone that had surgery and put on weight as the food attitude didn't change! Now I'm also ADHD lists girl you need to start your lists!! Put a list on the fridge everymorning of you daily eating plan! Do you do this for the rest of your daily activities to get everything done? I have black boards and white boards everywhere to keep me on track!! Use them but remember short lists and remove and add after each meal or job is done!! ADHA and over eating go hand in hand no surgery is going to change that....sorry
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Read the success boards and you'll see that those people are just like you and me. I wouldn't alter the functioning of my body surgically, to correct a psychological issue. I'd work on the psychological issue. All of us on here have issues, or we wouldn't be here. I would never not want to be able to eat a candy bar or a steak again. But I am working on fitting those things into my life in moderation. Good luck with your decision. There's no rush.0
-
OP did you read the link I posted? I think anyone considering weight loss surgery should read this first.0
-
Christine_72 wrote: »
Wow what an honest, heart felt article! The lady I know that had it done (gastric band) struggled so so much, we kept commenting on how awesome she looked but she just changed emotionally so much, we were worried, she was melting chocolate in the microwave so she could eat more her eating habits were actually getting worse, in the end we all lost contact with her she changed her phone number and moved house I ran into her at the supermarket about 5 years later and she was back to her former size. She said hello but not much more than that, I gave her my phone number and said we must catch up, she said yes but I never heard from her 0 -
summerkissed wrote: »Christine_72 wrote: »
Wow what an honest, heart felt article! The lady I know that had it done (gastric band) struggled so so much, we kept commenting on how awesome she looked but she just changed emotionally so much, we were worried, she was melting chocolate in the microwave so she could eat more her eating habits were actually getting worse, in the end we all lost contact with her she changed her phone number and moved house I ran into her at the supermarket about 5 years later and she was back to her former size. She said hello but not much more than that, I gave her my phone number and said we must catch up, she said yes but I never heard from her
Far out
Her and so many other people go through the trauma of surgery and everything that comes along with it, only to regain all the weight back.
0 -
because Its go to know and I am having second thoughts about it. The more I am informed and educated about the subject and opinions and articles the cons and pros, I will decided If I am ready for this or not or if its for me or not.ericGold15 wrote: »Why are you asking now ?
0 -
This is exactly what I did. For two weeks I ate as if I was post-op. And it was tough. I decided that if I wanted to eat that Big Mac or that piece of chocolate cake that I wanted that option. All I had left to do was schedule my surgery date and it was a done deal. I was paying out of pocket for the surgery and decided that if I could lose the weight on my own that I would use that money for plastic surgery and that's what I have done. Was it easy losing the weight? At first, no. After I learned the concept of CICO and moderation that's when it became easier. I still have about 10 pounds that I want to lose and those are being stubborn but I have the rest of my life to do it. I will be glad to chat with you or be friends if you like. I'm not very vocal on the boards but would love more friends. Take care and good luck.
That would be great .0 -
summerkissed wrote: »Ok my opinion......surgery won't help! I also know someone that had surgery and put on weight as the food attitude didn't change! Now I'm also ADHD lists girl you need to start your lists!! Put a list on the fridge everymorning of you daily eating plan! Do you do this for the rest of your daily activities to get everything done? I have black boards and white boards everywhere to keep me on track!! Use them but remember short lists and remove and add after each meal or job is done!! ADHA and over eating go hand in hand no surgery is going to change that....sorry
This is great Advice. Thank you
0 -
Christine_72 wrote: »OP did you read the link I posted? I think anyone considering weight loss surgery should read this first.
I haven't been able to read it fully I read half and got to the part of physiological side of it .. I can say it's sad. I also wondered the same . Because even now that I haven't done the surgery it's getting to me. perhaps not in the same way but I am thinking to much about the " what ifs" and what could happen and the damage that can be done. something to think about.0 -
summerkissed wrote: »Christine_72 wrote: »
Wow what an honest, heart felt article! The lady I know that had it done (gastric band) struggled so so much, we kept commenting on how awesome she looked but she just changed emotionally so much, we were worried, she was melting chocolate in the microwave so she could eat more her eating habits were actually getting worse, in the end we all lost contact with her she changed her phone number and moved house I ran into her at the supermarket about 5 years later and she was back to her former size. She said hello but not much more than that, I gave her my phone number and said we must catch up, she said yes but I never heard from her
" that's my fear" I don't want to be that way.0 -
Here is a positive scholarly article.
http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=199587
"Effective weight loss was achieved in morbidly obese patients after undergoing bariatric surgery. A substantial majority of patients with diabetes, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and obstructive sleep apnea experienced complete resolution or improvement."0 -
Lots of great advice given. Only you can make that decision, it's your life & your body. I thought about it, went to a few seminars given by my hospital. I work in the field and the potential complications & life long issues that can happen was more than enough to convince me to do it the old fashioned way...eat less, move more. Seriously if you have to lose weight anyhow to have the surgery, why not just do it all on your own. The procedure is not a cure all nor will the pounds just fall off you. You didn't put them on over nite, they're not going to disappear after the surgery. The food issues you have now are not going to go away after your stomach gets sleeved, banded or bypassed. You might be one of the lucky ones, surgery goes well, no issues and the pounds fly off you & all your eating issues miraculously disappear....but realize that those who do lose the weight can easily re gain it like all of us who did it the old fashioned way...there are ways to overeat even with the surgery. You are young and you have young kids ..really think about it-surgery is not something to rush into. Try it the old fashioned way, you can always get back on the list for surgery after you give it a LOT of thought.
Edited after saw the note above mine: When I started MPF (mid 2012) I had just got diagnosed with Type 2, had HTN, high cholesterol/triglycerides...was on a total of 5 meds for these issues. Lost the weight, no longer take any meds nor am I considered to have DM, HTN or lipid issues.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions