1500 calories a day to lose 1 lb a week. Possible?
Nightmare_Queen88
Posts: 304 Member
I started my journey in March of this year 268 lbs and I'm now at 197 lbs. I was losing 2 lbs or more a week and now I'm losing 1.5-2 lbs a week. But in order to preserve muscle I want to try to lose slower. I started out eating at 1600 calories a day, but sadly I got impatient and dropped it 1200 calories a day. I realized how unhealthy that was for me so I started eating at 1300-1400 calories a day. Now I've been told that because I'm not strength training and because I'm losing so much so fast I'll end up losing muscle as well as fat. Well I definitely don't want that so I increased my calorie goal to 1500 and starting Wednesday I'll be adding strength training into my routine. My question is: is 1500 calories enough to keep me from losing more than 1 lb a week or should I increase it? I'm 5'6 also just in case you needed to know that. I work out 5x a week for 30-45 mins. I go for walks and jogs and atm I do Jillian Michaels beginner shred which does use dumbbells, but I only currently have 5 lb ones. I do plan on buying some 10 and 15 lb dumbbells and a pair of 10 and 15 lb kettlebells. My diary is open in case you need to know what I eat. My macros are 120g Carbs 140g Protein and 62g Fat. I don't typically reach those macros. I'm under for protein and carbs and sometimes over for fat.
1
Replies
-
What does MFP say to eat to lose a pound a week?1
-
I Think If You Can Continue To Lose 1lb /Week At 1500 Calories Than Do It! Why Not Lose At 1500? That's More Food, And I'm All About MORE FOOD LOL..
If You Want To Start Adding Resistance Training Which I Think Is A Great Idea, You'll Naturally Start Toning And Maintaining Muscle.. It Will Also Help Speed Up Your Weight Loss.. 1-2 lbs A Week Is The Perfect Rate For Dropping Weight And Being Able To Sustain..1 -
I lost on 1600 (not eating back exercise calories). I was 34, 5'5". I was active/exercising at least an hour a day though. Got from 213 to 133.
Try 1500, give it 5 weeks, and reassess.1 -
I lost most of my weight between 1400-1600, 41 and 5'5". Of course, my planned loss was 1/2lb per week for the last 2 months (1610-1560).
Currently I'm less than a lb from goal, eating around maintenance (1900-2200) and doing Strong Curves for strength training. Lifting will make you hungrier so make sure you're getting enough satiating foods (protein/fiber/fats). I aim for 100g minimum protein a day (but goal is approximately 130g), everything else I let happen, though I find more carbs on lifting days really helps (its only about 30-40g extra).1 -
-
Try putting your info here and see what it says, as a cross-check against MFP's recommendation:
http://www.calculator.net/calorie-calculator.html2 -
When I eat the calories given to me by MFP, weigh and log my food, exercise, and eat back some (but not all) of my exercise calories, my average weight loss over time matches the weekly weight loss goal I set.1
-
I agree with @Cchioles . More food is better, make sure your getting healthy protein and still watching the unnecessary sugars and fats.
I started doing weights 6 weeks ago and I'm loving the changes. I do low weight and med weight days (no heavy yet- recovering from nerve surgery). Free weights are my favorite. Folks in there are very helpful.
Congratulations on your loss! Sounds like you have a good handle on it.1 -
0
-
TavistockToad wrote: »
I'm all about MFP. Mine says to eat 1200/day at losing half a pound a week. While that's fine if I'm eatting back running calories, but right now I'm essentially sedentary. Some times it takes a little human tweaking.
But a a good rule- yes MFP calculated calorie intake is a good start.
0 -
Well done on your efforts. Just a side comment - if you're doing a lot of exercise against lower than needed protein intake, I would instantly try and deal with that as a priority in your food. Decent protein is central to sparing your muscles and repairing them after your exercise.
Use the calorie calculator mentioned above to get a proper daily calorie requirement figure based on your age, height and activity levels, when you have a figure for your TDEE (Total Daily Energy Expenditure) take 500 off that to create your deficit level for a pound loss a week (7x500 calories=3,500 cals / 1 pound of fat) - this is really all you need to do. (Sorry if you already know this)
Start high, don't dick about with changing calorie levels every week, the body needs time to change!1 -
-
Well done on your efforts. Just a side comment - if you're doing a lot of exercise against lower than needed protein intake, I would instantly try and deal with that as a priority in your food. Decent protein is central to sparing your muscles and repairing them after your exercise.
Use the calorie calculator mentioned above to get a proper daily calorie requirement figure based on your age, height and activity levels, when you have a figure for your TDEE (Total Daily Energy Expenditure) take 500 off that to create your deficit level for a pound loss a week (7x500 calories=3,500 cals / 1 pound of fat) - this is really all you need to do. (Sorry if you already know this)
Start high, don't dick about with changing calorie levels every week, the body needs time to change!
I'll have to check that out. I don't want to raise my deficit too much though so I don't gain or hit a plateau.0 -
I agree with @Cchioles . More food is better, make sure your getting healthy protein and still watching the unnecessary sugars and fats.
I started doing weights 6 weeks ago and I'm loving the changes. I do low weight and med weight days (no heavy yet- recovering from nerve surgery). Free weights are my favorite. Folks in there are very helpful.
Congratulations on your loss! Sounds like you have a good handle on it.
Yeah I want to start small with weights as well and gradually increase every couple of weeks or so.0 -
I lost on 1600 (not eating back exercise calories). I was 34, 5'5". I was active/exercising at least an hour a day though. Got from 213 to 133.
Try 1500, give it 5 weeks, and reassess.
I think I'll give 1500 a shot. After all I only have 57 lbs to left to lose. Once I only have 20 left I'll readjust so I'm only losing .5 lb a week.1 -
I agree with alexpn. Get that protein up. Almost everyone who has a lot of weight to lose is going to lose fat and muscle so don't get anxious and fearful about losing muscle. It's normal to do so in weight loss. Protein is the one macro you really want to hit or exceed daily, though.
Eating as much as possible while still losing weight and feeling good is winning! If MFP says you can eat 1800 to lose one pound a week, then I would say you could easily eat 1600-1700. You'll feel so much better and be much more likely to stick to it.0 -
Nightmare_Queen88 wrote: »
If plan to eat 1500 a day your deficit is still a bit aggressive for your goals if MFP gave you 1800 to loose 1 pound a week.
So are you saying no matter what you do not want to eat more than 130 gr of protein and carbs a day and up your fats to reach 1800 calories?0 -
Nightmare_Queen88 wrote: »
If plan to eat 1500 a day your deficit is still a bit aggressive for your goals if MFP gave you 1800 to loose 1 pound a week.
So are you saying no matter what you do not want to eat more than 130 gr of protein and carbs a day and up your fats to reach 1800 calories?
No I'd rather not go over 130g. I typically don't anyways even if I don't pay attention to my macros. And if 1500 is still too low then I'll reassess in a week or two.0 -
cmriverside wrote: »I agree with alexpn. Get that protein up. Almost everyone who has a lot of weight to lose is going to lose fat and muscle so don't get anxious and fearful about losing muscle. It's normal to do so in weight loss. Protein is the one macro you really want to hit or exceed daily, though.
Eating as much as possible while still losing weight and feeling good is winning! If MFP says you can eat 1800 to lose one pound a week, then I would say you could easily eat 1600-1700. You'll feel so much better and be much more likely to stick to it.
I thought we were suppose to get .8 lbs of protein per kg of our weight. For me that's under 100g. At least that's what I keep reading online.0 -
cmriverside wrote: »I agree with alexpn. Get that protein up. Almost everyone who has a lot of weight to lose is going to lose fat and muscle so don't get anxious and fearful about losing muscle. It's normal to do so in weight loss. Protein is the one macro you really want to hit or exceed daily, though.
Eating as much as possible while still losing weight and feeling good is winning! If MFP says you can eat 1800 to lose one pound a week, then I would say you could easily eat 1600-1700. You'll feel so much better and be much more likely to stick to it.
Sorry I meant .8 grams not pounds. Lol.0 -
Nightmare_Queen88 wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »I agree with alexpn. Get that protein up. Almost everyone who has a lot of weight to lose is going to lose fat and muscle so don't get anxious and fearful about losing muscle. It's normal to do so in weight loss. Protein is the one macro you really want to hit or exceed daily, though.
Eating as much as possible while still losing weight and feeling good is winning! If MFP says you can eat 1800 to lose one pound a week, then I would say you could easily eat 1600-1700. You'll feel so much better and be much more likely to stick to it.
I thought we were suppose to get .8 lbs of protein per kg of our weight. For me that's under 100g. At least that's what I keep reading online.
Oh, I thought you said you weren't keeping up with your protein - but I see that you have your protein set pretty high already.
The point being that you can eat more!! Why not try 1700-1800 (as suggested by MFP.) Obviously if you are keeping your Carbs lower, you'll have to eat more fat. Mmmmm. Fat! Really, the difference between 1600 and 1800 can be as easy as errors in logging. I log everything, I use a digital food scale, but I'm sure I forget some things and/or underestimate/overestimate. It's a "close-enough" thing. That's why I have my calories set 150 calories lower than I need to - just for that buffer.0 -
Try putting your info here and see what it says, as a cross-check against MFP's recommendation:
http://www.calculator.net/calorie-calculator.html
This is good. It puts me within 10 calories difference to MFP's recommendation.0 -
cmriverside wrote: »Nightmare_Queen88 wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »I agree with alexpn. Get that protein up. Almost everyone who has a lot of weight to lose is going to lose fat and muscle so don't get anxious and fearful about losing muscle. It's normal to do so in weight loss. Protein is the one macro you really want to hit or exceed daily, though.
Eating as much as possible while still losing weight and feeling good is winning! If MFP says you can eat 1800 to lose one pound a week, then I would say you could easily eat 1600-1700. You'll feel so much better and be much more likely to stick to it.
I thought we were suppose to get .8 lbs of protein per kg of our weight. For me that's under 100g. At least that's what I keep reading online.
Oh, I thought you said you weren't keeping up with your protein - but I see that you have your protein set pretty high already.
The point being that you can eat more!! Why not try 1700-1800 (as suggested by MFP.) Obviously if you are keeping your Carbs lower, you'll have to eat more fat. Mmmmm. Fat! Really, the difference between 1600 and 1800 can be as easy as errors in logging. I log everything, I use a digital food scale, but I'm sure I forget some things and/or underestimate/overestimate. It's a "close-enough" thing. That's why I have my calories set 150 calories lower than I need to - just for that buffer.
Yeah I use a food scale as well. I'm very ocd about that. Lol. As for fat, well I'm always over that and atm it's set at 62g.1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions