Weight trend app and flying
Amerek412
Posts: 74 Member
I weight daily and use a weight trend app. I'm flying to San Diego today, and will be returning Wednesday. I know flying can cause you to retain water for a few days due to the pressure change, so I know my weight will be off for a little bit after I get back. My question is whether I should skip logging my weight all together for this week, since I'm worried if I do, it'll cause my trend line to be inaccurate. I've only been logging for 2 months, so I do feel like a week of "incorrect" weight is significant enough to skew the data. I also don't exactly like the idea of just not logging for a week because, well I don't know...habit, OCD about there being a gap, or maybe that could skew the data as well?
For those of you who use a weight trending app, do you log everyday (or as frequently as what's normal for you) no matter what, or do you skip days you know your weight is off for a specific reason?
For those of you who use a weight trending app, do you log everyday (or as frequently as what's normal for you) no matter what, or do you skip days you know your weight is off for a specific reason?
0
Replies
-
I still log them.... the trend line levels out after around 14 days (I use Happy Scale). I know that it is fluid retention but it is still reality just like when I eat sodium heavy meals I still log.0
-
I don't weigh on vacation, but go back to my normal every morning weigh-in as soon as I get back.0
-
Most important thing - don't worry about it or overthink it.
For example:
I just started weighing daily and using trend app bit over a month ago just out of interest. Surprisingly, i find it helps to keep me better accountable.
However, i will fly abroad for a week next month for a work thing. And while there, everything will be total mess.
First - there will be no scale there, so no weighing.
Second - i know that while there i will probably move more than at home, but i will very likely also eat lot more, and i will eat mostly stuff i can only eyeball and guess the caloric content. Still, i won't worry about it, since it is only a week.
When i'm back i will weigh daily again, trend will smooth over after some time.1 -
I'd log every day.
I don't view the trend line on the app I use to be anything other than casually informational. I don't even pay attention to any future prediction lines. I just like to see the overall trend from past weights.0 -
Go ahead and log it-- it won't skew the trend that much. Look at it with curiosity... "hmm, I wonder what flying does to my weight trend" rather than worry of "this is going to ruin the trend"1
-
-
I think the thing that will skew your results is weighing on a different scale while you're away from home.
0 -
I'd log it. It's just data, and you know what's going on.
It sounds like you're thinking if the trend line as somehow your true weight. It's not. It's a statistical artifact. I suspect that what you really care about is fat vs. lean. The water weight is neither. And all of them fluctuate constantly, anyway. Literally, constantly. IMO, we don't even have a "true weight", just a general current range, and a longer-term trend.
Don't give data or statistical artifacts any more importance than they deserve. Log it, learn from it, go on with life.
(I use Libra. I weigh every day, if I have access to a scale. I log it. Before Libra, for many years, even before trying to lose weight, I weighed myself daily and made a dot on graph paper for that date/weight. At this point, I have years (10? 15?) of data, an extremely thorough understanding of how my weight fluctuates and why, and no particular stress about any of that. )2 -
It will be fun to see how fast the line goes back down to normal. Some apps allow you to change the #days reflected in the trend line.1
-
Ugh. Please don't be disrespectful to people who actually have OCD by saying "OCD about there being a gap"...that's not OCD and you're on a health/wellness website. That's a doubt, anal retentiveness, peculiarly, etc.2
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions