DX2JX2 wrote: » How about some advice about how to choose a good personal trainer? What kind of questions should we ask? What should we look for? In my experience, it's easier to find a really bad personal trainer than it is to find a good one. It seems like the only qualification you need to become a trainer is to know how to get to the gym.
jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...).
Packerjohn wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). To be honest, for the vast majority of people the typical trainer will be working with, macro splits following the USDA My Plate guidelines and appropriate amounts of micro-nutrients and calories will be fine. For most people a trainer will be working with the idea of different splits for different goals is majoring in the minors. The certifications of most trainers don't allow them to give specific individualized diet advice to clients.
rybo wrote: » DX2JX2 wrote: » How about some advice about how to choose a good personal trainer? What kind of questions should we ask? What should we look for? In my experience, it's easier to find a really bad personal trainer than it is to find a good one. It seems like the only qualification you need to become a trainer is to know how to get to the gym. It also helps to know your specific goals. Be honest and upfront with the person potentially training you. Find out if they have worked with people who had similar goals and situations.
RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat.
jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat. Agreed. Nothing is one-size-fits-all in the fitness world. I wouldn’t necessarily agree though that your macro ratios would be that different from an individual having genetic similarities and wanting to reach the same goal. You may eat different types of foods but you need a similar macro/micro nutrient profile to achieve similar results on the same workout program. If your macro/micro profiles are identical and your workout programs are the same and you’re seeing variations in your results then that’s the sign there’s is a genetic variation to how the body may react whether it be to the foods they eat or to the training they are doing. There are so many things that can vary in the human body though and that is why it is so important to keep logs of dieting and training.
jasonlh515 wrote: » Packerjohn wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). To be honest, for the vast majority of people the typical trainer will be working with, macro splits following the USDA My Plate guidelines and appropriate amounts of micro-nutrients and calories will be fine. For most people a trainer will be working with the idea of different splits for different goals is majoring in the minors. The certifications of most trainers don't allow them to give specific individualized diet advice to clients. Providing nutritional advice is a dependent upon the state’s statute and if there is a defined scope of practice for nutritional care. Giving full nutritional programs to individuals, even in states where there is not a defined scope of practice, is extremely risky for the trainer and the individual involved. Unless your trainer is licensed as a dietician they should not be giving you macro breakdowns with a specific meal plan IMO. Sharing general knowledge is fine but prescribing any kind of diet plan should really be off limits for your client’s protection as well as your own. I personally think of myself as a very knowledgeable person when it comes to nutrition and have spent hundreds, if not thousands, of hours researching about nutrition, but I do not sell or prescribe any kind of nutritional care even though it is legal here in Texas without without being a licensed dietician. I think if you find a personal trainer that is not licensed trying to sell you dieting programs they are either money hungry or naive to think they are qualified enough to provide that kind of care. 99.9% are not qualified to give you that kind of advice and I would avoid if I were you.
RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat. Agreed. Nothing is one-size-fits-all in the fitness world. I wouldn’t necessarily agree though that your macro ratios would be that different from an individual having genetic similarities and wanting to reach the same goal. You may eat different types of foods but you need a similar macro/micro nutrient profile to achieve similar results on the same workout program. If your macro/micro profiles are identical and your workout programs are the same and you’re seeing variations in your results then that’s the sign there’s is a genetic variation to how the body may react whether it be to the foods they eat or to the training they are doing. There are so many things that can vary in the human body though and that is why it is so important to keep logs of dieting and training. Take your example goal of fat loss. Identical twins with a high body fat % Each has a TDEE of 2000, Twin A achieves satiety with a moderate protein, higher fat diet. Twin B with higher fibre carbohydrate diet. Why would you give them the same macro split? Fat loss comes from reducing your calories below your TDEE not from set macros.
jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat. Agreed. Nothing is one-size-fits-all in the fitness world. I wouldn’t necessarily agree though that your macro ratios would be that different from an individual having genetic similarities and wanting to reach the same goal. You may eat different types of foods but you need a similar macro/micro nutrient profile to achieve similar results on the same workout program. If your macro/micro profiles are identical and your workout programs are the same and you’re seeing variations in your results then that’s the sign there’s is a genetic variation to how the body may react whether it be to the foods they eat or to the training they are doing. There are so many things that can vary in the human body though and that is why it is so important to keep logs of dieting and training. Take your example goal of fat loss. Identical twins with a high body fat % Each has a TDEE of 2000, Twin A achieves satiety with a moderate protein, higher fat diet. Twin B with higher fibre carbohydrate diet. Why would you give them the same macro split? Fat loss comes from reducing your calories below your TDEE not from set macros. It depends. Are they achieving the same level of results with a different macro split? While satiety can help reduce their overall calorie intake, it doesn’t necessarily mean they’re going to achieve the same level of results or are receiving the same overall health benefits. Satiety is not the only important factor to consider. A sustainable plan that keeps your client feeling good in many different aspects is what is needed. Keeping their energy levels high, hormones stable, and the rest of the body functioning as well as possible should always be the end goal. Clients can see great results quickly with low carb diets but, as we know now, extremities with low carb/fat diets can have negative effects on the body when continued over a long period of time making it an unsustainable plan. With that said, satiety is a very important thing for clients who struggle against urges to resist eating too much. It may be a good plan to start them out differently because of that, but I think gradually you’d want to work them towards an identical macro pallet.
stanmann571 wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat. Agreed. Nothing is one-size-fits-all in the fitness world. I wouldn’t necessarily agree though that your macro ratios would be that different from an individual having genetic similarities and wanting to reach the same goal. You may eat different types of foods but you need a similar macro/micro nutrient profile to achieve similar results on the same workout program. If your macro/micro profiles are identical and your workout programs are the same and you’re seeing variations in your results then that’s the sign there’s is a genetic variation to how the body may react whether it be to the foods they eat or to the training they are doing. There are so many things that can vary in the human body though and that is why it is so important to keep logs of dieting and training. Take your example goal of fat loss. Identical twins with a high body fat % Each has a TDEE of 2000, Twin A achieves satiety with a moderate protein, higher fat diet. Twin B with higher fibre carbohydrate diet. Why would you give them the same macro split? Fat loss comes from reducing your calories below your TDEE not from set macros. It depends. Are they achieving the same level of results with a different macro split? While satiety can help reduce their overall calorie intake, it doesn’t necessarily mean they’re going to achieve the same level of results or are receiving the same overall health benefits. Satiety is not the only important factor to consider. A sustainable plan that keeps your client feeling good in many different aspects is what is needed. Keeping their energy levels high, hormones stable, and the rest of the body functioning as well as possible should always be the end goal. Clients can see great results quickly with low carb diets but, as we know now, extremities with low carb/fat diets can have negative effects on the body when continued over a long period of time making it an unsustainable plan. With that said, satiety is a very important thing for clients who struggle against urges to resist eating too much. It may be a good plan to start them out differently because of that, but I think gradually you’d want to work them towards an identical macro pallet. Yes, this is the definition of Satiety.
jasonlh515 wrote: » stanmann571 wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: » jasonlh515 wrote: » I’ll open it with macro ratios. Based on your personal experience what works best for each different type of goals (lean muscle mass, strength, maintain, fat loss, etc...). Surely this would be dependant on the client not just the goal. Macros aren't a one thing suits all. I can have the same goal as the next person but my macro preference could be very different depending on what I find filling or just what I like to eat. Agreed. Nothing is one-size-fits-all in the fitness world. I wouldn’t necessarily agree though that your macro ratios would be that different from an individual having genetic similarities and wanting to reach the same goal. You may eat different types of foods but you need a similar macro/micro nutrient profile to achieve similar results on the same workout program. If your macro/micro profiles are identical and your workout programs are the same and you’re seeing variations in your results then that’s the sign there’s is a genetic variation to how the body may react whether it be to the foods they eat or to the training they are doing. There are so many things that can vary in the human body though and that is why it is so important to keep logs of dieting and training. Take your example goal of fat loss. Identical twins with a high body fat % Each has a TDEE of 2000, Twin A achieves satiety with a moderate protein, higher fat diet. Twin B with higher fibre carbohydrate diet. Why would you give them the same macro split? Fat loss comes from reducing your calories below your TDEE not from set macros. It depends. Are they achieving the same level of results with a different macro split? While satiety can help reduce their overall calorie intake, it doesn’t necessarily mean they’re going to achieve the same level of results or are receiving the same overall health benefits. Satiety is not the only important factor to consider. A sustainable plan that keeps your client feeling good in many different aspects is what is needed. Keeping their energy levels high, hormones stable, and the rest of the body functioning as well as possible should always be the end goal. Clients can see great results quickly with low carb diets but, as we know now, extremities with low carb/fat diets can have negative effects on the body when continued over a long period of time making it an unsustainable plan. With that said, satiety is a very important thing for clients who struggle against urges to resist eating too much. It may be a good plan to start them out differently because of that, but I think gradually you’d want to work them towards an identical macro pallet. Yes, this is the definition of Satiety. Satiety is the feeling or condition of being full. Just because you’re reaching a state of feeling full doesn’t mean you’re balanced with the correct macro/micro nutrients for your body.
A sustainable plan that keeps your client feeling good in many different aspects is what is needed. Keeping their energy levels high, hormones stable, and the rest of the body functioning as well as possible should always be the end goal.