Diet drinks

kerrbear2017

Hey all. I am trying to lose weight by eating fewer carbs and sugars. People I know are always giving me diet advice, and although I know they mean well, they are themselves heavy most of the time. I realize that diet coke is probably not the healthiest choice, but considering that I am transitioning to a low carb sugar free diet I think once in a while is probably not too bad. I mean like once or twice a week at the most. What I am getting at is I need to lose weight, and the more restrictions I put in my diet the harder it is. I was an ethical vegetarian, but due to my pre diabetes and sleep apnea I stopped restricting my animal protein intake because I don't need to make things more challenging than they already are. And I recently stopped smoking cigs, and I wonder if diet soda is as bad as smoking? Seriously, because that's how people I know act when they see me drinking diet coke, as though I am committing a mortal sin. Any thoughts??

seltzermint555

A lot of people really overreact about the diet soda thing. Just my opinion.

As for personal experiences. I've lost over 130 lb and maintaining that for several years now. I won't go into the carbs/sugars discussion because I'm no expert and honestly never paid a whole lot of attention to that beyond trying to stay within my MFP-set guidelines for both (and sodium). When I was obese for years, I didn't like water. I didn't drink water very often at all. I drank coffee and/or juice in the morning, a 12 oz can of diet soda with lunch and a 12 oz can of diet soda with dinner. That's literally all I drank in a typical day. I had a lot of problems with migraines and I believe it was a combination of higher than average blood pressure and dehydration, because it's been years since I've had a migraine. When I started getting serious about health & weight loss, I started adding in as much water as I could and it wasn't easy to make myself drink it. Now I drink water from dawn til dusk and that feels normal to me and I don't have to rush to the restroom all the time, either...a lot of my friends/relatives watch me drinking water and complain that they would have to go every 15 minutes if they drank water so much, but I think your body will usually adjust to it.

Maybe you already drink a ton of water and that has nothing to do with what you posted about. haha sorry!

ANYWAY! I do still drink diet soda. About 3 cans a week. We have it at work in the fridge and once in awhile I'll grab a diet Mountain Dew as an afternoon pick me up. At home, we buy a 12 pack once a month and between me and my husband, we always finish it - I like it with certain meals, like homemade veggie pizza. It just hits the spot to me, taste wise. No ill effects that I have noticed. I haven't studied up on artificial sweeteners, and I know a lot of people think they are the devil, but I tend to view it like anything else...don't go crazy with it, use moderation...

GREAT decision to stop smoking btw...I know you already realize it is, but that's awesome!!

Unknown

This content has been removed.

bioklutz

NO - diet soda is not bad for you. Some people have sensitivities to artificial sweeteners but that doesn't make it bad for everyone. My preference is diet a&w root beer. I could easily drink a liter of it everyday.

Concentrate on tackling pre-diabetes and smoking. Once that is under control if you really feel that it is important to cut out diet soda work on that. To be honest though - 2 diet cokes a week is hardly anything to be worried about. If you enjoy it I wouldn't give it up.

Dani9585

I typically drink 1-3 cans of caffeine-free Diet Coke per day, when it's in the house. I log it, despite being 0cals. It's a part of my self-care routine. Regular Diet Coke was interfering with my sleep.

Ignore what others say (easier said than done) and enjoy your treat!

musickfit

I definitely agree with the others, tackle the bigger rocks first. Once you have those under control, it's easer to consider things like gut health and inflammation.

That being said, I definitely disagree that they aren't "bad" for you. As someone who consumed her fair share of artificial sweeteners, I can tell you it has eventually had a really disruptive effect on my gut health to the point where I had to eliminate all sweeteners for a long time to heal my gut and then reintroduce them.

However, I was consuming mass quantities of artificial sugar in everything: drinks, syrup, supplements, protein waffle mix, protein bars, and coffee daily. It sounds like you have it under control if you're only talking a couple times a week.

cheyennerufer

You should research The Truth About Cancer. They have some interesting data and information about aspartame and excitotoxins and their effects on the body.