Creatine Questions - water weight and non responders

mkakids
mkakids Posts: 1,913 Member
edited May 2016 in Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
I know that usually when you begin creatine, there is water weight gain of a couple of pounds (3-5ish?). I have also read that some people do not respond to Creatine.

I have been taking Creatine mono-hydrate for 14 days now. I did a loading phase of 20mg for 5 days and am now taking 5mg per day for the last 9 days.

I have not seen any water weight gain, I have also not noticed a difference in endurance or recovery (in running and strength training).

Is it possible that I am a non responder? I know its only been 14 days, and I would usually give it a full month before asking, but not having any water weight gain is making me wonder.

I have tried googling 'Creatine non resonder' and 'no water weight with creatine' and the like, but all I get is anecdotal evidence stating that all people do not respond to creatine.

I'm just curious to hear from other people who may have more insight than I do. Regardless, I will continue to take it for a full 6 weeks to gauge any progress/differences that may occur. I already have it, and I'm not seeing any ill effects, so I might as well keep taking it to see what happens!

ETA: I am currently eating in a slight deficit of around 250 a day.

Replies

  • viren19890
    viren19890 Posts: 778 Member
    TBH I didn't see a water weight gain either. I also did the creatine uptake during my deficit -so I should've seen an increase but did not.

  • psuLemon
    psuLemon Posts: 38,427 MFP Moderator
    There is roughly 20-30% of people who do not respond to creatine. Often, those are the people tend to have a good amount of meat. But if you aren't seeing an increase in reps/weights, then you may be a non responder like I am.

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/comment/35277672/#Comment_35277672
    The above thread has great information on creatine, below is an abstract:

    Creatine monohydrate (like all forms of creatine) increases intracellular water retention to give your muscles a fuller, thicker look. However, this water is deposited inside the actual muscle cell and not subcutaneously (underneath the skin). For that reason, creatine monohydrate does NOT cause any form of “bloating”.

Categories