I'm debating on keto
xlinaxmx
Posts: 11 Member
Hey!
So like everyone else .... I'm amazed by people on keto. They loose so much. I'm trying to basically loose baby weight. Prior to baby I was a vegan and I don't plan on being vegan anymore. (If that helps sway your decision)
I originally was on a strict Cal's In Cal's out low fat healthy eating diet and I went from 210 to 193 in about a month and a half.. lets just say two. My friend lost like 25 on keto I the same about of time and she dosent even work out. (I do )
So my question is for long term and matinance, what is the best diet? Once I get my goal (120) I don't want to gain again. So I feel like keto isn't something I should do for life. Should I just stick to a low carb, low fat, no processed foods like I was ? Or should I do keto until I'm at my goal.
My issue with keto is keeping it up once I hit goal
Traveling with keto (I travel a lot and clean eating is eaiser imo)
I have a family history of heart problems and diabetes, so keto honestly scares me.
I feel like a crave more junk food on keto. On a clean diet I can have a sugar craving and just eat an apple or banana and feel like I've had my "sweet" keto I just can't.
I really like black beans lol (no beans on keto)
Thanks !
So like everyone else .... I'm amazed by people on keto. They loose so much. I'm trying to basically loose baby weight. Prior to baby I was a vegan and I don't plan on being vegan anymore. (If that helps sway your decision)
I originally was on a strict Cal's In Cal's out low fat healthy eating diet and I went from 210 to 193 in about a month and a half.. lets just say two. My friend lost like 25 on keto I the same about of time and she dosent even work out. (I do )
So my question is for long term and matinance, what is the best diet? Once I get my goal (120) I don't want to gain again. So I feel like keto isn't something I should do for life. Should I just stick to a low carb, low fat, no processed foods like I was ? Or should I do keto until I'm at my goal.
My issue with keto is keeping it up once I hit goal
Traveling with keto (I travel a lot and clean eating is eaiser imo)
I have a family history of heart problems and diabetes, so keto honestly scares me.
I feel like a crave more junk food on keto. On a clean diet I can have a sugar craving and just eat an apple or banana and feel like I've had my "sweet" keto I just can't.
I really like black beans lol (no beans on keto)
Thanks !
5
Replies
-
The best diet is the one you're going to stick to. If you don't think you can do keto long term, then it might not be for you. The additional weight your friend lost (and you lost a GOOD amount of weight in the first two months anyway!) is additional water weight due to the depletion of glycogen stores by cutting carbs.16
-
I would pick a way of eating that you can do for the rest of you life.5
-
From the sounds of what you like foodwise Keto may not be your best option. Just use the calorie allotment MFP gives you and you can eat whatever you want as long as you remain in a calorie deficit.6
-
I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.10 -
I’m on keto and it’s worked so well for me that I’m fine with being on it for life. Type 2 diabetes runs in my family and I’ve got a sweet tooth; it was only ever going to be a matter of time before a doctor told me I had to go on something like it, anyway.
My husband travels for work and has struggled a lot more with keto than I did, but he also had a much healthier relationship with food to start with and didn’t “need” it. He can eat some junk food and then go back to normal; I never could. So I just don’t eat it, and my treats have become things like berries, small amounts of pineapple, and chocolate so bitter I wouldn’t have even wanted it before. Now it tastes amazing. And I can eat the “right” amount and put the rest away and not obsess about it until I cave and eat it all.
BTW I do occasionally eat a couple of tablespoons of black beans from my grocery store’s salad bar, paired with enough non-carb calories to stay in ketosis. Because black beans are awesome.
So it really kind of depends on what you’re looking for in a way of eating. It sounds, frankly, like yours is working fine for you; you just wish it were faster. When you’re at your goal weight, will it really bother you if it took you a few months longer than your friend? I mean, speed in and of itself isn’t that big of a deal in the long run.6 -
100_PROOF_ wrote: »I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.
Exactlyyyyy I totally don't. I can tell you anything and everything you want to know about being a vegan but keto I have no idea. I talked to the dietician local to me but she wasn't very helpful nor my trainer ( which I think I may replace for a bunch of reasons). Like I just want something I can keep for life that is healthy and manageable.... That's not vegan lol. I've come to like chicken lol0 -
The best diet is the one you're going to stick to. If you don't think you can do keto long term, then it might not be for you. The additional weight your friend lost (and you lost a GOOD amount of weight in the first two months anyway!) is additional water weight due to the depletion of glycogen stores by cutting carbs.
I was thinking after reading more that it was just water weight too. And thank you!2 -
Keto works very well for many people. But for many of those people, they don't really know why it works. They think it works because carbs and fat. But for those that lose weight on it, it's because they are creating a deficit in energy balance. That's the only thing that works. Keto is a method, but its results depend on the same energy balance deficit that any other weight loss program has.
But the truth about how it really works is often masked by all the "amazing" anecdotes. There is a ton of money to be made by masking the truth. The funny thing is - the ketogenic diet works just fine with a deficit, but that's not its selling point. Or perhaps better said, the deficit works just fine using the ketogenic method. It's the deficit that works. Always.
If you want to do keto, have at it. Nothing wrong with it. Do some research. Know what to expect. If you go that route, you'll still want to count calories. You can be in ketosis and still gain fat if you are eating too much. It's not magic. It's a method. If you can stick to it, go for it. If you can't, you should expect to put a bunch of water weight (not fat) back on when you stop -even if you continue to eat in a deficit. That's not a bad thing, just beware of it ahead of time.3 -
100_PROOF_ wrote: »I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.
Exactlyyyyy I totally don't. I can tell you anything and everything you want to know about being a vegan but keto I have no idea. I talked to the dietician local to me but she wasn't very helpful nor my trainer ( which I think I may replace for a bunch of reasons). Like I just want something I can keep for life that is healthy and manageable.... That's not vegan lol. I've come to like chicken lol
Were you eating vegan to diet? And now you're looking for another diet to help you lose weight? That's not the point of veganism and trying to find a "diet" to lose weight is not likely to lead you to maintaining your loss.
As others have said, you need to find a way of eating that is sustainable for you.1 -
Keto has worked for me. I lost 40 pounds just counting calories, and was diagnosed T2D after the weight loss because my fasting glucose was "pre-diabetic." I tried the Diabetes Association diet after diagnosis, and my glucose numbers were terrible. I tried the Zone because I had lost weight with that in the 90's, and it was supposed to be good for diabetics. That was better, but my numbers were still too high, and I did not want to increase meds. I tried keto, and almost instantly my glucose numbers were significantly better.
In all this I was watching calories, and I realize this means it is still CICO, but the glucose numbers were the motivator to stay on a keto diet. I qualify as someone with a medical condition, etc.
Since going on the keto diet, I have lost 70 more pounds at the rate of about a pound a week. I am happy with what I am eating, and find it pretty easy to stick to the diet. Energy levels have been good. Eating out can be a challenge, but it is still easy enough.
It is a big adjustment in terms of what you are eating for most people. If you don't have a medical condition that benefits from this specific diet, you might want to ask if it is sustainable. I know it is for me. I am not hungry or craving things I can't have. It took the T2D for me to try keto. I don't think I would have tried it otherwise, but it is a very good WOE for me.
You have to figure out what works for you and do it.5 -
100_PROOF_ wrote: »I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.
Exactlyyyyy I totally don't. I can tell you anything and everything you want to know about being a vegan but keto I have no idea. I talked to the dietician local to me but she wasn't very helpful nor my trainer ( which I think I may replace for a bunch of reasons). Like I just want something I can keep for life that is healthy and manageable.... That's not vegan lol. I've come to like chicken lol
Were you eating vegan to diet? And now you're looking for another diet to help you lose weight? That's not the point of veganism and trying to find a "diet" to lose weight is not likely to lead you to maintaining your loss.
As others have said, you need to find a way of eating that is sustainable for you.
No I was vegan as a life choice but I was way healthy as a result of it. I just no longer want to be vegan and I'm looking for a diet / way of eating that gives me that healthy weight that I can maintain.0 -
100_PROOF_ wrote: »I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.
Exactlyyyyy I totally don't. I can tell you anything and everything you want to know about being a vegan but keto I have no idea. I talked to the dietician local to me but she wasn't very helpful nor my trainer ( which I think I may replace for a bunch of reasons). Like I just want something I can keep for life that is healthy and manageable.... That's not vegan lol. I've come to like chicken lol
Consider this:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10636388/free-customized-personal-weight-loss-eating-plan-not-spam-or-mlm
It's pretty much what I did to lose about 1/3 of my body weight in a bit less than a year, and stay at a healthy weight for 2+ years since.5 -
I just started the keto lifestyle 2 weeks ago, it was hard the first few days with headaches and cravings, but lots of water and tea helped me. I’m doing it as a lifestyle, but of course I’m losing weight, first 2 weeks 12 pounds gone, now I’m more use to it, no hunger, cravings, nothing, just eat when I’m hungry, the Low carbs food, no SUGAR, I’m off the sugar for good. I have no health problem, I’m doing this for me, for my life. I’m feeling happier, in control. Like everyone said, you have to find the diet that you can stick to it for life.3
-
MeMyselfAndI2018 wrote: »I just started the keto lifestyle 2 weeks ago, it was hard the first few days with headaches and cravings, but lots of water and tea helped me. I’m doing it as a lifestyle, but of course I’m losing weight, first 2 weeks 12 pounds gone, now I’m more use to it, no hunger, cravings, nothing, just eat when I’m hungry, the Low carbs food, no SUGAR, I’m off the sugar for good. I have no health problem, I’m doing this for me, for my life. I’m feeling happier, in control. Like everyone said, you have to find the diet that you can stick to it for life.
If this is the best plan for you I hope you are successful for years to come. One thing to note, though, you are still in the evaluation phase of your new plan. I have been on a few diets and the second week does get easier and I am usually feeling pretty good with a nice scale drop from water weight. This is about the point the true fat weight loss begins and it will be slower. The true test for the sustainability of your diet is most probably still ahead of you. My point is I would not be making declarations just yet. Give yourself time.2 -
So I’m on keto and have found it to be a great choice for traveling because avoiding a food group and going for satieting foods is going to naturally restrict what you eat on the go. But to be clear—going on it requires a pretty tough initiation period and you really have to commit to it. I’m sure other diets would be just fine for you, especially if you love black beans! I don’t miss them, though. I feel like i have new taste buds now.0
-
Like others have said, your friend that lost so much weight didn't lose it because of any 'keto magic' (unless you consider water weight and a calorie deficit magic).
I know someone who has lost over 50 lbs with keto, but I also know she eats extremely low calories and does intense workouts almost every day. She's losing weight super fast because she's under eating.
Don't compare yourself to your friend. There's lots of factors that could've gone into her losing more in the same time frame. (Any chance "like 25 lbs" was inflated to make herself sound better?) Faster isn't always better. Focus on you and your journey, and finding a way of eating that will be sustainable long term.1 -
Vegan to keto may be a bit of a shock.3
-
You have to find a way of eating that you can stick to for life, to lose weight and keep it off this is the only way. Anything you do temporarily will lead to temporary loss.
You can't compare anyone elses weight loss to your own, your friend might have needed to lose much more for one thing.1 -
100_PROOF_ wrote: »I mean this in the nicest way possible but sounds like you might lack the knowledge needed to make the decision.
Do you know why your friend initially lost more? It wasn't because keto is magic.
If you have a medical condition that warrants you to restrict your carbs, keto might be a good choice. Otherwise I wouldn't recommend it.
I would personally start to do your own research. Look at reliable sources ( not Fung and all the other quacks. Not magazines or blogs. Real research. Peer reviewed studies might be a good place to start)
You'll find a lot of misinformation about keto and you'll find a lot of people who are very ignorant
( uneducated)about the subject. Don't believe everything you hear and read. Instead learn how to do your own research.
Exactlyyyyy I totally don't. I can tell you anything and everything you want to know about being a vegan but keto I have no idea. I talked to the dietician local to me but she wasn't very helpful nor my trainer ( which I think I may replace for a bunch of reasons). Like I just want something I can keep for life that is healthy and manageable.... That's not vegan lol. I've come to like chicken lol
Don't overthink this. You don't need to be on a named plan to have a healthy manageable diet. It sounds like you have an idea of what's good for you in a general sense, most people do. Simply apply that knowledge. If you like chicken, eat it. It's lean protein. Add some of the vegetables, healthy fats, whole grains, tubers, legumes, and fruit you ate as a vegan. If you like, have some candy or cookies or ice cream every now and then because life is too short to not have dessert.
The most important thing for managing your weight is controlling your caloric intake, and MFP gives you the tools to calculate how many calories you need to eat to do that.
Find some exercise you like to do and do it.
There, you have a healthy eating plan you can sustain for life. Customized for you.3 -
Are you currently tracking macros?
To lose the weight, you simply need a deficit - for me, I prefer higher fat/higher protein so I've adjusted my macros accordingly. My carbs aren't anywhere low enough to be keto, but adjusting my intake allows me to eat the way I prefer and the deficit allows for the fat loss. Like others said, it's best to find a diet you can stick to and comparing results to others and their methods can get exhausting and ultimately, isn't helpful.
Best of luck!3 -
Have you tried just setting up MFP with your stats, activity level, and a reasonable rate of loss for the amount of weight you have to lose? Getting a calorie target from MFP then eating a variety of foods within that calorie target - focusing on foods that provide nutrition, satiety and enjoyment? Logging everything you eat as accurately as possible, ideally using a food scale?
This approach works no matter what type of foods you like or what you feel is better (for you) to restrict.
Vegan, Keto, Clean Eating - those are all personal choices and won't guarantee weight loss if you aren't in a calorie deficit. No particular "diet" offers long term advantages for weight loss, it all comes down to CICO, and finding a way of eating that you find sustainable and enjoyable.
2 -
Hey!
So like everyone else .... I'm amazed by people on keto. They loose so much. I'm trying to basically loose baby weight. Prior to baby I was a vegan and I don't plan on being vegan anymore. (If that helps sway your decision)
I originally was on a strict Cal's In Cal's out low fat healthy eating diet and I went from 210 to 193 in about a month and a half.. lets just say two. My friend lost like 25 on keto I the same about of time and she dosent even work out. (I do )
So my question is for long term and matinance, what is the best diet? Once I get my goal (120) I don't want to gain again. So I feel like keto isn't something I should do for life. Should I just stick to a low carb, low fat, no processed foods like I was ? Or should I do keto until I'm at my goal.
My issue with keto is keeping it up once I hit goal
Traveling with keto (I travel a lot and clean eating is eaiser imo)
I have a family history of heart problems and diabetes, so keto honestly scares me.
I feel like a crave more junk food on keto. On a clean diet I can have a sugar craving and just eat an apple or banana and feel like I've had my "sweet" keto I just can't.
I really like black beans lol (no beans on keto)
Thanks !
You answered your own question. If you don't feel that keto is a long term, realistic and sustainable option for you then why bother? Nothing wrong with experimenting with different plans, but you should be focusing on trying ones that you think you may realistically enjoy doing for the next 50 years (or more).
For what it's worth-I'm a long time maintainer. I enjoy experimenting with different foods/plans etc, but my maintenance plan always revolves around CICO and being mindful of my calorie intake. No matter what I'm doing, this is the foundation 3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions