Halo Top vs Enlightened?

HvymetalMG

I'm curious if anyone has tried both of these protein ice creams and which one you all prefer?

I find Enlightened to be much closer to the real thing. And the macros are pretty decent. It helps my sweet cravings.

What do you guys prefer?

chocolate_owl

Depends on the flavor, but overall I find Enlightened has a slightly better texture (after it's softened a bit). It's usually cheaper and goes on sale more often at my grocery store, so that's a driving factor for what I stock up on.

Still, can't beat the real thing sometimes. I'll make room for Talenti if I really want it.

jordandills

I prefer Halo Top for the texture. My Halo Top can soften pretty well within 10 minutes, but when I tried Enlightened I had to let it sit for 20+ before it was even scoopable.

Kimblesnbits13

I posted this same thread haha

http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10516658/halo-top-vs-enlightened-ice-cream-pints#latest

Kimblesnbits13

I posted this same thread haha

http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10516658/halo-top-vs-enlightened-ice-cream-pints/p1

EHollander89

I buy both. Enlightened seems to have a bit higher calories. I think Enlightened is creamier and has better added pieces like their cookie dough bites. I usually get what is on sale since both are somewhat pricey. I love the plain vanilla bean Halo Top the best, but Enlightened has butter pecan. Yummy!