1 Gallon of Water a Day?

2»

Replies

  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,992 Member
    noirelb wrote: »
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    Any science behind this theory of yours that drinking cold water = measurably increased caloric burn? I'd be interested in reading that, even though the original statement was that drinking water boosts metabolism, which it doesn't.
    He's not incorrect about drinking colder water versus tepid water for more calorie burn. But it's negligible overall in weight loss. Drinking 8 ICE COLD 8 ounce glasses of water a day is about 70 calories burned. The science is there. But it's not boosting metabolic rate.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png



    Yes but 1 grain of rice is about 100 calories - 0.1 Calories (Kilocalories) ... So it unfortunately doesn't make a difference in your actual weight loss.
    Mathematically it does IF they don't eat that extra grain of rice.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png

  • snickerscharlie
    snickerscharlie Posts: 8,578 Member
    edited July 2017
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.
    In the literal sense yes, you do burn more calories with an ice cold glass of water versus a tepid glass of the same amount. But it's splitting hairs here. If people think that "hey all I gotta do is drink more ice cold water to burn more calories" we're basically talking the calorie amount to get up off the couch, go the the cupboard, fill the glass of water, drink it and then go back down to sit on the coach. Wouldn't it be just more sensible just to move that amount to equal that glass of water?
    I guess if people want to take every advantage they can to count every calorie they burn, drinking ice cold water would be a small benefit.

    But if they're getting up off the couch, walking to the kitchen, getting a glass of ice water, walking back to the couch and sitting down, wouldn't that *double* the 'burn' (LOL) rather than not having gotten up off the couch at all?

    There might just be something to this after all.

    <runsawayquickly> ;)
    Lol, yes that's true. But then it becomes the obsession of counting every calorie for everything they do. Walking to throw the trash away. Walking to the mailbox. The occasional wiping off of the TV screen, etc. And they get to eat those calories back if they are already in a deficit. :D:D
    I've had (note past tense) quite a few peeps on my fl doing just that. I kept rolling my eyes so hard I was giving myself a brain scan. :)

  • noirelb
    noirelb Posts: 216 Member
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    noirelb wrote: »
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    Any science behind this theory of yours that drinking cold water = measurably increased caloric burn? I'd be interested in reading that, even though the original statement was that drinking water boosts metabolism, which it doesn't.
    He's not incorrect about drinking colder water versus tepid water for more calorie burn. But it's negligible overall in weight loss. Drinking 8 ICE COLD 8 ounce glasses of water a day is about 70 calories burned. The science is there. But it's not boosting metabolic rate.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png



    Yes but 1 grain of rice is about 100 calories - 0.1 Calories (Kilocalories) ... So it unfortunately doesn't make a difference in your actual weight loss.
    Mathematically it does IF they don't eat that extra grain of rice.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png


    LOL! Quite accurate
  • MelanieCN77
    MelanieCN77 Posts: 4,047 Member
    edited July 2017
    I go for 72oz but just for hydration, not weight loss.
  • earlnabby
    earlnabby Posts: 8,171 Member
    edited July 2017
    ninerbuff wrote: »
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    Any science behind this theory of yours that drinking cold water = measurably increased caloric burn? I'd be interested in reading that, even though the original statement was that drinking water boosts metabolism, which it doesn't.
    He's not incorrect about drinking colder water versus tepid water for more calorie burn. But it's negligible overall in weight loss. Drinking 8 ICE COLD 8 ounce glasses of water a day is about 70 calories burned. The science is there. But it's not boosting metabolic rate.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    9285851.png

    Weird fact for the day: hot water poured in your ice cube trays will freeze faster than cold water in the trays.

    (Yes, I know it is off topic but we WERE discussing benefits of cold water over other temps. I have had that bit of trivia in my brain for years and never had an excuse to use it)
  • kristikitter
    kristikitter Posts: 602 Member
    The cool (ha) benefits of water that I have found are:

    - Keeps me hydrated
    - I love the taste
    - Drinking lots seems to ease DOMS for me (could just be imagined)

    AND THE BEST


    - Makes my poop super-smooth B)
  • Ainadan
    Ainadan Posts: 158 Member
    Drink when you are thirsty, unless you are chronically not thirsty and your pee is dark yellow, then you need to watch out. I've noticed carbonated beverages decrease my thirst level in general (not just because I drank the beverage), so if you are having problems, stop drinking that kind of beverage and see if it helps.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    earlnabby wrote: »
    Weird fact for the day: hot water poured in your ice cube trays will freeze faster than cold water in the trays.

    Nope.

    The tiny kernel of truth that lies at the heart of this oft-repeated legend is that water brought to boiling, and then returned to room temperature, can freeze ever so slightly faster than room temperature water that wasn't brought to boiling first.


  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    AngelaHuo wrote: »
    Is this good for weight loss?

    Drinking water has nothing to do with weight loss...keeping hydrated is a healthy thing to do...not everything is about weight loss.

    There is no universally correct amount of water to drink...you just need to keep hydrated which means your urine would be pale yellow to almost clear most of the time. One's hydration needs can vary greatly...a sedentary individual isn't going to need as much hydration as a very active individual. I live in the desert at over a mile high in elevation and I'm pretty active...my hydration needs are going to be greater than someone living at sea level in a more temperate climate who is more or less sedentary...
  • stevencloser
    stevencloser Posts: 8,911 Member
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    That's 40-64 calories THAT ARE ALREADY IN YOUR TDEE. Or do you normally not drink even a single drop of water.
  • Rammer123
    Rammer123 Posts: 679 Member
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    That's 40-64 calories THAT ARE ALREADY IN YOUR TDEE. Or do you normally not drink even a single drop of water.

    Right, but increasing from 64oz to a gallon like OP was talking about, would have the same 40-64 calorie effect. I am not staying everyone has to drink more ice cold water to burn more calories, more just bringing it up to say it has a slight effect and that it does make your body work harder. Just like sitting in a ice bath would cause you to burn more calories, also not advocating sitting in a ice bath to burn more calories, just for recovery.
  • Rammer123
    Rammer123 Posts: 679 Member
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    That's 40-64 calories THAT ARE ALREADY IN YOUR TDEE. Or do you normally not drink even a single drop of water.

    Right, but increasing from 64oz to a gallon like OP was talking about, would have the same 40-64 calorie effect. I am not staying everyone has to drink more ice cold water to burn more calories, more just bringing it up to say it has a slight effect and that it does make your body work harder. Just like sitting in a ice bath would cause you to burn more calories, also not advocating sitting in a ice bath to burn more calories, just for recovery.

    Doing the chicken dance every time you drink water (normal drinking, not excessive) works even better for calories, and it's less likely to cause electrolyte imbalances than drinking a gallon of water.

    A gallon of water will not cause an electrolyte imbalance if you are eating a well balanced diet.
  • Rammer123
    Rammer123 Posts: 679 Member
    noirelb wrote: »
    I tried drinking a lot more water than my usual yesterday... maybe 2litres and I dropped a full pound today so It's definitely going to get rid of the water weight. I then checked out websites about how much I should drink per day and it's apparently around 1 liter per 50lbs! They also say it boosts your metabolism but not sure how much truth is in that. Also, you would have to drink many liters in a short period of time to have water intoxication so I wouldn't worry. I don't think 1 gallon for a 200lbs+ person would be to much but maybe for a small person?
    I'm definitely going to up my water intake!

    Drinking water does not boost your metabolism. Drinking water hydrates you, keeps you regular, helps with muscle repair from exercise and helps flush excess sodium (and the accompanying water retention) from your system. Pretty helpful things in and of themselves, but boosting metabolism isn't one of them. :)

    But it does effect on the amount of calories you burn..... The original definition of a calorie was the amount of energy needed to raise 1 gram of water 1 degree Celsius. Albeit not a crazy amount calories unless you're drinking gallons and gallons of water, it does have an effect.

    It's somewhere between 5 and 8 calories to heat up the cold water to reach your normal body temperature. With drinking a very normal 8 glasses a day, that would put you at 40-64 calories a day. If you are an active individual who drinks a lot of water, that could be 80-128 calories a day from drinking a gallon of cold water a day. Obviously this is not going to make or break you weight loss, but it does have an effect on the amount of calories you burn a day.

    That's 40-64 calories THAT ARE ALREADY IN YOUR TDEE. Or do you normally not drink even a single drop of water.

    Right, but increasing from 64oz to a gallon like OP was talking about, would have the same 40-64 calorie effect. I am not staying everyone has to drink more ice cold water to burn more calories, more just bringing it up to say it has a slight effect and that it does make your body work harder. Just like sitting in a ice bath would cause you to burn more calories, also not advocating sitting in a ice bath to burn more calories, just for recovery.

    Doing the chicken dance every time you drink water (normal drinking, not excessive) works even better for calories, and it's less likely to cause electrolyte imbalances than drinking a gallon of water.

    A gallon of water will not cause an electrolyte imbalance if you are eating a well balanced diet.

    Things like forcing copious amounts of cold water down your throat are very unlikely to stick and do little more than be tedious for a near negligible return.

    Very far from anything I have said.
  • JennJ323
    JennJ323 Posts: 646 Member
    edited July 2017
    I drink a gallon (or close to it a day)... I have a 16oz cup I fill each hour and drink it within that hour (while I'm at work 9-5) so to me it's mindless and easy to do the gallon in one day. I do think it helps, whether it does or not is beyond me, but it helps me to not want to mindlessly snack come 3pm. I also feel like it helps with bloat.. either way I plan to continue drinking water like this. It can't hurt. (once I get home I don't drink too much the rest of the evening, maybe another 16oz)

    And I usually only drink water, except for the occasional adult beverage :)
  • earlnabby
    earlnabby Posts: 8,171 Member
    edited July 2017
    Mr_Knight wrote: »
    earlnabby wrote: »
    Weird fact for the day: hot water poured in your ice cube trays will freeze faster than cold water in the trays.

    Nope.

    The tiny kernel of truth that lies at the heart of this oft-repeated legend is that water brought to boiling, and then returned to room temperature, can freeze ever so slightly faster than room temperature water that wasn't brought to boiling first.


    It was demonstrated on a science TV show (Newton's Apple IIRC). Had nothing to do with boiling or not it was about the convection created by the large temp difference when you put the trays of hot water in the freezer.
  • ccrdragon
    ccrdragon Posts: 3,374 Member
    earlnabby wrote: »
    Mr_Knight wrote: »
    earlnabby wrote: »
    Weird fact for the day: hot water poured in your ice cube trays will freeze faster than cold water in the trays.

    Nope.

    The tiny kernel of truth that lies at the heart of this oft-repeated legend is that water brought to boiling, and then returned to room temperature, can freeze ever so slightly faster than room temperature water that wasn't brought to boiling first.


    It was demonstrated on a science TV show (Newton's Apple IIRC). Had nothing to do with boiling or not it was about the convection created by the large temp difference when you put the trays of hot water in the freezer.

    Actually true - the hot water releases energy (in the form of heat) quicker and thus freezes quicker.
  • WickAndArtoo
    WickAndArtoo Posts: 773 Member
    I drink a gallon (or close to it a day)... I have a 16oz cup I fill each hour and drink it within that hour (while I'm at work 9-5) so to me it's mindless and easy to do the gallon in one day. I do think it helps, whether it does or not is beyond me, but it helps me to not want to mindlessly snack come 3pm. I also feel like it helps with bloat.. either way I plan to continue drinking water like this. It can't hurt. (once I get home I don't drink too much the rest of the evening, maybe another 16oz)

    And I usually only drink water, except for the occasional adult beverage :)

    I am like you, I generally just drink around a gallon a day and it's normal for me. Also like you I only drink water, sometimes I'll have coffee, tea, or kombucha as a treat but 99% of the time I am a water drinker. I've never been much of a snacker, but I have always been a water drinker so maybe that's why. :smile:
This discussion has been closed.