Calorie Counter

You are currently viewing the message boards in:

It's official. MFP says "Eating carbs in moderation may help you live longer"

OrphiaOrphia Posts: 6,619Member Member Posts: 6,619Member Member
At the top of my MFP app feed today from the MFP blog:

https://blog.myfitnesspal.com/eating-carbs-in-moderation-may-help-you-live-longer/
While a low-carb diet might be beneficial for weight loss — a 2018 study found overweight dieters who cut their carbohydrate intake lost an average of 13 pounds — cutting carbs could also cut years from your life.

THE LATEST RESEARCH

Two new studies found connections between low-carb diets and premature death. In a study published in The Lancet, researchers followed 15,428 adults and found a connection between carbohydrate consumption and the risk of dying during the 25-year study period.

Moreover, research presented at the 2018 European Society of Cardiology conference reviewed the results of seven studies with 447,506 participants over 15 years and found an association between low-carb diets (defined as fewer than 26% of daily calories from carbohydrates) and an increased risk of premature death, including death from cardiovascular disease and cancer.

Dr. Maciej Banach, professor at the Medical University in Poland explains, “The reduced intake of fiber and fruits and increased intake of animal protein, cholesterol and saturated fat with these diets may play a role [in increased mortality risk].”

THE BIGGEST RISK

The participants who adopted low-carb diets and replaced carbs with animal proteins and fat were at the greatest risk of premature death. In other words, cutting out bread and pasta but eating beef and pork instead is a recipe for health issues.

That’s because it’s not just about adding unhealthy foods but cutting those that are full of nutrients. Joan Salge Blake, RD, clinical associate professor of nutrition at Boston University and author of “Nutrition & You” believes the potential for weight loss leads a lot of dieters to cut carbs but warns, “You end up eliminating a lot of foods like fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts, beans and dairy products — all carbohydrates — that are part of a healthy diet.”

HOW MUCH AND WHAT TYPES OF CARBS SHOULD YOU AIM FOR?

You should get between 45–65% of your daily calories from carbohydrates, according to the U.S. Dietary Guidelines. In fact, in a 16-week study, increasing carbohydrate intake helped participants lower their body mass index, weight, fat mass and insulin resistance.

The Lancet research found the risks of premature death were minimized when filling up on complex carbs from fruits, vegetables and whole grains. “Fad diets often lead people to fear carbohydrates. But the research continues to show healthy carbohydrates are the healthiest fuel for our bodies,” Dr. Hana Kahleova, study author and director of clinical research for the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine explained in a statement.

THE BOTTOM LINE

“A low-carb diet might help you lose weight in the beginning but, over the long-term, there is no benefit and there might even be significant risks,” Blake says. Instead, Blake recommends eating everything in moderation, including carbohydrates, and making sure to opt for complex over refined sources.

It's saying low carb is a fad diet and increases your risk of death.

Debate over, methinks.
«134

Replies

  • nvmomketonvmomketo Posts: 11,410Member Member Posts: 11,410Member Member
    While some might debate this study saying you die sooner with low carb, there are the Blue Zones showing that the longest living populations in the world all have a higher carb intake.

    That's comparing two seprate things, IMO. Apples and oranges.

    People arguing that the average low carbers will not die sooner than the average person on a higher carb diet does not negate the fact that some of the longest lived people live in the blue zones, nor that those people may live the longest due to a variety of factors (not just diet).

  • nvmomketonvmomketo Posts: 11,410Member Member Posts: 11,410Member Member
    nvmomketo wrote: »
    While some might debate this study saying you die sooner with low carb, there are the Blue Zones showing that the longest living populations in the world all have a higher carb intake.

    That's comparing two seprate things, IMO. Apples and oranges.

    People arguing that the average low carbers will not die sooner than the average person on a higher carb diet does not negate the fact that some of the longest lived people live in the blue zones, nor that those people may live the longest due to a variety of factors (not just diet).

    I'm not sure what you're rebutting since I pretty much laid out they were two different things. I'm simply pointing out that longevity seems to correlate with higher carb consumption, among other factors.

    I wasn't trying to imply that Blue Zones had anything to do with showing that low carbing led to people dying sooner, I was just pointing out that there doesn't seem to be evidence that low carbing leads to longevity.

    I guess I did not follow your change of topic, from the study referenced in the Op's linked blog to the unrelated fact that people in the blue zones live the longest.
«134
Sign In or Register to comment.