malibu927 wrote: » Unless you have a medical reason, macros are a personal preference. You can eat 100% carbs and lose weight as long as you're in a calorie deficit.
ksmommy5 wrote: » malibu927 wrote: » Unless you have a medical reason, macros are a personal preference. You can eat 100% carbs and lose weight as long as you're in a calorie deficit. So my macros don't matter? As long as I eat the 1500 cals mfp tells me to I'm good? I worry I'd get 3 weeks in calories counting and sabotaged myself by not eating these macros properly.
ISO905 wrote: » ksmommy5 wrote: » malibu927 wrote: » Unless you have a medical reason, macros are a personal preference. You can eat 100% carbs and lose weight as long as you're in a calorie deficit. So my macros don't matter? As long as I eat the 1500 cals mfp tells me to I'm good? I worry I'd get 3 weeks in calories counting and sabotaged myself by not eating these macros properly. Ya...your macros do matter. I suspect your true goal is just not weight loss. If we were to talk about your goals I would guess that your goal is really to have HEALTHY weight loss to a sustainable body weight and be metabolically healthy (good blood pressure, cholesterol, no vitamin or mineral deficiencies etc.) I have yet to meet anyone whose only goal was: "I want to loose weight...I want to get down to 120 pounds but I want to be unhealthy with poor cholesterol levels, poor vitamin profile and have no energy...the ONLY thing I'm interested in is weight loss" If THAT is your only goal then yes, only calories matter. otherwise...they kinda matter
Jazzymamma1 wrote: » I'm not expert by any means, but my PT has been coaching me in nutrition too and has had me tracking Macros for the last several months. My basic understanding is that while yes, you can lose weight eating whatever the heck you want- like nothing by candy bars, as long as you don't go over your daily caloric goal, HOWEVER, common sense will tell you that will eventually make you sick and probably rot your teeth out. So tracking Macos help you to balance what and how much you eat. With my current Macros, my Protein and Carb intake are almost equal. It also depends on what your goal is- as was mentioned in a previous reply. Also on your activity level and intensity. I strength train 4-5 days a week lifting heavy weights. I do little to no cardio. So with that in mind my Trainer allotted me equal portions of Protein and Carbs. Carbs are easily digested and what your body taps into first for energy during physical exertion. Excess carbs that aren't used are then broken down into sugar and then stored as fat. Protein is what aids you body in recovery and helps repair/rebuild muscle the tiny fibers that are broken down during exercise. But girl, just stick with the Macros that MFP calculated for you as a starting point for at least 6-8 weeks. Trust me, you will see results. Fitness and Nutrition is a Constantly Evolving beast. As you progress, your goals are likely to change. You can do this!!!
ksmommy5 wrote: » So I'm 5'5" and 245 lbs. Set to lose 1.5 lbs a week. My macros are 50/30/20. For a fat person I find it odd that I need 50% carbs? Is this right??