Thyroid problems
Options
ladyj22
Posts: 146 Member
How do you lose weight if your thyroid is crazy?
0
Replies
-
I have hypothyroidism so I've been taking natural supplements they don't help me lose weight, but they definitely help me control my weight better, when I take them my weight is more steady inspite of what I eat. And when I'm not taking them I seem to gain weight faster and easier. There are also certain food I try to stay away from that can cause it to act up3
-
What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?0
-
-
No not yet0
-
-
Get your medical professional to assess you and provide you with the correct medication if it is your thyroid. "Natural" remedies will achieve nothing.11
-
What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much0 -
Hypothyroidism doesn't cause very much weight gain, which has been well proven by doctors. 5 to 10 pounds at most. If you have no other medical conditions, there is a very very low chance your thyroid is doing much to hinder weight loss.4
-
What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much
All of this does not necessarily apply, and I feel it's premature to suggest this before the OP has her thyroid functions under control with the proper medication.
I have hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's) and find that the things you mention - specifically gluten and cruciferous vegetables - are not an issue for me.
And taking the "Thyroid Supplements" that are available can actually be dangerous:
http://www.consumerreports.org/vitamins-supplements/never-take-thyroid-supplements/
This issue needs to be addressed with a medical doctor. It's not something to screw around with on one's own.13 -
I have hypothyroidism and I've been taking Levothyroxine. None of the things you mentioned about eating gluten free or avoiding certain vegetables was even mentioned by my doctor and I've never had an issue either. You should get checked sooner than later because unchecked you could will have a lot more complications than just gaining weight.
6 -
1. See your doctor. Get your thyroid checked and medicated if necessary.
2. Log and weigh your food.
3. Exercise - if you want.
I'm hypothyroid myself. Weight loss is really no different than it is for anyone else, aside from step # 1.7 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much
All of this does not necessarily apply, and I feel it's premature to suggest this before the OP has her thyroid functions under control with the proper medication.
I have hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's) and find that the things you mention - specifically gluten and cruciferous vegetables - are not an issue for me.
And taking the "Thyroid Supplements" that are available can actually be dangerous:
http://www.consumerreports.org/vitamins-supplements/never-take-thyroid-supplements/
This issue needs to be addressed with a medical doctor. It's not something to screw around with on one's own.
Of course everyone should consult with a doctor first before taking anything, but they should also look for alternatives if you don't want to take drugs, at least with supplements you know exactly what's inside of it. You can consult with a doctor that will give you meds that have worse side effect than what these Supplements contain which is really none at all, I looked at many options is this is the best if you want to take care of it naturally with out side effects from harmful drugs. And Everyone is different what might work for me may not work for others, but at least I can share for those who are willing to try it out.
Doctors are alway trying to steer people away from natural cures, I did a lot of research both medically and other wise so like I said this is what worked for me so I shared it.
0 -
There is a lot of misinformation here, don't let anyone tell you calories in-calories out = weight loss. When suffering from a thyroid condition, especially an autoimmune disease like Hashimoto's, your body is literally attacking itself. Your hormones are out of balance and medication can certain help balance everything out making weight loss a little easier but it is in no way the same as not having a thyroid condition. If you have Hashimoto's then getting off gluten can help normalize some symptoms. Gluten is structurally similar to your thyroid tissue so when consumed it can set off a chain reaction that makes your body go into fight mode.
I gained 75 pounds over 3 months with my first thyroid storm having not changed a thing in my life.
Make sure you research and discuss with your doctor the importance of not only T4 supplementation but possibly T3. I spent 8 years of my life on T4, fighting 100 times harder to lose 1 pound than someone without thyroid disease to just have a thyroid storm and gain 20 pounds in a month. If your body doesn't properly convert T4 to T3 then your metabolism (free T3 and total T3 levels) could very well be very low causing you to not lose weight. Once your hormones are normal you still have to focus on healthy eating and activity like anyone else. Metabolism and hormones are key to weight loss.
Once I started T3 (low doses, prescribed and not stacking for fat burn), my face puffiness went down within weeks. I've been losing weight with moderate exercise but I still need to focus on diet.
Research. Research. Research. Take all the information and find the truth for yourself. Don't allow others to get into your head. I did for years and when I finally found out my previous doctor wasn't treating me properly (he was a recommended endocrinologist by many people in my area) it was nice to know I found someone who would listen and treat my symptoms, not just my TSH.7 -
I must correct the last poster.
Gluten is not structurally similar to your thyroid tissue. Gluten only needs to be avoided by people with gluten allergies or celiac disease. A lot of unscrupulous people on the internet like to tell people with thyroid problems that they need to avoid it.
They're wrong.
When people come one here and tell you to research, research, research, they don't mean to actually read scientific papers. They want you to google alternative web sites because they're convinced that big pharma big medicine are in some huge conspiracy to deny proper treatment to thyroid patients.
It's tiring to read all of this.
A lot of the symptoms that people experience and think are thyroid related even after being treated are symptoms of carrying extra weight or other undiagnosed conditions, but those unscrupulous internet sites don't mention this.
I wasn't going to get involved in this thread because I tend to be blunt when I have a migraine, but...here I am.
I have Hashimoto's and an almost non-functioning thyroid.
I've lost 94 pounds, simply counting calories.
OP, I agree with snickerscharlie. It's still early days for you, and yes, you're going to be holding water for a little while as things stabilize. That will all calm down. It can take a couple of months to get your dose sorted, so start to think in terms of months instead of weeks to get this sorted.
Once you're sorted out, you'll be able to lose weight just like anyone else.
I promise.20 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much
All of this does not necessarily apply, and I feel it's premature to suggest this before the OP has her thyroid functions under control with the proper medication.
I have hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's) and find that the things you mention - specifically gluten and cruciferous vegetables - are not an issue for me.
And taking the "Thyroid Supplements" that are available can actually be dangerous:
http://www.consumerreports.org/vitamins-supplements/never-take-thyroid-supplements/
This issue needs to be addressed with a medical doctor. It's not something to screw around with on one's own.
Of course everyone should consult with a doctor first before taking anything, but they should also look for alternatives if you don't want to take drugs, at least with supplements you know exactly what's inside of it. You can consult with a doctor that will give you meds that have worse side effect than what these Supplements contain which is really none at all, I looked at many options is this is the best if you want to take care of it naturally with out side effects from harmful drugs. And Everyone is different what might work for me may not work for others, but at least I can share for those who are willing to try it out.
Doctors are alway trying to steer people away from natural cures, I did a lot of research both medically and other wise so like I said this is what worked for me so I shared it.
Here's where you are misinformed. There are absolutely *no* regulations regarding the content, strength, purity or efficacy of any supplements that are available that proclaim to aid (or in some cases even cure) thyroid issues, among many other ailments.
I've had Hashimoto's for 35 years. It is well managed and controlled by taking varying levels of prescribed medication depending on what stage my disease is currently in. I feel it is irresponsible to suggest foregoing proper medication in favour of unregulated and potentially dangerous supplement alternatives, regardless of how "natural" you may think they are.
tl;dr : Big Pharma is *not* evil.13 -
There is a lot of really poor information here.
I have Hashimoto's. I was diagnosed at 11. I'm now 34. I've gone through great times and I've gone through short periods of time needing major adjustments with my medication.
I'm not sure what you mean when you say that your "thyroid is crazy". I mean I'm losing weight with a TSH of 38 right now. We are working to get that down to a 2.5 at most. I'm doing the same things everyone else is doing: weighing food, counting calories, being more active. The difference is that I'm a very tired person regardless of how much sleep I get when my thyroid is being naughty. So I have to get to bed earlier to get up for that 5 am gym session. My skin has been super dry so I'm using a better moisturizer and cutting back on the soap and shampoo when I can. I've been intolerant to cold so I'm wearing layers and wearing socks to bed. Those are the changes I make. I do LCHF diet because I am also diabetic and trying to get off of meds for that if possible. It has nothing to do with gluten.
Don't let your thyroid become an excuse. CICO still works for us but sometimes the base formulas are wrong so you might have to make adjustments. You will figure this out if your weight plateaus. Play around with those calories in until you start losing again.
In the meantime PLEASE don't take anything other than prescribed medicine for a thyroid condition, especially if you have an autoimmune disease like Hashimoto's. There are things that just aren't safe. If you are getting your thyroid tested in only takes a few days for lab results to come in. Just get on medication. Many of us take it for a lifetime.
One thing I will say is that you need to be your own advocate. Many PCPs will treat your thyroid differently than an endocrinologist will.16 -
So much this^^^
Having had Hashimoto's for as long as I have, and being older and therefore knowing my own body *really* well, my doctor has given me a medication dosage range that I can adjust myself as needed. As long as I stay within the prescribed range, I can increase or decrease the amount I take depending on what my body is currently doing. I still get blood work done every 3 months to make certain I'm on the right track and am neither over or under medicating. This has worked really well for me, and my labs always come back pretty bang on.5 -
Skyblueyellow wrote: »There is a lot of really poor information here.
I have Hashimoto's. I was diagnosed at 11. I'm now 34. I've gone through great times and I've gone through short periods of time needing major adjustments with my medication.
I'm not sure what you mean when you say that your "thyroid is crazy". I mean I'm losing weight with a TSH of 38 right now. We are working to get that down to a 2.5 at most. I'm doing the same things everyone else is doing: weighing food, counting calories, being more active. The difference is that I'm a very tired person regardless of how much sleep I get when my thyroid is being naughty. So I have to get to bed earlier to get up for that 5 am gym session. My skin has been super dry so I'm using a better moisturizer and cutting back on the soap and shampoo when I can. I've been intolerant to cold so I'm wearing layers and wearing socks to bed. Those are the changes I make. I do LCHF diet because I am also diabetic and trying to get off of meds for that if possible. It has nothing to do with gluten.
Don't let your thyroid become an excuse. CICO still works for us but sometimes the base formulas are wrong so you might have to make adjustments. You will figure this out if your weight plateaus. Play around with those calories in until you start losing again.
In the meantime PLEASE don't take anything other than prescribed medicine for a thyroid condition, especially if you have an autoimmune disease like Hashimoto's. There are things that just aren't safe. If you are getting your thyroid tested in only takes a few days for lab results to come in. Just get on medication. Many of us take it for a lifetime.
One thing I will say is that you need to be your own advocate. Many PCPs will treat your thyroid differently than an endocrinologist will.
This and several other comments above. So much yes. Especially the bold here.
After losing over 60 lbs and then gaining it back plus some "because of my thyroid" (I've since learned it wasn't really my thyroid that was "the problem", it was more because I entirely quit my previous active exercise routine and started binge eating daily) I've realized that being hypo doesn't make CICO irrelevant, it may just change the equation a bit.
It can be difficult to get yourself out there to exercise, but I've found it makes me feel a lot better, even sleep better which leads to feeling a little more better the following day.
I was diagnosed about 10 years ago, I'm now 23. I've been over weight most of my life and I'm just starting to get a better grasp on my weight management. There has been some tinkering with different medications and dosages along the way, but for the most part I try to find where I feel decent and my numbers are ok. I stick with it and almost forget that I have a thyroid problem to begin with.
Eating and over eating (the reason I am overweight) is much more emotional and mental for me, now that I've realized that and stopped making excuses I've been able to manage my weight much more effectively. This is why I will always say if you are properly medicated you are really no different than anyone else when it comes to weight loss. (I've actually found that I can lose and maintain while eating quite high calories, partly because I am active.)
Now if I see a gain or not a loss when I was expecting it, I look back at my week. Many times I realize, oh yeah, I ate an entire pizza and that's probably why my week went this way. My weight usually has 99% to do with how I've been eating lately.
Weight loss is hard for many people. It's hard and it's ok to admit that. A "crazy thyroid" may add a little more difficulty at times, but weight loss and control is still entirely possible.5 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »snickerscharlie wrote: »What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much
All of this does not necessarily apply, and I feel it's premature to suggest this before the OP has her thyroid functions under control with the proper medication.
I have hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's) and find that the things you mention - specifically gluten and cruciferous vegetables - are not an issue for me.
And taking the "Thyroid Supplements" that are available can actually be dangerous:
http://www.consumerreports.org/vitamins-supplements/never-take-thyroid-supplements/
This issue needs to be addressed with a medical doctor. It's not something to screw around with on one's own.
Of course everyone should consult with a doctor first before taking anything, but they should also look for alternatives if you don't want to take drugs, at least with supplements you know exactly what's inside of it. You can consult with a doctor that will give you meds that have worse side effect than what these Supplements contain which is really none at all, I looked at many options is this is the best if you want to take care of it naturally with out side effects from harmful drugs. And Everyone is different what might work for me may not work for others, but at least I can share for those who are willing to try it out.
Doctors are alway trying to steer people away from natural cures, I did a lot of research both medically and other wise so like I said this is what worked for me so I shared it.
Here's where you are misinformed. There are absolutely *no* regulations regarding the content, strength, purity or efficacy of any supplements that are available that proclaim to aid (or in some cases even cure) thyroid issues, among many other ailments.
I've had Hashimoto's for 35 years. It is well managed and controlled by taking varying levels of prescribed medication depending on what stage my disease is currently in. I feel it is irresponsible to suggest foregoing proper medication in favour of unregulated and potentially dangerous supplement alternatives, regardless of how "natural" you may think they are.
tl;dr : Big Pharma is *not* evil.
Like I said everyone is different and different things work for different people, I'm not old enough to have had to deal with this for that many years, but the years that I've have this has worked for me better than any prescription has ever. I think it's better to let someone know about these alternative because they could be like me, and has tried many things but can't find what works for them.
There's no reason to be condescending, everyone is entiled to there opinion, and I'm just sharing my experience just like everyone else, I'm not talking out of my butt or making things up out of thin air, these are thing I actually took time to educate myself about through tons of reseach, questions and evidence.
and there are just certain drugs I don't take especially if they have too many side effects, it will just make your condition worse than what it already is.0 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »snickerscharlie wrote: »What supplements do you take? What kind of food should be avoided?
The supplement I take is 1 Body Thyriod support supplement you can get it off amazon for about $25, they also sell it at Vitamin Shoppes if I'm not mistaking
The main food I stay away from is gluten, because it's more difficult for people with Hyothriodism to break down food that contain gluten, you don't have to give it up completely just minimize your intake. I kind a gave it up completely because that's what works for me.
Also some veggies, particually cruciferous vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, and kale because it interferes with thyriod production especially if you have an iodine deficiency. These are some of my fave veggies I still eat them just not as much
All of this does not necessarily apply, and I feel it's premature to suggest this before the OP has her thyroid functions under control with the proper medication.
I have hypothyroidism (Hashimoto's) and find that the things you mention - specifically gluten and cruciferous vegetables - are not an issue for me.
And taking the "Thyroid Supplements" that are available can actually be dangerous:
http://www.consumerreports.org/vitamins-supplements/never-take-thyroid-supplements/
This issue needs to be addressed with a medical doctor. It's not something to screw around with on one's own.
Of course everyone should consult with a doctor first before taking anything, but they should also look for alternatives if you don't want to take drugs, at least with supplements you know exactly what's inside of it. You can consult with a doctor that will give you meds that have worse side effect than what these Supplements contain which is really none at all, I looked at many options is this is the best if you want to take care of it naturally with out side effects from harmful drugs. And Everyone is different what might work for me may not work for others, but at least I can share for those who are willing to try it out.
Doctors are alway trying to steer people away from natural cures, I did a lot of research both medically and other wise so like I said this is what worked for me so I shared it.
Here's where you are misinformed. There are absolutely *no* regulations regarding the content, strength, purity or efficacy of any supplements that are available that proclaim to aid (or in some cases even cure) thyroid issues, among many other ailments.
I've had Hashimoto's for 35 years. It is well managed and controlled by taking varying levels of prescribed medication depending on what stage my disease is currently in. I feel it is irresponsible to suggest foregoing proper medication in favour of unregulated and potentially dangerous supplement alternatives, regardless of how "natural" you may think they are.
tl;dr : Big Pharma is *not* evil.
Like I said everyone is different and different things work for different people, I'm not old enough to have had to deal with this for that many years, but the years that I've have this has worked for me better than any prescription has ever. I think it's better to let someone know about these alternative because they could be like me, and has tried many things but can't find what works for them.
There's no reason to be condescending, everyone is entiled to there opinion, and I'm just sharing my experience just like everyone else, I'm not talking out of my butt or making things up out of thin air, these are thing I actually took time to educate myself about through tons of reseach, questions and evidence.
and there are just certain drugs I don't take especially if they have too many side effects, it will just make your condition worse than what it already is.
I fail to see where I was condescending.
But I will stand by it being inappropriate to even mention supplements to a person who hasn't had her thyroid issues (if they exist) addressed by her physician as yet. At this point, were she to follow your advice and look into supplements, it could have some potentially dangerous consequences for her.
I honestly feel that your education in this area may be incomplete or perhaps just one-sided. Please put forward your "tons of research and evidence" if you are certain your idea has merit, because the legitimate medical community strongly disagrees with you.16
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 391 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 924 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions