We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Gaining weight during recomp

jamieparadis20
Posts: 129 Member
Hi guys,
I started a recomp after realizing I was skinny fat and so far I think it's going pretty good. However, since I had the completely wrong mindset for weight loss previously, the scale going up really scares me. I know the most obvious reason is that muscle weighs more than fat, but I can't help worrying that I'm Or strength training hard enough and the extra calories I'm eating are turning into fat.
Any advice?
I started a recomp after realizing I was skinny fat and so far I think it's going pretty good. However, since I had the completely wrong mindset for weight loss previously, the scale going up really scares me. I know the most obvious reason is that muscle weighs more than fat, but I can't help worrying that I'm Or strength training hard enough and the extra calories I'm eating are turning into fat.
Any advice?
0
Replies
-
Keep in mind that strength training also tends to retain excess water in your muscles which is normal. Keep your hydration up and monitor your sodium intake if you're feeling bloated often. Also, you hint that you're eating above your needed calories presumably to gain muscle. How many calories are you aiming for? Generally people go for 100-200 above their maintenance so weight gain should be fairly slow1
-
Keep in mind that strength training also tends to retain excess water in your muscles which is normal. Keep your hydration up and monitor your sodium intake if you're feeling bloated often. Also, you hint that you're eating above your needed calories presumably to gain muscle. How many calories are you aiming for? Generally people go for 100-200 above their maintenance so weight gain should be fairly slow
I'm eating below maintenance on days I don't strength train and at maintaince on days I do. For me that's 1400 and 1600. Should I be eating above maintenance? It feels like a lot of food already honestly because I'm not used to eating that much.0 -
My maintenance is 2100. 1500 seems really low for maintenance since women need a minimum of 1200 just to survive and function without exercise.
Do you have a slow metabolism? Have you a history of dieting?
Sounds like you need to rev up the metabolism again honestly.0 -
jamieparadis20 wrote: »Hi guys,
I started a recomp after realizing I was skinny fat and so far I think it's going pretty good. However, since I had the completely wrong mindset for weight loss previously, the scale going up really scares me. I know the most obvious reason is that muscle weighs more than fat, but I can't help worrying that I'm Or strength training hard enough and the extra calories I'm eating are turning into fat.
Any advice?
If you're total weight is trending up consistently, then that's not a recomposition. The point to maintain a target weight as you build muscle and lose fat. One thing that's hard is to differentiate a trend from fluctuations since you are supposed to be eating at maintenance.0 -
Your post is a bit confusing!
Muscle doesn't weigh more than fat. A pound is a pound is a pound. That it's more dense is an irrelevance as regards your weight increase.
Why does the scale going up scare you? Over what timescales are you talking? How much?
Remember you need to think long term and not react to short term fluctuations.
Recomposition is generally meaning maintaining your weight.
Is the "Or" supposed to be "not" in this sentence?but I can't help worrying that I'm Or strength training hard enough and the extra calories I'm eating are turning into fat.0 -
Your post is a bit confusing!
Muscle doesn't weigh more than fat. A pound is a pound is a pound. That it's more dense is an irrelevance as regards your weight increase.
Why does the scale going up scare you? Over what timescales are you talking? How much?
Remember you need to think long term and not react to short term fluctuations.
Recomposition is generally meaning maintaining your weight.
Is the "Or" supposed to be "not" in this sentence?but I can't help worrying that I'm Or strength training hard enough and the extra calories I'm eating are turning into fat.
Sorry for the confusion, I wrote that right before bed.
I realize it may be fluctuations because my weight went down a little today. I think I'll see how much it's gone up in about a week.
Is 1500 really small? Sometimes I feel super over full at the end of the day and it almost feels like too much.
Yes, it's supposed to be not instead of or.0 -
My maintenance is 2100. 1500 seems really low for maintenance since women need a minimum of 1200 just to survive and function without exercise.
Do you have a slow metabolism? Have you a history of dieting?
Sounds like you need to rev up the metabolism again honestly.
^^again, I didn't realize 1500 was that low! I followed an online calculator and rounded down like it said to for women. I sometimes feel super full after 1600! At the same time, today I ate this amount and I'm still kind of hungry.
I'm not sure about my metabolism because I don't know how to measure that. I'm guessing it's on the slower side because I gained weight easily before I started my fitness journey. How would I "rev up" my metabolism?0 -
jamieparadis20 wrote: »My maintenance is 2100. 1500 seems really low for maintenance since women need a minimum of 1200 just to survive and function without exercise.
Do you have a slow metabolism? Have you a history of dieting?
Sounds like you need to rev up the metabolism again honestly.
^^again, I didn't realize 1500 was that low! I followed an online calculator and rounded down like it said to for women. I sometimes feel super full after 1600! At the same time, today I ate this amount and I'm still kind of hungry.
I'm not sure about my metabolism because I don't know how to measure that. I'm guessing it's on the slower side because I gained weight easily before I started my fitness journey. How would I "rev up" my metabolism?
You need to start thinking not in terms of individual weeks, but in terms of say 4 week stretches. Re-comp is a long, slow process. If you are doing it right, while there will be weight fluctuation due to various factors that primarily affect water weight, weight will stay long term 4 weeks, 8 weeks, about the same. What will change, if you are doing it correctly, is measurements, so get out a measuring tape to get your starting measurements, and your camera to take pictures so that in a couple of months you have something to compare to.
In terms of calories, at 19, unless you are very tiny, you likely would need more. However, if after 3-4 weeks your weight is stable, it is likely you are eating an appropriate amount, although it is likely in that case you are eating more than you think you are.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.5K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.5K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions