Cheat Day Or No Treat Day?

Options
VodkaAddictx
VodkaAddictx Posts: 33 Member
in Health and Weight Loss
Do you have a treat day?? Or not? If So how often? Life's boring behaving all the time...
«13

Replies

  • qpmomma1
    qpmomma1 Posts: 221 Member
    Options
    If I am craving something, I work it into my day. A few days ago I had 2 twinkies. It wasn't the best thing in the world, but I stayed within my calories and was able to get back on track with nutrition the next day.
  • Sapphires4me
    Sapphires4me Posts: 93 Member
    Options
    I agree, don't deprive yourself of something then you really can't focus on anything but that. Fit it into your calories and add a little to your workout. Everything in moderation and accounted for.
  • T1DCarnivoreRunner
    T1DCarnivoreRunner Posts: 11,502 Member
    Options
    At first, I would give myself cheat days when I reached certain milestones. Mind you, I have a tremendous appetite, so it was very nice to be able to finally eat as much as I wanted after feeling like I'm starving for so many months that it took to reach that "milestone" weight.

    So I would lose for 4-6 months and then have a "cheat day." I would log most of what I ate on cheat days, but would not restrict. Some cheat days were 15K-18K calories, and sometimes 20K-30K calories. I don't think there was ever a day where I exceeded 32K calories. Of course, the problem with eating as much as I want is that I would often gain back months of weight loss in a single day. That awareness made me give up on cheat days. I admit that it is now a lot more difficult to stay within my calorie goals and I even have found myself for the last 2 months going over calories once or twice per week (just by 1K-2K calories, not as much as I would if I had a real cheat day) a lot more often because I can't stand feeling like I'm starving every day and I know a cheat day destroys so much progress. Still, I'm considering doing another one to "fill my tank" so I can go back to a deficit every day without feeling overwhelmed right away.
  • Need2Exerc1se
    Need2Exerc1se Posts: 13,576 Member
    Options
    I do. I don't always have a treat when I'm craving it. Sometimes I'll just plan to have it on the weekend. This has two benefits for me. It has taught me not to freak out over every little craving. I can have that food whenever I want. I control it. Plus, about 1/2 the time the craving goes away by the time I planned to eat it. It was just a passing thing.

    Most of my treat or cheat or whatever you want to call a high calorie day are occasions - holidays, birthdays, parties, gatherings, etc. I have more than enough of these in my life without purposely adding more high calorie days.
  • MelaniaTrump
    MelaniaTrump Posts: 2,694 Member
    edited January 2016
    Options
    For me it was disastrous. I would rather save up the calories during the week for that day and enjoy. Here is my entry which is in the food log database.
    Carry Over - Unused Calories From Past Week
  • CooCooPuff
    CooCooPuff Posts: 4,374 Member
    Options
    I add in foods into my daily goals and accept that there will be days when I go over, holidays, vacation, etc, and just roll with it. If I need to, I'll undergo a slight deficit.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    Options
    I work the foods I want into my daily plans -- I don't want to divide the rest of my eating life into "behaving myself" and "not behaving myself." On certain days (Thanksgiving, Christmas), I won't try to hit a certain calorie goal -- but I still log everything.
  • oolou
    oolou Posts: 765 Member
    Options
    kimerfy wrote: »
    Do you have a treat day?? Or not? If So how often? Life's boring behaving all the time...

    No, I try instead to work my treats into my calorie allowance. Currently magnum icecream bars are my thing. And brie and crackers. I also plan for digestive biscuits twice a week when my theatre group meets!
  • joelacy11
    joelacy11 Posts: 42 Member
    Options
    If I crave something really bad, I wait until the end of the week and have it. I keep my macros lower through the day and then bang PIZZA. I always have too much and feel sick - its fantastic.
    get your craving out of the way and it puts you back on track. You could also try IIFYM. I use this approach to some of meals every now and again.
  • VodkaAddictx
    VodkaAddictx Posts: 33 Member
    Options
    joelacy11 wrote: »
    If I crave something really bad, I wait until the end of the week and have it. I keep my macros lower through the day and then bang PIZZA. I always have too much and feel sick - its fantastic.
    get your craving out of the way and it puts you back on track. You could also try IIFYM. I use this approach to some of meals every now and again.

    Haha this is what I do!!!! But was wondering If I was ruining everything I'd been doing.. I have a serious blow out.. a pub meal or takeaway then can't get enough chocolate n sweets... Then get straight back on track again the day after.. Some times have a treat next day then jump back on the wagon!!
  • kshama2001
    kshama2001 Posts: 27,933 Member
    Options
    My appetite spikes up premenstrually so I eat at maintenance for a few days. Mostly just more normal foods, but I have some higher calorie treats then as well.
  • oolou
    oolou Posts: 765 Member
    Options
    kimerfy wrote: »

    Haha this is what I do!!!! But was wondering If I was ruining everything I'd been doing.. I have a serious blow out.. a pub meal or takeaway then can't get enough chocolate n sweets... Then get straight back on track again the day after.. Some times have a treat next day then jump back on the wagon!!

    Whether you're ruining everything or not depends on how much you've blown your calorie deficit for the week.

    For example, if you manage a total deficit of 3000 calories over a week (eating at a deficit of 500 cal a day) - but on your cheat day you eat at a surplus of 3500 cals over your daily goal ... yeah you just ruined your week. You won't gain, but you also won't lose.

    But you'll only know for sure if you log everything you eat on your cheat day :)

  • ashesfromfire
    ashesfromfire Posts: 867 Member
    Options
    I love cheat days / cheat meals. Firstly, because I plan on enjoying my favorite foods for the rest of my life but this teaches me moderation. It also helps me with cravings. I might be dying for a giant sugary latte and bagle, and if I still want it three days from now on cheat day then I will definitely have it and enjoy it! But it gives me a place to put those cravings I would otherwise give into. And, moreover, only a couple of those cravings last until cheat day, so instead of having 15 indulgences a week, I have 2 or 3 and it all shakes out better in the end ♡
  • Need2Exerc1se
    Need2Exerc1se Posts: 13,576 Member
    Options
    kimerfy wrote: »
    joelacy11 wrote: »
    If I crave something really bad, I wait until the end of the week and have it. I keep my macros lower through the day and then bang PIZZA. I always have too much and feel sick - its fantastic.
    get your craving out of the way and it puts you back on track. You could also try IIFYM. I use this approach to some of meals every now and again.

    Haha this is what I do!!!! But was wondering If I was ruining everything I'd been doing.. I have a serious blow out.. a pub meal or takeaway then can't get enough chocolate n sweets... Then get straight back on track again the day after.. Some times have a treat next day then jump back on the wagon!!

    This may or may not be a problem. If your overall calories (on average or weekly) are still in a deficit then you should lose fat. But, it is possible to undo 6 days of deficit with one 'serious blow out'.
  • Spierce02
    Spierce02 Posts: 29 Member
    Options
    Every couple of days I'll have one soda or two lindt truffles. Usually I'm below my calorie goal so I don't feel guilty about and it hasn't had an impact on weight. I use to live off of soda and chocolate and knowing that I can still have it once in a while is great.
  • benzieboxx
    benzieboxx Posts: 253 Member
    Options
    I had a mochi ice cream last night. Best 120 calories ever. I don't have "cheat days" because I will go overboard, but I definitely treat myself. If I feel too deprived I'll binge and that's kind of the opposite of what I want.

    What really helped me was I stopped thinking of my favorite foods as "bad". There are no "bad" foods. Or good foods. There's just food. I mean yeah obviously there are foods that are healthier than others, but I still don't label them. Labeling things just lays the guilt on me when I do indulge in them.
  • cbelc2
    cbelc2 Posts: 762 Member
    Options
    I keep some dark chocolate for a treat as long as it fits into my daily cals, carbs, and sugar. Do I go all out? No.
  • harrybananas
    harrybananas Posts: 292 Member
    Options
    Don't deprive yourself. Treat yourself every day. Don't be 60yrs old and teethless and regret you didn't eat what you wanted when you were young.
  • TaraHancock827
    TaraHancock827 Posts: 37 Member
    Options
    I cheat every Saturday. If I want 14 donuts then that's what I eat. Yes it derails everything I did from the week but I cant diet 7 days a week or id go crazy. Maybe that's why I cant loose the 20 pounds I desperately want to loose...hello!! LOL
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    Options
    TaraHancock827 wrote: »
    I cheat every Saturday. If I want 14 donuts then that's what I eat. Yes it derails everything I did from the week but I cant diet 7 days a week or id go crazy. Maybe that's why I cant loose the 20 pounds I desperately want to loose...hello!! LOL

    Yes, "cheat days" are only compatible with weight loss if the person using them doesn't cancel out the calorie deficit they've created during the rest of the week.

Categories