We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Back at it again: Maintenance or Deficit? Noob Lifter

shrinkingletters
Posts: 1,008 Member
Hi Y'all! I'm not sure if this question should go in this forum or not but here goes:
I'm not new to MFP or how it works. A few years back I used this to successfully lose 30 lbs and get in pretty good shape. I was pretty happy with my appearance and overall fitness and obviously feeling really accomplished. However, life happens: I met my boyfriend, we've been dating about 3 years now, and 25 of those lbs have crept back up.
Now, I'm by no means saddened by my appearance, I actually still feel very positively about my body, and knowing that I want to be able to comfortably live my life without spending every moment of it obsessing about food and calories, I've decided I want to lose again, but a more modest amount, maybe 15 lbs, and see how I feel then.
The thing is, I've recently started a basic lifting program, and I'm REALLY loving it. I'm feeling very accomplished and I love that I get to try to lift more every week. I've been at it for a month and a half and am worried that if I go into a deficit now, I might become discouraged if my lifting suffers for it.
My question is: Should I stick to maintenance for another month or two to really solidify my routine and feel out where I am strengthwise, before starting a deficit to lose weight (I'd obviously still be lifting to preserve muscle as much as I can)? Or should I go straight into a deficit while lifting and do my best not to be discouraged if my strength gains start dropping off?
I am currently 5'4, 155 lbs (and have been holding steady at that weight for the last 2 months while eating at maintenance and lifting). I lift 4x a week, split up into push/pull days with 1 day of light cardio, weekends occasionally including a casual bike ride or a hike. My lowest weight was 127 and I was very lean, but it was a nightmare to keep up, so I would settle for dropping anywhere between 135-140, since I've been that weight before and in pretty good shape.
I'm not new to MFP or how it works. A few years back I used this to successfully lose 30 lbs and get in pretty good shape. I was pretty happy with my appearance and overall fitness and obviously feeling really accomplished. However, life happens: I met my boyfriend, we've been dating about 3 years now, and 25 of those lbs have crept back up.
Now, I'm by no means saddened by my appearance, I actually still feel very positively about my body, and knowing that I want to be able to comfortably live my life without spending every moment of it obsessing about food and calories, I've decided I want to lose again, but a more modest amount, maybe 15 lbs, and see how I feel then.
The thing is, I've recently started a basic lifting program, and I'm REALLY loving it. I'm feeling very accomplished and I love that I get to try to lift more every week. I've been at it for a month and a half and am worried that if I go into a deficit now, I might become discouraged if my lifting suffers for it.
My question is: Should I stick to maintenance for another month or two to really solidify my routine and feel out where I am strengthwise, before starting a deficit to lose weight (I'd obviously still be lifting to preserve muscle as much as I can)? Or should I go straight into a deficit while lifting and do my best not to be discouraged if my strength gains start dropping off?
I am currently 5'4, 155 lbs (and have been holding steady at that weight for the last 2 months while eating at maintenance and lifting). I lift 4x a week, split up into push/pull days with 1 day of light cardio, weekends occasionally including a casual bike ride or a hike. My lowest weight was 127 and I was very lean, but it was a nightmare to keep up, so I would settle for dropping anywhere between 135-140, since I've been that weight before and in pretty good shape.
1
Replies
-
You shouldn't have any problems with increasing strength if you keep your deficit modest.
Lifting is a very small calorie burn and you really shouldn't have any problems with maintaining intensity as long as you don't go for an aggressive deficit.3 -
If you are doing a beginners lifting program (like SL5x5), your increases will drop off at some point anyway. You can’t just add 5# until infinity. But noob gains are a legit thing, so roll with it.
Doing a small cut (-250) should have a very minimal impact on your strength training, especially at the beginning.3 -
You shouldn't have any problems with increasing strength if you keep your deficit modest.
Lifting is a very small calorie burn and you really shouldn't have any problems with maintaining intensity as long as you don't go for an aggressive deficit.If you are doing a beginners lifting program (like SL5x5), your increases will drop off at some point anyway. You can’t just add 5# until infinity. But noob gains are a legit thing, so roll with it.
Doing a small cut (-250) should have a very minimal impact on your strength training, especially at the beginning.
Thanks both of you! I used to be primarily into cardio but towards the end of my weight-loss/right before I met my boyfriend I was trying to get a feel for what lifting could do for me and was starting to appreciate what it was doing for my shape. I'm glad to hear I can do exactly what I need to do without sacrificing my fun time at the gym.3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.6K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.5K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions