Anyone 5ft eat fewer than 1200 a day
Options
Replies
-
SwatiNigam1 wrote: »I usually eat between 800-1200 calories a day. I exercise 5 days a week. This is the range I found that helps me lose weight and get toned. Discovered only 2-3 weeks back. And started losing weight much more easily. Before that I tried all kinds of things, and it did not work. I used to be afraid of eating fewer calories, but then read Dr. Michael Mosley's work - the 2 different plans - 5:2, and 800 calories for 2 months, and I mixed everything and invented my own plan that works for me. I also tend to get in the pre-diabetic range if I am not careful, so his work was important to me. I think you will be able to figure out what works best for you.
You're exercising and eating 800 calories a day??
That is not a good plan to do anything but lose muscle and possibly lead to binging. Talk to your doctor.
OP, if you're exercising at the level you posted, you really should at least raise your calories to 1200.
Shift your priorities as middlehaitch said. This isn't just about weight loss. Hopefully, you've developed an appreciation for your fitness goals along the way to losing weight. Part of achieving overall health (and a healthy body) involves adequately fueling activity. This might mean a slower rate of weight loss, but the ultimate goal is not to just get to goal weight.
The ultimate goal is to form a balance between eating and activity and the healthy behaviors around them. Right now, you're too focused on weight loss instead of the relationship those two things have to each other and the idea of habit forming.
Just some food for thought.2 -
I want to gain muscle as I lose weight and eventually just maintain and gain muscle.0
-
nickkreitzer wrote: »That's my issue as well. I am 5'8 and only eat on average 1100 per day sometimes even less. I am looking to cut but maintain lean muscle mass and not bulk up however like you. I have also added a 3rd cardio day in for a 5x per week gym session but it is working for me. I know I need to eat more productive food but why try and fix what isn't broken right?
Sorry but I doubt you are maintaining your muscle at 1100 calories or less exercising 5x a day as a guy.
Edited to add: how is a 5 ft female eating 1000 the same issue as a 5'8 male eating 1100?6 -
nickkreitzer wrote: »That's my issue as well. I am 5'8 and only eat on average 1100 per day sometimes even less. I am looking to cut but maintain lean muscle mass and not bulk up however like you. I have also added a 3rd cardio day in for a 5x per week gym session but it is working for me. I know I need to eat more productive food but why try and fix what isn't broken right?
As a male your minimum calorie intake should be 1500...at 1100 you are lower than my minimum and I'm a 5'2 woman. Are you under a doctor's supervision?0 -
Just to clarify one point - I dont think anybody is recomending any active petite women eat only 1200 calories in total
They are recommending some sedentary petite women do (ie with no excercise calories to add on) - or such active women eat 1200 net - ie PLUS whatever exercise calories they burn.
So to the previous poster who said she was 5ft 1 and eating double that - yes, that could well be appropriate in total, if you are also very active and/or also have more to lose - but probably not for someone sedentary and with only a small amount to lose.4 -
SwatiNigam1 wrote: »I usually eat between 800-1200 calories a day. I exercise 5 days a week. This is the range I found that helps me lose weight and get toned. Discovered only 2-3 weeks back. And started losing weight much more easily. Before that I tried all kinds of things, and it did not work. I used to be afraid of eating fewer calories, but then read Dr. Michael Mosley's work - the 2 different plans - 5:2, and 800 calories for 2 months, and I mixed everything and invented my own plan that works for me. I also tend to get in the pre-diabetic range if I am not careful, so his work was important to me. I think you will be able to figure out what works best for you.nickkreitzer wrote: »That's my issue as well. I am 5'8 and only eat on average 1100 per day sometimes even less. I am looking to cut but maintain lean muscle mass and not bulk up however like you. I have also added a 3rd cardio day in for a 5x per week gym session but it is working for me. I know I need to eat more productive food but why try and fix what isn't broken right?
And it is posts like these that prompt the "shock" comments like @Aaron_K123 posted above, which was offensive to people who have a legitimate reason for eating 1200 or slightly below due to being extremely petite or sedentary... however was really directed to people like above who are drastically under eating for their height and activity level and who are likely wasting lean body mass in the process.
Best case scenario is both are underestimating how much they are actually eating due to logging inaccuracies, but that just perpetuates the false perception that they HAVE to eat that low in order to lose...
8 -
I'm under 5ft and have eaten more than 1200 cals a day for years, and that is why I need to lose weight. I've cut back to 1200 and the weight isn't shifting. I've now reduced to 1100 to see it that works. I can eat, very healthy, at 1100, my problems are that I tend to overeat at weekends, not necessarily because I'm hungry, but because I'm more likely to be less organised and therefore more easily influenced by higher calorie foods.0
-
I'm 4'11 and this is what I'm currently eating at (and my diary is public) for those of you who think 1,200 calories is "eating like a toddler". I am losing at this caloric deficit and normally I wouldn't eat this low with my TDEE factored in, however, I am doing a mock version of a bikini prep competition and trying to get my BF between 8-11%. Once I'm finished with this diet, I'll begin reverse dieting and eating back in my normal range (1,600ish) or possibly bulking (around 2,000). Just waiting to see what my goals will be after this diet.0
-
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.8K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 396 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 971 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions