Women: how much do you eat NET to maintain
Replies
-
annaskiski wrote: »I'm guessing everyone not specifically stating that this is their non-exercise # is offering their TDEE number....
Can't speak for anyone else - but I did not specifically state this and when I answered 1710 that is my net number as per MFP's calculations.
Not my TDEE.
0 -
Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.4 -
I am doing a crappy job at maintaining, partly due to ambitious fitness goals that ramp up my appetite.
5'11, maintaining 154 eating NET between 1400-1600.
Consuming around 2600 TOTAL a day (TDEE according to fitbit is 2750ish to 2800).1 -
Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.
Ditto and I'm terrified of getting sick or taking a rest day. I just can't do 1500 calories! On a lazier day I end up around 2400.
I do agree that a lot of people here seem to be confused between TDEE and net calories (which is TDEE without exercise).2 -
Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.
Ditto and I'm terrified of getting sick or taking a rest day. I just can't do 1500 calories! On a lazier day I end up around 2400.
I do agree that a lot of people here seem to be confused between TDEE and net calories (which is TDEE without exercise).
Since I seem to be one of the "confused" people, my net calories are my BMR which is around 1200.0 -
Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.
Ditto and I'm terrified of getting sick or taking a rest day. I just can't do 1500 calories! On a lazier day I end up around 2400.
I do agree that a lot of people here seem to be confused between TDEE and net calories (which is TDEE without exercise).
Since I seem to be one of the "confused" people, my net calories are my BMR which is around 1200.
Well, net is not BMR either, but nevermind.....2 -
annaskiski wrote: »Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.
Ditto and I'm terrified of getting sick or taking a rest day. I just can't do 1500 calories! On a lazier day I end up around 2400.
I do agree that a lot of people here seem to be confused between TDEE and net calories (which is TDEE without exercise).
Since I seem to be one of the "confused" people, my net calories are my BMR which is around 1200.
Well, net is not BMR either, but nevermind.....
Dude, really? You're going to pick it apart now? I know the difference between net and BMR. Okay, here you go.
TDEE 1940
BMR (according to MFP) 1194
Exercise calories (using ShapeSense calulator) 895
NET CALORIES 1045
OMG 155 OFF MY GUESS OF 1200. I SHOULD BURN FOR BEING SO WRONG.4 -
annaskiski wrote: »Sadly, netting 1500 cal seems to be it.
Happily, I do a whole lot of exercise so I rarely have to eat that low.
Ditto and I'm terrified of getting sick or taking a rest day. I just can't do 1500 calories! On a lazier day I end up around 2400.
I do agree that a lot of people here seem to be confused between TDEE and net calories (which is TDEE without exercise).
Since I seem to be one of the "confused" people, my net calories are my BMR which is around 1200.
Well, net is not BMR either, but nevermind.....
Dude, really? You're going to pick it apart now? I know the difference between net and BMR. Okay, here you go.
TDEE 1940
BMR (according to MFP) 1194
Exercise calories (using ShapeSense calulator) 895
NET CALORIES 1045
OMG 155 OFF MY GUESS OF 1200. I SHOULD BURN FOR BEING SO WRONG.
Lol.
I'm guessing you're not burning as much as you think in exercise... because if your net calories were lower than your BMR, you'd still be losing weight (because science).
Although I'm a bit confused about what's considered NET calories. I mean, my EXERCISE calories (like, me going to the gym or purposely going for a walk) are maybe 400-700 calories a day, but I try to stay active otherwise too and sometimes burn another 400 from random 5 to 15 minutes walking during the day... would that count as exercise or not? Because some days I don't purposely go to the gym but still burn 2200 calories with my main activity being just walking in my backyard while watching my puppy, for example (14k steps). BMR is around 1350 and if I don't move much all day (maybe 3000 steps), my TDEE will be 1500 on a good day.
0 -
Net for me IS TDEE because I don't do cardio. My strength training falls into my lightly active lifestyle.3
-
I maintain at 2200-2400 calories total (I don't add/subtract exercise). I do CrossFit 3-4 times/week, bike 3-4 hours/week, run 1-2x week. I'm 5'7" and around 150 lb. I've increased my lean mass over the past two years by about 10 lb with lifting and CrossFit.
I'm similar...eat about 2200 cals/day to maintain. I run, do Crossfit, and practice yoga.
ETA I'm 5'6" and 125 lbs1 -
ocrXfitter wrote: »I maintain at 2200-2400 calories total (I don't add/subtract exercise). I do CrossFit 3-4 times/week, bike 3-4 hours/week, run 1-2x week. I'm 5'7" and around 150 lb. I've increased my lean mass over the past two years by about 10 lb with lifting and CrossFit.
I'm similar...eat about 2200 cals/day to maintain. I run, do Crossfit, and practice yoga.
ETA I'm 5'6" and 125 lbs
Sounds like fun! And obstacle races?
0 -
ocrXfitter wrote: »I maintain at 2200-2400 calories total (I don't add/subtract exercise). I do CrossFit 3-4 times/week, bike 3-4 hours/week, run 1-2x week. I'm 5'7" and around 150 lb. I've increased my lean mass over the past two years by about 10 lb with lifting and CrossFit.
I'm similar...eat about 2200 cals/day to maintain. I run, do Crossfit, and practice yoga.
ETA I'm 5'6" and 125 lbs
Sounds like fun! And obstacle races?
Definitely OCRs. First one of the year for me is in three weeks!1 -
My maintenance number is 1,970. I am doing a lot of cardio, so goal calories is usually around 2,600 with the exercise adjustment. At the time I am only eating about 100 of my workout calories back (or a little over 2,000 calories), which is still resulting in a slight weight loss. I have been adding calories back slowly in maintenance.1
-
At the moment I'm trying to figure out what my maintenance calories are.
MFP had them set to 1530 but I keep dropping weight so I've pumped it up to 1680. I'll try that for about a month and see how it goes.
I'm in the same boat........MFP has mine set to 1490 and still loosing. Maybe I will take your advice and up mine to see if that helps.Thanks:)0 -
In reality, my TDEE is 1940.
According to MFP it's 1650.. it most certainly is not.
It depends on which weight I'm maintaining though. Right now I'm healthy, but I used to maintain on 1600-1800 when I was 96-100lbs. MFP would calculate that at just around my BMR at that weight (1250) so that would mean I was burning like 50 calories a day. Surrrre1 -
TimothyFish wrote: »gebeziseva wrote: »TimothyFish wrote: »gebeziseva wrote: »TimothyFish wrote: »0
Did you have anything in mind when you wrote this?
Sure, the definition of "net" is that you take what you eat and subtract your TDEE. To maintain weight that number can only be zero.
In MFP diary 'net = eaten - intentional exercise'.
Thanks for your input.
So, if you are asking about MFP Net instead of net calories, what you really want to know is NEAT.
NET calories is not zero at all. You are very wrong....
Via MFP "We set your nutritional target in Net Calories which we define as:
Calories Consumed (Food) - Calories Burned (Exercise) = Net Calories
This means that if you exercise, you will be able to eat more for that day. For example, if your Net Calorie goal is 2000 calories, one way to meet that goal is to eat 2,500 calories of food, but then burn 500 calories through exercise."
Like net income is income minus taxes etc NET calorie intake is considered calories eaten minus excess exercise. It can't be an intake if it's 0. You eventually spend all your money too but your NET income isn't considered 0.1 -
45. 5'5". 135-137#. My "MFP net" is 2150. I work out hard - climb twice a week, long hilly mountain bike rides, run either intervals or 6 miles steady, lift twice a week. So - I usually end up eating 2400-2700/d.
I'm still losing about 1/2# a month so just bumped up my calories. Again (which is awesome!)3 -
When you say "NET" you mean how much do you eat after exercise is taken into account?
For myself, I am maintaining at 2000cal a day, and I usually do Crossfit which burns around 300-400 cal ... so maybe that means net is 1600-1700?
Anyway, I eat quite a bit!1 -
I'm 5'10". I net 1200 now but eat 1350-1400. I walk a lot, no other exercise. I used to net 1400 for the first four years or so of maintenance, but my weight slowly crept up in the last 18 months, so I had to drop to keep maintaining. I'm in my late 50's though, and your calorie needs do change. I'm still not hungry so it must be enough.0
-
gebeziseva wrote: »Thanks everyone! This has been very insightful.
Note that many folks have given you their height, and some have even provided their age, and activity levels. All are important variables.3 -
In theory, it's about 2300. I'm 5'10 and 148.4
But I tend to eat to what I'm maintaining that day, i.e. 1850 when I'm basically a dead fish and don't do anything apart from getting up to get food but if I'm training two hours that day (kickboxing) I need at least 3100. But it's not an exact science as I'm still losing and I'm working in free weights as well so it's more of a guide.0 -
I'm 5ft2 and do Olympic lifting, strength training plus a tiny bit of cardio too. My calories vary day to do but never more than around 1200-1300.0
-
5'3", 45 years old, 130 lbs. I eat about 1500-1600 to maintain, but on really active days it can be up to 2300.1
-
I'm at 1900-2000 to maintain. 115 lbs and 5'7"0
-
Net about 1700 for me to maintain. 5'9" and 160-ish.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions