1200 per day
perkymommy
Posts: 1,642 Member
I've been at this weight loss thing over and over so I know what to do and my biggest problem is staying on plan. I was at goal for many years and was always thin growing up and as a young adult. My "biggest" years (other than when pregnant) have been the last seven years and going back and forth with losing weight.
Does anyone else lose slowly even at 1200 per day? On days I walk or work out I don't eat back those calories either. The weight comes off slow. I got to goal last year and stayed there for most of the year but gained it all back very quickly this past winter. Now it seems the weight doesn't want to come off at all or I'm having a hard time jump starting my weight loss and that just makes me want to be content where I am and give up.
Does anyone else lose slowly even at 1200 per day? On days I walk or work out I don't eat back those calories either. The weight comes off slow. I got to goal last year and stayed there for most of the year but gained it all back very quickly this past winter. Now it seems the weight doesn't want to come off at all or I'm having a hard time jump starting my weight loss and that just makes me want to be content where I am and give up.
0
Replies
-
what are your stats?1
-
3
-
I have had the same damn experience. Couldn't lose even though I was eating 1200, and exercising. From what I understand about the latest research I'v done, and I'm just as much making shots in the dark as you, creating a calorie deficit is inaccurate information. It has something to do with burning glucose as opposed to burning fat. Also, your body will burn the fuel you put in, so if you decrease your calories, you decrease your energy output. I have had a blood sugar reading that was pre diabetic, so I started doing research on insulin and I found some information on fasting that clicked for me. Apparently, your body will burn fat in a fasting state. Have you heard of intermittent fasting? There are many misconceptions about fasting that I read about in Dr. Jung's book. It's worth a peek if you're doing research. Not sure what others will say about this but I'm convinced enough to give it a try.43
-
gomissfitnes wrote: »I have had the same damn experience. Couldn't lose even though I was eating 1200, and exercising. From what I understand about the latest research I'v done, and I'm just as much making shots in the dark as you, creating a calorie deficit is inaccurate information. It has something to do with burning glucose as opposed to burning fat. Also, your body will burn the fuel you put in, so if you decrease your calories, you decrease your energy output. I have had a blood sugar reading that was pre diabetic, so I started doing research on insulin and I found some information on fasting that clicked for me. Apparently, your body will burn fat in a fasting state. Have you heard of intermittent fasting? There are many misconceptions about fasting that I read about in Dr. Jung's book. It's worth a peek if you're doing research. Not sure what others will say about this but I'm convinced enough to give it a try.
there's so much no in this post....22 -
I am in the same boat as you, OP. I feel like I'm spinning my wheels. I'm 5'3 and 125 pounds, lifting weights 4x per week and attending a one hour cardio/body pump class 1x per week. I just want to get down to 115!
I haven't been weighing my coffee creamer or the 1 tbs of peanut butter I put in my oatmeal every day, but I don't eat back exercise calories so I feel like I should have a little bit of wiggle room.0 -
I started at 190, 5'2". 1200 cals per week. I am now down to 171.
As someone else asked, what are your stats?1 -
Boo! I'm so confused. What works??? The never ending question. I'll keep trying.0
-
gomissfitnes wrote: »Boo! I'm so confused. What works??? The never ending question. I'll keep trying.
a calorie deficit... it really is as simple as that...12 -
I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?6
-
I'm 5'3 got to 195lbs. 1200 calories a day with excerisee 3/4 times a week and I'm down to 147lbs in 5 and a half months. It works, you may need to tighten up your logging as you may be eating more than you think. When I got a food scale I was very surprised haha. As a few people have mentioned, what are your stats?
7 -
5ft 2" and in 55 days I'm down 13lbs I burn more than I eat and I'm on 1200 calories per day. I exercise for about 30 mins per day on my Elliptical trainer and walk quite a lot. Seems simple but it's working for me 2
-
Maybe your metabolic rate is naturally low. Mine is and I lose slowly but steadily even being overweight to start with. Try looking for other measures of success as well - how do your clothes feel, can you lift heavier, run further or faster? If you are exercising you will be building muscle which weighs heavier. We obsess so much about being 'good' or 'bad', 'on' or 'off' healthy eating, don't think about 'giving up', if you are eating healthily and exercising you are doing your body good. And try to relax about the number on the scales as stress can interfere with weight loss. You don't say how much you want to lose in total or weekly, but it can be unrealistic to lose high if you are not overweight to begin with as creating that deficit needed is not possible. Even a 0.5lb is a loss will build up over time. I know what you mean about w
anting to jump your weight loss and maybe want a 3, 4, 5, 6 lb etc loss in the first week, but a month will pass anyway and each loss adds up3 -
I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?
I eat 1200 to lose. But if I work out, I eat more. Just up your intake on the days you work out.1 -
MFP set my calories at 1200, but I eat back my exercise calories. My weight has fluctuated (which is normal) but over the past 7 weeks I have lost at a rate of just half a pound a week. That's slow but steady, so I take that as a win. Don't give up!2
-
At 5'4", 118 lbs (30 year old female), if I don't work out my maintenance calories are only about 1600/day, so if I were to try to lose on 1200 it would be slow, less than a pound per week.
When you're female, shorter, lighter (or older), your body just doesn't burn as much in a day and so loss can be slower, but it's still not a good idea to cut your calories much further because it's very, very difficult to get the nutrition you need (both macro- and micro-nutrients) on fewer.
The best remedy for this IMO is increasing exercise. If I throw in even a 5K run or a fitness class or my 45 bike commute and focus on walking more, I can bump my TDEE up to 2000 at least without a massive effort, and that means I can either lose faster or eat more than 1200 and still lose.
The other option is, of course, to understand that my body just doesn't burn as much as larger/more active people and to be happy with a half pound a week.
I've been in maintenance for several years, but after periods of overindulgence, I've had to cut a few times and this is always the way it is for me. It can get very frustrating if you don't adjust your expectations a bit.3 -
I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?
What calculator gives you a goal of 1,200 to maintain? I'm 5'4, 108, and my sedentary calorie goal is 1,460.1 -
1
-
An average of 1400 calories is about as low as I can get before I'm ready to snap, but even there, I lose slowly. But here's the kicker...slow weight loss is exactly what my stats predict will happen. I'm 5'4", about 118 pounds and am fairly inactive outside of dedicated exercise time, so I just can't create a big enough calorie deficit to lose more than 0.5 pound per week. It's not a surprise and it's not disappointing; it's just what the math says is going to happen.
With that said, if your stats predict that you should be losing more quickly, it's time to look at how you're calculating your intake. Are you measuring using a food scale, measuring cups/spoons, or eyeballing? Are you actually averaging 1200 calories per day, or are there days where you're eating more and throwing off your weekly average? Are you eating back your exercise calories, and if so, how are you calculating those totals?4 -
gomissfitnes wrote: »Boo! I'm so confused. What works??? The never ending question. I'll keep trying.
Eating fewer calories than your body burns in a day is what works.....period.
Now, some people are close to goal and will lose slowly. When close to goal, you can't create a huge deficit in a healthy manner. Your body always needs a certain amount of fuel (heart, lungs, kidneys, etc).
For 2 pounds a week you would need a 1,000 calorie deficit everyday, for 1 pound it's a 500 calorie deficit. Google your TDEE (total daily energy expenditure)......this is maintenance for you.
http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/3 -
I'm 5ft6 - started at 132lbs and I'm now 118lbs (4 months in).
I started on 1,200 calories and about a month ago (or maybe 2, I can't remember!) I upped it to 1,300. Everyone is different and I can't say why, but I've actually found that I've lost weight more steadily since I've upped it!
I found eating 1,200 was fine but do make sure you're choosing highly nutritional foods, as lower calorie goals can limit your much needed nutrition intake.
Also, make sure your considering your calories as 'NET'. If your goal is 1,200 and you burn 500 calories with exercise, please ensure you're eating some of these back. Eating under 1,000 calories NET is really bad for you, and you should aim to closer to 1,200.
Obviously, account for water retention/water weight and fluctuations too - these are natural.
Good luck!
P.S. Happy to connect with anyone for motivation/food ideas - my diary is open so you can see what I eat etc. for low calorie days, if it helps!2 -
I'm 5'3 and 128lb, I eat 1200ish and it is comparatively slow progress to someone with lots of weight to lose. My sedentary TDEE is around 1800 rather than the 2000 average - and seeing as food packaging can be up to 20% out on calorie information I'm happy with the 5 lb I've lost in a month and a bit.0
-
I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?
Where did you read that?! At 5'3 when I was 118lb I maintained at 1800! 1200 might be your maintenance if you're bed-bound...1 -
Slow is better than no! I have lost 36.5 at 1200 a day. It feels slow to me but it didn't pack on overnight and it isn't going to leave quickly. I am changing habits.0
-
I'm curious as to what everyone is calling slow.1
-
It's a misconception that eating the lowest possible "safe" amount of calories... aka 1200 calories... is the way to go for everyone across the board. I am now a WLS post-op patient and even *my* calorie intake goal is not down at 1200 calories.
Prior to surgery, I saw the most success when I took the time to learn about what exactly my body was burning, and adjusting my eating habits to match. Not talking about taking the Scooby calculator and letting it guess for me, or using MFP calculations of calories for exercise and food stuffs... I'm talking about investing in tech that used biometrics other than heart rate to measure my actual heat expenditure throughout the day.
When I did this, I learned a LOT about how inaccurate calculators based on averages can be... and I decided to eat for what I was doing in *my* body rather than what the averages dictated. I went from a crawl to dropping a lot of weight, fast. I was eating 4k+ calories a day on a regular basis and losing at a rate 2x+ quicker than what any calculator had tried to tell me I could do.
Of course, I was a huge fatty and had a lot to lose... but my point is, taking the time to learn about your body, what it needs, talking to your doctor and making some investments is what leads to success.
I lost 115lbs on my own using this tactic before I hit an epic stall... and I did surgery because I had a lot more to lose and it was going so slowly by that point that I needed professional help, and the only way I could afford it was with insurance, and my insurance only covered it if surgery was involved XD I don't regret it one bit... But now that I'm post-op, my calorie goal is set around 1300 per day alongside a fair amount of vitamin supplementation, and my weight loss is at a "crawl" compared to bariatric patients. Super low calorie diets are not always the answer all the time.
All this being said, if you are close to goal weight, you're not going to lose in a crazy way and your lbs lost is going to be in the decimal points, not in the whole numbers. That's just how it is.0 -
janejellyroll wrote: »I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?
What calculator gives you a goal of 1,200 to maintain? I'm 5'4, 108, and my sedentary calorie goal is 1,460.
Just as an FYI, MFP gives me 1200 as sedentary maintenance.
5'1 100-105lbs, 63yo.
Most on line calculators give me that ~50 cals either way.
My BMR is usually estimated at 950-1000.
I actually eat closer to 1600 most days, estimated as I rarely log.
OP
My weight loss was from 130-105 (estimate as a scale change changed numbers 1/3 of the way along) on an appropriate 1200 over a year with 175-200 cals eaten per hr of exercise.
Precise logging, and working with collected data to refine the calorie out side of the equation, was needed to get the last 10 lbs off.
Try to find a way to be consistent that will carry you through into maintenance. This usually includes using an appropriate deficit, eating foods you like, while meeting basic nutritional goals, and timing your eating habits so they fit your lifestyle and satiety levels.
Keep yoyoing means you lose fat and muscle while dieting. When gaining you gain only fat ( unless you are lifting).
Eventually you will get back up to the original start weight but have more fat than when you started yoyoing at the same weight. This will lead to your BMR being slightly lower and it getting harder and harder to lose the same lbs.
Cheers, h.1 -
middlehaitch wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »I personally think 1200 is too low. No matter what the experts say about eating at deficit, it actually will leave me hungry and tired to get a good workout. I'm 5'4", CW 116lbs, and I'm supposed to eat 1200 or so at maintenance?.. but I eat 1600-1700. I feel way more satisfied! Have you read about increasing calories to lose weight/burn fat?
What calculator gives you a goal of 1,200 to maintain? I'm 5'4, 108, and my sedentary calorie goal is 1,460.
Just as an FYI, MFP gives me 1200 as sedentary maintenance.
5'1 100-105lbs, 63yo.
Most on line calculators give me that ~50 cals either way.
My BMR is usually estimated at 950-1000.
I actually eat closer to 1600 most days, estimated as I rarely log.
OP
My weight loss was from 130-105 (estimate as a scale change changed numbers 1/3 of the way along) on an appropriate 1200 over a year with 175-200 cals eaten per hr of exercise.
Precise logging, and working with collected data to refine the calorie out side of the equation, was needed to get the last 10 lbs off.
Try to find a way to be consistent that will carry you through into maintenance. This usually includes using an appropriate deficit, eating foods you like, while meeting basic nutritional goals, and timing your eating habits so they fit your lifestyle and satiety levels.
Keep yoyoing means you lose fat and muscle while dieting. When gaining you gain only fat ( unless you are lifting).
Eventually you will get back up to the original start weight but have more fat than when you started yoyoing at the same weight. This will lead to your BMR being slightly lower and it getting harder and harder to lose the same lbs.
Cheers, h.
Thanks for the context.2 -
I lose two pounds every week, I weigh my food. If you aren't losing it's probably because your miscounting how many calories your consuming. I highly suggest weighing food until you get an idea of serving size, not all foods on here are accurate. I would check carbs, if that's all your filling up on your body will retain more water. Cut back on your carbs.1
-
Iheartrunning36 wrote: »I lose two pounds every week, I weigh my food. If you aren't losing it's probably because your miscounting how many calories your consuming. I highly suggest weighing food until you get an idea of serving size, not all foods on here are accurate. I would check carbs, if that's all your filling up on your body will retain more water. Cut back on your carbs.
This^^^
Weighing food changed EVERYTHING about my diet.. and helped it so much more. I didn't realize how cheap food scales are either. I went to walmart and bought one for $15. Then I found one on Amazon for $10 and loved it more than the $15 Walmart one! So now I keep one at work and one at home!
3 -
I just don't understand the point of logging food if the person doesn't actually know for sure how much they're eating. Weighing/measuring seems quite necessary 'to me' because I certainly wouldn't know 1 oz of cheese at a glance - no way.5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions