Have you tried GLP1 medications and found it didn't work for you? We'd like to hear about your experiences, what you tried, why it didn't work and how you're doing now. Click here to tell us your story

Body fat %

Wombat468
Wombat468 Posts: 191 Member
in Health and Weight Loss
I have one of those body fat % scales. I know they're not madly accurate, but they have to be in the right ballpark, yes? So far I've lost 32lb, which is over 1/7 of my bodyweight. I've also been lifting, and can see muscle. My fat % has apparently decreased only from 39% to 37%. Surely this can't be right?!

Replies

  • jemhh
    jemhh Posts: 14,261 Member
    I read some study recently that found an 8% error in either direction, meaning that you may be anywhere from 29-47%. I really would not rely on those things at all. My scale has had me at the same bf% from the day I got it, 2 years and many pounds ago, before I started lifting weights.
  • robininfl
    robininfl Posts: 1,137 Member
    I don't think they are accurate for everyone.

    I use these:
    Calipers
    Online calculators (put in weight, height, measurements, it estimates)
    AND
    the bioimpedence device (like your scale but handheld)

    and all of them, for me, are within 2% of each other so I feel that I have a reasonable estimate.

    Also, it depends on how much you weigh. Fat as a % of weight is a relative measurement so if you, say, started at 237 and 39% bf, and lost 37 pounds and it was about half fat, half other stuff you would land right at that 37%. Even though, in that example, you would have lost over 18lb of fat. I don't think it's possible to lose only fat...

    So I agree the device is most likely wrong, but remember that the bodyfat as a % is relative. You can lose fat, your body weight drops so then the fat % is calculating off a smaller mass.
  • quiksylver296
    quiksylver296 Posts: 28,439 Member
    jemhh wrote: »
    I read some study recently that found an 8% error in either direction, meaning that you may be anywhere from 29-47%. I really would not rely on those things at all. My scale has had me at the same bf% from the day I got it, 2 years and many pounds ago, before I started lifting weights.

    Same. I don't even look at that number.
  • DanyellMcGinnis
    DanyellMcGinnis Posts: 315 Member
    I have lost about 25 pounds so far and went from 32.1% to 25.9%, according to my body fat scale. (I am starting to see muscle, as well, mostly in the upper body where I have always been smaller.) That is reasonably close to what the online calculators are giving me, and the trend is in the right direction. I don't think I would emphatically state that I had 25.9% body fat, but the trend makes me think the device is basically working for me.
  • mburgess458
    mburgess458 Posts: 480 Member
    My scale is worthless for bodyfat %. One time of day it always says 5%... like every day at that time it says 5%. I think that might be its minimum display. Other times of day it will vary from 17% to 20%. I had a BodPod measurement done (similar idea to water displacement in a dunk tank, but it is air displacement in a pod) that said 11%. Comparing to pictures of what various bodyfat percentages look like the 11% seems about right.
  • Asher_Ethan
    Asher_Ethan Posts: 2,430 Member
    My scale says I'm 30% body fat.
  • cecsav1
    cecsav1 Posts: 714 Member
    Hydration is a factor as well concerning the bioimpedence scales. Also, I know the CICO police are gonna come after me, but... if you're working out regularly, and eating at a calorie deficit, but you're not eating enough protein, your body will burn muscle. Enough protein is the difference between losing weight and losing fat.
  • hhazzouri
    hhazzouri Posts: 103 Member
    Those scales are not even close to accurate...
  • rollerjog
    rollerjog Posts: 154 Member
    hydrostatic body fat test is the one you want to get, very accurate
  • MissusMoon
    MissusMoon Posts: 1,900 Member
    CiaraCatch wrote: »
    I have one of those body fat % scales. I know they're not madly accurate, but they have to be in the right ballpark, yes? So far I've lost 32lb, which is over 1/7 of my bodyweight. I've also been lifting, and can see muscle. My fat % has apparently decreased only from 39% to 37%. Surely this can't be right?!

    Body fat scales are basically using a simple algorithm. They have no idea what your body fat truly is. You'd have a more accurate result measuring neck/waist/hips and using a website.
  • cmtristani
    cmtristani Posts: 117 Member
    My scale isn't too far off right now, but in the last three days it has measured my bf% at 11.4, 13.2, and 12.2. I am ultra ritualistic in my morning routine, weighing myself under the exact same conditions every time, and the BF varies a lot. Three weeks ago doing a caliper test I was 12.4%. BF% on a scale is a measuring tool that if you put faith in will disappoint you often.

Categories