New BMI

ALG775
ALG775 Posts: 247 Member
edited 1:42AM in Health and Weight Loss
Have you heard about the new BMI scale? It is specifically for very short and very tall people.
http://www.healthyweightforum.org/eng/calculators/new-bmi/
I like it-as the weight I seemed to have settles with so far is 24.6 on the new BMI and 25.8 on the old BMI!

I'm not too concerned about BMI, but thought it was interesting.
«1

Replies

  • SCoil123
    SCoil123 Posts: 2,111 Member
    It only changes mine by 0.1
  • ALG775
    ALG775 Posts: 247 Member
    For people of average height, there is little to no change.
  • JessicaMcB
    JessicaMcB Posts: 1,503 Member
    edited October 2017
    This one dives me .5 and takes me from healthy on the old scale to underweight on the new.
  • fiddletime
    fiddletime Posts: 1,868 Member
    I'm short and the new one added 0.8 to my BMI.
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,486 Member
    Shortie here too. From 19.3 old to 20.1 new.
    Makes no difference to me, I like what I weigh.

    Don't quite get the new one. Is it being applied anywhere but the site it is on, Insurance companies etc?

    Cheers, h.
  • Graelwyn75
    Graelwyn75 Posts: 4,404 Member
    Eh, new one makes my BMI 17.9. Old one, 18.3.
  • SafioraLinnea
    SafioraLinnea Posts: 628 Member
    If I'm choosing I will keep my old one. This one adds 0.7 of a point of BMI to my current one.
  • stanmann571
    stanmann571 Posts: 5,727 Member
    Zero credibility. Conflates Obese 30.1-35 w/ Morbidly obese 35.1+
  • Tacklewasher
    Tacklewasher Posts: 7,122 Member
    stanmann571 wrote: »
    Zero credibility. Conflates Obese 30.1-35 w/ Morbidly obese 35.1+

    Use this one then

    https://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/trefethen/bmi_calc.html

    Doesn't have the same glitch.

    But I am curious is there is any narrative/study to go along with the calculators.
  • Mouse_Potato
    Mouse_Potato Posts: 1,511 Member
    According to this, I could lose all the way down to 101 pounds and still be at a healthy weight. :worried:
  • estherdragonbat
    estherdragonbat Posts: 5,283 Member

    eliciaobrien1 wrote: »
    Wanh, I just left obese with the old one and the new one just threw me back in. Rude.

    Same. And here I was, patting myself on the back for finally sliding out of 'obese' and into 'overweight' this week.

    *kicks new calculation*. Might come back to it when I'm further into the new range.
  • kristen8000
    kristen8000 Posts: 747 Member
    This takes me down to 20 even, and the old system I'm 20.7. But, it takes my 5'4", 155lb Mom even more Overweight...and honestly, she's not. She wears the same size clothes as I do at 5'11, and 148. I'm pretty sure she has steal bones...LOL
  • heybales
    heybales Posts: 18,842 Member
    Great, take tool meant for population groups and misused by insurance and medical fields, and try to improve it for their use.

    I've got this knife I keep reaching for to use a screwdriver because it's close at hand - I guess it would be good to file a flat edge on it.
  • kgirlhart
    kgirlhart Posts: 5,162 Member
    I'm short and it raised me from 21.1 to 21.6.
  • mph323
    mph323 Posts: 3,565 Member
    Wow, at 5'3" I could go down to 99 lbs. and still have a BMI of 18.0 :o It pushed my current BMI up 0.5 points. I have a narrow frame and small bones and I would still look emaciated at that weight. Just, no.
  • Mouse_Potato
    Mouse_Potato Posts: 1,511 Member
    mph323 wrote: »
    Wow, at 5'3" I could go down to 99 lbs. and still have a BMI of 18.0 :o It pushed my current BMI up 0.5 points. I have a narrow frame and small bones and I would still look emaciated at that weight. Just, no.

    Yep. That was my point as well. I mean, I weighed 120 in my profile picture. Does anyone seriously believe I had 20 extra pounds to jettison?
  • ShaDucky
    ShaDucky Posts: 67 Member
    It added .9 to my BMI.....Yuck!
  • PaulaWallaDingDong
    PaulaWallaDingDong Posts: 4,641 Member
    It boosted me from 24.8 standard to 25.5 new at 5'3". I'm ultimately shooting for mid-range anyway so it won't make much of a difference at that point.
  • rheddmobile
    rheddmobile Posts: 6,840 Member
    I'd like to see how it correlates to health outcomes before passing judgement. It drops me .3 which is nice, but I'm skeptical, particularly since it doesn't differentiate between men and women, who have different sized bones.
  • leggup
    leggup Posts: 2,942 Member
    I'm tall as heck. (6 ft)
    Current Weight- Standard: 23.0 New: 22.1 (Difference: 0.9)
    Goal Weight- Standard: 19.7 New: 18.9 (Difference: 0.8)

  • MoveitlikeManda
    MoveitlikeManda Posts: 846 Member
    I don't like this, it added 1.1 on to mine :'(
  • ISweat4This
    ISweat4This Posts: 653 Member
    I'm still in the healthy range.
  • hydechildcare
    hydechildcare Posts: 142 Member
    .9 off of mine! I like that from obese to overweight. Now to get to normal
  • singingflutelady
    singingflutelady Posts: 8,736 Member
    Only .2 off from 18.7 to 18.5. I'm 5'8
  • maybyn
    maybyn Posts: 233 Member
    mph323 wrote: »
    Wow, at 5'3" I could go down to 99 lbs. and still have a BMI of 18.0 :o It pushed my current BMI up 0.5 points. I have a narrow frame and small bones and I would still look emaciated at that weight. Just, no.

    Isn't 18.0 underweight? Healthy weight is 18.5 - 25.
  • BootyfulBikerZX10r
    BootyfulBikerZX10r Posts: 72 Member
    when I go off just height and weight it says Im like 50% but at the gym my trainers tell me Im 41% I can never trust these calculators.
  • mph323
    mph323 Posts: 3,565 Member
    maybyn wrote: »
    mph323 wrote: »
    Wow, at 5'3" I could go down to 99 lbs. and still have a BMI of 18.0 :o It pushed my current BMI up 0.5 points. I have a narrow frame and small bones and I would still look emaciated at that weight. Just, no.

    Isn't 18.0 underweight? Healthy weight is 18.5 - 25.

    You're right - 18.5 is 102 lbs. On the old chart my lowest healthy weight is 105 lbs.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories