Being too loud while dead lifting?
Ensmardj
Posts: 12 Member
I had an issue today at my gym because I was “smashing” the weights while I was dead lifting. I just want a little feedback from you guys because I felt like I wasn't being that loud to be honest. I was dead lifting 245 lbs which I know is not that much but for me is a PR, when this girl walked to me and told me that I can't “smash” the weights like that in the gym because I was disturbing her birds (I don't know wtf she was referring too). I was filming my self while I was doing it because I don't have a workout partner, so I check I'm not rounding my back or *kitten* up my form this way. The weights weren't bouncing at all, and I was just letting the bar go (I wasn't actually dropping the bar, just trying not to hold it as it goes down) as you are supposed in the negative part of the lift. I was grunting a little bit, but nothing too loud. Just a Small grunt when I was locking my lift. I want to know if any of you guys have had this problem before, and how you deal with it. Also, I want to know if there is a gym around Hartford, CT where this kind of problem do not happen because I want to get bigger and stronger, and I don't want to have people around bothering me while I try to progress. It just doesn't feel right to be thinking about not making too much noise to be honest... It's a gym after all, isn't it?
Thanks you
Thanks you
0
Replies
-
How far above the ground were you dropping the bar? Personally, I lower it all the way to the floor. I find the negatives to be helpful to the exercise. Sometimes I even pause the motion halfway down and simply hold it there.... it helps me to identify weak spots in my form.
*edited because grammar and spelling is hard0 -
This content has been removed.
-
BecomingBane wrote: »How far above the ground were you dropping the bar? Personally, I lower it all the way to the floor. I find the negatives to be helpful to the exercise. Sometimes I even pause to motion halfway down and simply hold it there.... it helps me to identify weak spots in my form.
My bad, I didn't explain it very well. I didn't drop the bar, I hold it until it touched the ground on every rep. When I say that (I let it go) I was referring that I wasn't trying to hold it because I don't want to snap something in my lower back.0 -
Even when I'm doing a 1RM, I don't let go of the bar unless my grip fails me. If I'm doing reps, it's touch and go, controlled throughout the movement.
My bad, I didn't explain it very well. I didn't drop the bar, I hold it until it touched the ground on every rep. When I say that (I let it go) I was referring that I wasn't trying to hold it because I don't want to snap something in my lower back.0 -
Even when I'm doing a 1RM, I don't let go of the bar unless my grip fails me. If I'm doing reps, it's touch and go, controlled throughout the movement.
X 2
Most the people smashing weights do so at the expense of proper form and instability. Drop the weight down to controlled lifts and you won't have to drop the weights. However, I assume since you were filming it was for the social media effect...all the Internet fitness stars do it. Drives me nuts how inefficient they are.0 -
Even when I'm doing a 1RM, I don't let go of the bar unless my grip fails me. If I'm doing reps, it's touch and go, controlled throughout the movement.
X 2
Most the people smashing weights do so at the expense of proper form and instability. Drop the weight down to controlled lifts and you won't have to drop the weights. However, I assume since you were filming it was for the social media effect...all the Internet fitness stars do it. Drives me nuts how inefficient they are.
Yes, I didn't explain my self properly on that point. What I meant to say is that I wasn't trying to hold the bar, but I didn't actually drop the bar. I always hold it neat and tidy until it touches the ground on every rep.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I am not judging. I don't think I drink a beer without it going on IG.
2 -
Can you share your form video so people can give you pointers on where your form might be breaking down? Or at least see what you are referring to?0
-
i dont drop the weights, but i also wouldn't care if anyone had an issue with any sounds i make in the gym.2
-
I'm still trying to wrap my head around "disturbing her birds" ?!4
-
I wouldn't worry about it. Deadlifts with any amount of weight make a lot of noise. Period.3
-
-
BecomingBane wrote: »Can you share your form video so people can give you pointers on where your form might be breaking down? Or at least see what you are referring to?
+1. You have video evidence, post the video evidence and we can objectively tell you if she had a point or not.0 -
I had an issue today at my gym because I was “smashing” the weights while I was dead lifting. I just want a little feedback from you guys because I felt like I wasn't being that loud to be honest. I was dead lifting 245 lbs which I know is not that much but for me is a PR, when this girl walked to me and told me that I can't “smash” the weights like that in the gym because I was disturbing her birds (I don't know wtf she was referring too). I was filming my self while I was doing it because I don't have a workout partner, so I check I'm not rounding my back or *kitten* up my form this way. The weights weren't bouncing at all, and I was just letting the bar go (I wasn't actually dropping the bar, just trying not to hold it as it goes down) as you are supposed in the negative part of the lift. I was grunting a little bit, but nothing too loud. Just a Small grunt when I was locking my lift. I want to know if any of you guys have had this problem before, and how you deal with it. Also, I want to know if there is a gym around Hartford, CT where this kind of problem do not happen because I want to get bigger and stronger, and I don't want to have people around bothering me while I try to progress. It just doesn't feel right to be thinking about not making too much noise to be honest... It's a gym after all, isn't it?
Thanks you
Meh, tell her your grip slipped and to go feed her birds.
Anyway, sounds like a commercial gym... Find a more hardcore/athletic based one.1 -
mangamadayan wrote: »As the weights get heavier, a little sound and grunting is inevitable. But don't hold yourself back because if you control your grunts, you may find it difficult to lift and cause injury to yourself. Do you want to comply with an imbecile or do you want to not cause yourself any injury.
However, some jocks drop the whole barbell on the ground as a show of cockdom and that is totally not cool and is lame. Don't do that, of that is what it is. Then she is definitely right.
Yeah, I was mostly trying not to injure myself since it was a PR for me. The problem is that the girl is from the gym staff, and I didn't want to get kicked out or anything like that.0 -
My bad, I didn't explain it very well. I didn't drop the bar, I hold it until it touched the ground on every rep. When I say that (I let it go) I was referring that I wasn't trying to hold it because I don't want to snap something in my lower back.
I know you're question has already been answered, but I'm so confused and really want to understand. At what point are you letting it go? Or are you saying that you're not letting go of it but also not resisting the weight when lowering it such that it's essentially a semi-controlled drop? I'm not trying to be dense or obnoxious! Just trying to picture it!0 -
I have witnessed a few idiots purposely dropping weights again and again, when it is meaningless, most as a "look at how mean and strong I am" signal. I mean, if you keep dropping dumbbells 10 times during bicep curls, you are either doing it to grab attention, or you really are clueless, that type of thing. So maybe this was what this person thought you were doing? Especially if she only heard you and did not see you?0
-
Was this PF? :laugh:2
-
I've been patiently waiting for the video in the five minutes it took me to read this thread...5
-
You should control the bar on the way down. But it's gonna make some noise. I try to minimize the noise personally.0
-
Maybe by "birds" she was talking about other women in the gym? It's not very polite, but I've heard people refer to women as "birds," although imho it's a tad old-fashioned.
Or she's just weird. tbh it's more likely she's just a little odd.0 -
distinctlybeautiful wrote: »My bad, I didn't explain it very well. I didn't drop the bar, I hold it until it touched the ground on every rep. When I say that (I let it go) I was referring that I wasn't trying to hold it because I don't want to snap something in my lower back.
I know you're question has already been answered, but I'm so confused and really want to understand. At what point are you letting it go? Or are you saying that you're not letting go of it but also not resisting the weight when lowering it such that it's essentially a semi-controlled drop? I'm not trying to be dense or obnoxious! Just trying to picture it!
yeah I honestly don't get it either.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
-
I do the same thing when I deadlift touch the bar to the ground, no one at CrossFit has ever complain because we all do it, when we are lifting and trying to beat the clock.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions